coming and has decided, this once, to let it come.
77
"Then let it be said in this room, since Mr. Ward has been plain." Marsh
turned to Elias. "If this is left lying — if the agent does nothing and I do
nothing and Mr. Vail goes on trapping and burning and keeping dead boys'
knives on pegs — then sooner or later something happens on that creek that
gets laid at the East Fork band's door. A settler's stock killed. A traveler fired
on. Something. The country is full of men ready to swear it was Apache
work before the blood's dry. And when it happens, sir, the department will
not send a clerk with a notebook. They'll send me — me and my half a
company up the East Fork in the snow to make an example — and men will
die, my men and Tolin's men and women likely, for a hide thief's profit and a
sutler's ledger. I've seen the reports out of the southern country, Mr. Ward. I
know what the columns do when the reports are lies. I would prefer to do my
soldiering against the man who actually did it, while there's still a peace to
keep. So would you, I think."
The stove ticked. Whitfield looked down at his folded hands, and Elias
watched the man's fear rearrange itself — not smaller, but joined by a second
fear, younger and louder.
"You're volunteering your detachment, Lieutenant."
"I'm stating a fact, sir. A patrol to inspect the line — with your clerk along to
record it — is the cheapest peace this territory will ever buy. Three days.
Give me three days to ready it and it's done before the New Year."
Whitfield was silent a while. Then he reached, slowly, for a clean sheet of
the agency's paper, and uncapped the ink, and Elias understood that the
argument had been won not by him but by the specter of Marsh's alternative
— the war Whitfield feared, arriving by the very road of his refusal.
"These are my conditions," Whitfield said, and wrote as he spoke, in a fair
78
clerkly hand. "A patrol will ride to the Cedar Creek line in three days' time,
escorting my clerk, who will record what he finds exactly as found. Mr.
Ward will guide the patrol. And the East Fork band will keep the peace —
wholly, entirely, not a shot, not a threat, not a young man riding out to look
at the poachers from a ridge — until the patrol has been and gone. If the band
breaks the peace, the patrol does not ride, the record does not get made, and
whatever follows follows without my name on it." He looked up. "Your word
is the collateral for theirs, Mr. Ward. I am aware—" and here something
crossed his face that was not quite sympathy, "—that you have some history
with undertakings of this kind. Do I have it?"
There it was. The room knew. Of course the room knew; a post kept its
memories the way a body keeps scar tissue. Elias Ward, the guide who had
led Captain Doren's column through the dark in January of '68 to a camp
asleep on Salt Creek, and forty-odd souls had not woken. His word had once
bought a night march. Both men at that desk were spending it now, knowing
the denomination.
"You have it," Elias said. "I'll answer for them keeping the peace, because
they'll answer to Tolin, and Tolin gave me his word before witnesses of his
own. And I'll guide the patrol myself. Three days."
"Then there is one more thing." Whitfield turned the sheet around on the
desk and held out the pen, and the pen was heavier than it had any right to
be. "A written statement. Your account — the line, the cache, the burning,
the knife — and, Mr. Ward, since your credibility is the entire substance of
this proceeding, your account of Salt Creek as well. In your own words, with
your name under it. If this paper is to go up against Vail's friends, it goes
whole or it doesn't go at all. I won't be hung out with half a witness."
Elias had known, since the moment he'd taken the sheath off the peg, that it
79
would come to this. Confession to Tolin's council had been spoken in a
circle, in two languages, into the air of the mountains, and the air had kept it
the way the mountains keep everything, which is to say forever and in
silence. This was different. This was ink. Ink went into files, and files went
up rivers of offices, and men he would never see would read his name under
the worst night of his life and make their calculations. It would be on paper
when he was dead, and when everyone who might have forgiven him was
dead. That was the point of it, and the terror of it.
He took the pen.
He wrote the better part of an hour, with the light going out of the window
and the clerk lighting the lamp without being asked, and Whitfield reading
the ration ledger at the far side of the room to give the writing the privacy of
not being watched. He wrote it plainly: dates, places, names. Captain Doren.
Salt Creek. January 1868. A winter camp asleep. More than forty killed; he
wrote the words and sat with the pen over them, because a guide's honesty
had to be exact and the truth was that nobody had counted and he would not