The old rancher looked as though he had aged twenty years in a single night. His gray hair stood out wild beneath his slouch hat, his flannel shirt was stiff with his dead foreman’s dried blood, and his good right hand gripped a double-barreled ten-gauge shotgun with knuckles that were white as bone.
Beside him, standing on the elevated wooden boardwalk outside the sheriff’s office, was Sheriff Caleb Dunn.
Dunn was fifty, thick-waisted, with an iron-gray mustache and the tired, haunted eyes of an ex-cavalryman who had seen too many frontier massacres. He was wearing his tin star pinned to his buckskin coat, his hands resting heavily on the double buckle of his gun belt as he shouted down at the mob, trying in vain to stem the rising tide of vengeance.
“Hold your horses, Nathaniel!” Dunn’s voice boomed down the frozen street. “You ride up that canyon with a vigilante rope, you’ll start a war the territorial militia can't finish! We wait for the federal marshal from Pueblo!”
“The marshal’s sixty miles south!” Ward roared back, his voice cracked with grief and fury. “By the time he gets his boots on, my herd will be across the reservation line and Bennett will be rotting in the ground! We ride now, or we burn the whole mountain!”
A chorus of savage shouts went up from the ranchers. Lever actions clicked. Men swung into their saddles.
“Hold your fire!” a voice bellowed from the timberline.
The mob froze.
Fifty heads turned toward the north end of the street.
Down the gentle incline of the stage road, riding at a slow, deliberate walk, came the small party.
Josiah rode in the center, his sheepskin coat open to reveal his holstered Colt, his hands resting calmly on Gideon’s pommel. At his right side rode Black Crow, sitting tall and rigid as an iron monument on his painted pony, his face cold and unreadable. At his left rode Ayanna, her red dress blazing like a drop of fresh blood against the snow.
A collective, stunned silence fell over Silver Creek.
For three seconds, nobody moved. The sight of the reclusive mountain hermit riding openly beside the most feared war chief in the territory was so wildly impossible that the ranchers simply stared, their minds refusing to process the image.
Then, Nathaniel Ward raised his shotgun.
“It’s him!” a rancher screamed from the livery door. “It’s Black Crow! He’s come right into town!”
“String the bastard up!” another voice shrieked.
Rifles came up in a ragged, terrifying wave. Thirty gun barrels leveled directly at the riders' chests.
Josiah did not reach for his Winchester. He kicked Gideon forward two paces, placing the broad chestnut shoulder of his gelding directly between the ranchers’ gun sights and Black Crow’s breast.
“Put 'em down!” Josiah’s voice rolled down the frozen street with the booming, parade-ground authority of an infantry officer. “Every last one of you damn fools, lower your iron before you kill the only men who can save this valley!”
Nathaniel Ward took two trembling steps off the boardwalk, the barrels of his ten-gauge shaking with rage. “Get out of the way, Mercer! You’ve gone Indian-lover! He burned my barn! He murdered Bennett!”
“He didn't burn a damn thing, Nathaniel!” Josiah roared back, reining Gideon in twenty feet from the old rancher. “Black Crow was five miles north in Widow’s Canyon when your place took fire! His own winter lodges were burning at the exact same hour!”
The crowd murmured, the certainty of their fury wavering against the raw conviction in Josiah’s face.
Sheriff Dunn stepped off the boardwalk, his hand dropping to the butt of his Colt. “Mercer, you better have more than your word for this. Bennett’s lying on my office floor with a three-foot ash arrow through his ribs.”
Josiah reached into his coat and produced the arrow he had pulled from the post where Ayanna had hung. He hurled it down into the frozen mud at Dunn’s boots.
“Look at the shaft, Caleb!” Josiah shouted. “Look at the fletching! That’s northern ash turned on an industrial lathe! It’s the same arrows Granite Ridge Consolidated bought two weeks ago at the freight depot in Pueblo! Black Crow cuts his shafts from mountain chokecherry with a flint knife!”
Dunn frowned, stooping slowly to pick up the arrow. His weathered fingers traced the straight, machine-turned grain of the wood.
Before the sheriff could speak, the double doors of the Silver Creek Saloon swung wide.
Stepping out onto the boardwalk, flanked by four heavily armed men wearing tailored gray broadcloth coats, was Captain Edmund Voss.
He was freshly shaved, his gray mustache neatly waxed, smelling of bay rum and expensive tobacco. Behind him, looking pale, terrified, and bandaged around the shoulder, walked a young drifter named Peter Clay.
Voss looked at Josiah, then at Black Crow, and finally down at the crowd of armed ranchers.
He smiled—a wide, confident, predatory smile that made Josiah’s blood run cold.
“Well, Sheriff Dunn,” Voss said smoothly, adjusting the beaver-fur lapels of his coat. “It appears the suspects have saved you the trouble of tracking them through the drifts.”
Chapter 15: The Sheriff’s Scale
The frozen street of Silver Creek became a deadfall trap.
Voss took three measured steps down the boardwalk steps, his polished boots clicking sharply against the frost-caked pine planks. His four mercenaries fanned out behind him, their Winchester carbines held at the low ready, their eyes sweeping the crowd with professional, cold disdain.
“You’re out of your jurisdiction, Mercer,” Voss said, his tone carrying the polite condescension of an officer addressing a delinquent private. “And you are in the company of hostile combatants accused of capital crimes against territorial citizens.”
“Shut your mouth, Voss,” Josiah said, his voice flat and level as a drawn blade.
Nathaniel Ward looked back and forth between the two men, his breath coming in ragged, white gasps. “Mercer... you know this man?”
“I know him,” Josiah said, never taking his eyes off Voss’s face. “I knew him in Tennessee when he was stealing army rations from dying soldiers. And I know him now as the representative of Granite Ridge Consolidated—the company that’s trying to steal your ranch, Ward, and every drop of water on Black Timber Creek.”