to know how much labor went into making it say plainly what it said. The
trap line had been illegal. It had been set on land reserved to the band,
without license, without right, and in numbers meant to strip the country. The
burnings laid at the band's door in the autumn's talking, the burned wickiups,
the destroyed caches, had been the poachers' work, done to be blamed on the
band or on no one, done either way to make the country untenable. And the
band, the report said, had kept a peace it had been provoked past ordinary
endurance to break.
Whitfield watched him read. "It goes to Washington with the winter mail,"
he said. "It will be read by men who read nothing. But it will be in the file,
Mr. Ward. Files outlast the men who read nothing."
Elias set the page back square with the desk's edge. "Pruitt?" he said.
"Will Pruitt will serve two years. The court weighed his testimony, and the
manner of his coming forward. The judge said from the bench that a
104
confession dragged out of a man is worth half of one carried in by the man
himself." Whitfield folded his hands. "He asked after you, in his statement.
He said you told him the truth was a load a man could set down if he was
willing to be the one who'd carried it. I don't know that he understood it. He
said it anyway."
Elias thought of the boy in the patrol's camp, nineteen years old and shaking
apart like a foal, telling what Vail's crew had found in their own steel on a
February creek the year before, and what Vail had ordered done with it, and
the ice closing over all of it while a family on the East Fork went on setting a
place in their minds for a son who was not coming home. Two years was not
the weight of that. It was not meant to be. It was the court's arithmetic, and
Elias had learned, at cost, the difference between arithmetic and weight.
"And Vail," he said.
"Twelve years. He will be an old man in a country that has forgotten his
name, if the country bothers." Whitfield stood, and Elias stood with him, and
at the door the agent paused with his hand on the latch in a way that said the
official business was done and something else was deciding whether to be
said. "For three years," Whitfield said at last, "the file on this district has
contained two accounts of nearly everything, and a man reading it could not
have said which was the lie. That is finished. Whatever else comes, Mr.
Ward, the record and your word are the same document now. I am not a man
who says such things for comfort. I say it because it is a fact of
administration."
Elias rode home to the line cabin in a wind that came down off the
Mogollons with snow in it fine as sifted ash, and he thought about facts of
administration, and about Captain Doren, dead these two years in a fall from
a horse in Texas, who would never read any file. He thought about
105
Lieutenant Marsh, who had taken his patrol out in the open with a guide the
whole command knew for a man with a massacre in his past, and whose
report had used the word guided without flinching. The paper had finished its
work. Paper could not carry a man back to January of 1868 and put his feet
on a different trail. It could only stand in the record and say where his feet
had in fact been, and that he had finally said so himself, in the open, in
council and in writing, where it could be heard. For three years what Elias
Ward said and what the world said had been two different stories, and he had
lived in the gap between them like a man living in a crack in the ice. The gap
was closed now. What was on the other side of it was not peace, exactly. It
was level ground. He was still learning how to stand on level ground.
The cabin, when he came back to it for the deep part of the winter, was as he
had left it, and not as he had left it. The walls held. The roof he had patched
in October shed its snow in the right places. The stove drew. He had lived
alone in that cabin, on and off, through three winters of trapping that had
been less a living than a way of being somewhere no one asked him
questions, and the solitude of it had been the point of it, the way the deep part
of a thicket is the point of it for a wounded animal.
He tested it now the way a man tests a mended limb, putting his weight on it
a little more each day. He trapped a short line, more from habit than hunger,
and found the work neither sweet nor bitter. He read his two books by
lamplight and found the words stayed on the page instead of sliding off into
other years. He slept, some nights, all the way through until the cold woke
him, and woke understanding where he was.
The silence had changed its nature. It was no longer a place to hide. A hiding
place is a thing a man maintains, the way he maintains a trail he does not