years of being gone.
He raised his head. He looked at the chief, and past him at the daughter, and
he answered in the open, before the fire, where all three camps could hear
him.
"Then I'll answer it in the open, Chief. The blood is from a camp on the Rio
Puerco, three winters ago —"
He told it the way he had rehearsed it in a hundred empty camps, except that
in the rehearsals there had never been listeners, and the listeners changed the
19
weight of every word. Micah Thorne sat on the hide the council had given
him, close enough to the fire that the heat worked at the front of his shins
through his worn trousers, and he told the whole of it in the grammar of a
report, because a report was the only grammar he owned that could carry
what he had to carry.
Three winters ago, the winter of seventy-one, he had been a sergeant of
scouts attached to a column out of Fort Stanton, riding courier and point for a
captain whose name he did not give the fire, because the captain was dead of
fever the following spring and the dead could not correct him. The column
had orders to punish a raiding band that had lifted stock along the Rio Puerco
and killed a herder. The identification of the band — which camp, which
people, which fires — had come from a civilian guide named Petr Hasek, a
Moravian who had trapped the Puerco country in his youth and spoke four
tongues and was paid by the head. Fifty dollars a warrior. Micah said the
figure plainly and watched no face, because he had learned in the first minute
of the telling that if he watched faces he would begin to edit, and he had
sworn to the dry dark of his own mind, years ago, that if he ever told it he
would tell it whole or not at all.
Hasek led them in by a dry arroyo in the last of the night. Micah rode at the
head of the advance with the guide, and he remembered the cold coming off
the river bottom and the smell of woodsmoke lying low over the camp, and
he remembered — he made himself remember it aloud — that there had been
no horse herd worth the name, only a string of ponies and two mules, and no
sentry fire, and that he had felt the wrongness of it go through him the way a
horse feels bad ground, and had said nothing, because a sergeant of scouts
does not argue his feeling against a guide's certainty with the column already
dismounted behind him. The bugle did what a bugle does at dawn. He told
20
the fire the rest in the shortest words he had: that the camp was not a raiding
band. It was a peaceful band, old people and women and children and a
handful of young men, traveling under a paper from the agent to draw rations
at the agency, a paper some of them perhaps believed would walk in front of
them like a flag. What the column reported as warriors killed were, in the
main, the guards of a burial party that had been out on the bluff at first light
burying an old woman who had died on the march, men who had gone up the
hill unarmed but for two rifles and had died coming down it with empty
hands. He had walked the camp after, when the smoke thinned, doing a
sergeant's work, counting. In a dead woman's hand, folded small and kept dry
against her breast under her dress, he had found the ration tickets for her
family, printed fresh at the agency, the ink not yet faded. He did not dwell on
it. He set it down in the telling the way he had set nothing down in the camp
— gently, and without looking away, and in one sentence — and passed on,
because the fire did not need his dwelling to understand what a ration ticket
in a dead woman's hand meant.
He told them about the ride back, because the ride back was where his own
part stopped being ignorance and became something he had to carry with
both hands. Hasek rode beside the column's surgeon with his tally in his head
and his fee growing at every name the burial detail called out, and at the first
halt he was already arguing the count upward — a boy of fifteen with his
grandfather's rifle beside him on the ground had become a warrior in Hasek's
arithmetic before the flies settled. Micah had said, the once, that the boy had
not fired the rifle and likely could not have lifted it loaded, and Hasek had
looked at him with the patient contempt of a man explaining weather to a
child, and said that the army did not pay for what a dead man had done, it
paid for what he would have done, and that Micah's softness was a luxury of
men whose pay did not depend on the number. He had not answered. He told
21
the fire he had not answered, and that the not-answering was the true
beginning of the thing — not the dawn, not the smoke. A man who will not
argue a boy's age over a tally sheet has already agreed to the arithmetic,
whatever he tells himself afterward in the dark. At the fort there had been an
evening when he stood outside the adjutant's tent with his report in his hand
— his own true report, written out fair, with the ration tickets mentioned and
the burial party named for what it was — and had listened to the laughter
inside, and the captain's voice saying the territory was quieter than it had
been in years, and had understood that the paper in his hand would not
correct the record; it would only end his usefulness and be burned in a stove
by a clerk before spring. He had fed it to his own fire instead, page by page,
which he named to the council as the act he was most ashamed of in the