Jonah went to the windmill without a word, and Clara watched him climb, his movements sure and unhurried, the way competent men move when they are looking for trouble. He reached the platform, examined the gears and the rods, and then he called down, his voice tight.
Clara. Up here.
She climbed after him, because she did not send other people to look at things she needed to see herself, and when she reached the platform, Jonah showed her: a rod unpinned, a bolt removed, a gear wedged with a piece of wood driven in hard. The windmill had been broken deliberately, and carefully, by someone who knew machinery β not smashed, which would have been obvious from the ground, but crippled, so that it would turn a few times and then seize, and the well pump would stop, and the ranch would lose its water a little at a time, the way a ranch loses everything a little at a time when men like Rourke are at work.
Can you fix it? she asked.
I can, Jonah said. "I have the parts in the barn. But it will take the morning, and while I'm up here, the troughs are still fouled, and the cattle are still thirsty."
Then we work both at once, Clara said. "You fix the mill. I'll scrub the troughs with the boys. Amos, you ride the boundary. I want to know if anything else was touched."
Amos rode out, and Clara scrubbed, and the work was hot and filthy and necessary, and by noon the troughs were clean and the windmill was turning again, and the cattle drank, and the horses drank, and the ranch went on. But Clara did not go on as if nothing had happened. She went to the ledger in the kitchen, and she wrote it down, dated, in her steady hand: troughs fouled, windmill crippled, July, night, unknown hands. And Amos and Jonah signed as witnesses, as Lind had taught her.
It was Jonah who found the evidence, late that afternoon, when the light went low and slanted across the yard. He came to her with something in his hand, held carefully, like a thing that mattered.
A glove, he said. "Leather. Left-handed. Found it by the windmill ladder, where the man who climbed up must have dropped it going down in the dark."
Clara took it. It was a workman's glove, worn, with a seam split at the thumb. Inside, stamped faintly, was a maker's mark she did not recognize, and that was all. But Jonah was not finished.
And this, he said, and he showed her the second thing: a spur mark in the dust by the trough, pressed deep, a rowel with a broken tooth, a pattern as distinctive as a signature. "One tooth missing on the left side. If we ever see that spur again, we'll know it."
And the rider? Clara asked.
Jonah's face went still. "I caught a shadow last night," he said. "I was on watch β not a full watch, just restless, the way you get when you feel something wrong. I saw a rider moving along the creek line, no lantern, keeping to the dark. I went after him, but he knew the ground and I didn't, not the way he did, and he got away toward the road. I didn't see his face. But I saw the way he rode, and I saw that he rode like a man who had done this before."
Clara looked at the glove and the spur mark, and she thought of the evidence chain Lind had described β a record, dated, witnessed, each piece small, each piece pointing the same way β and she understood that this was how a case was built: not in one dramatic discovery, but in gloves and spur marks and fouled water, laid down one after another until no honest person could look at them and call them accidents.
She put the glove in the tin box with the deed and the ledger, and she wrote down the spur mark's description beside it, and she had Jonah sign.
Amos came back from the boundary ride as the light failed, and his report was both a relief and a warning. Nothing else had been touched β no cut wire, no missing cattle, no fresh tracks at the corrals. But along the creek line he had found the same boot prints, and a place where a horse had stood a long time in the dark, waiting, and he said the waiting worried him more than the fouling. A man who fouls a trough and leaves is a vandal. A man who waits by a creek in the dark is a man with a plan, and a plan meant Rourke was not finished with the water.
At supper Mabel set down a pot of beans with more force than necessary and said what everyone was thinking and no one had said aloud. "They'll come for the well next," she said. "Mark me. The troughs were practice."
Clara did not argue. She added Mabel's words to the ledger that night, in her own hand, with the date, and she drew the spur mark as best she could remember it β the rowel, the missing tooth on the left side β so that if she ever saw that spur again, she would know it the way she knew her own handwriting. The record was growing, page by page, and each page made the next incident harder to call an accident.
That night she set a full watch, in turns, with the boys and Amos and Jonah, and she slept with her revolver beside her, and she dreamed of water running clean and of windmills turning, and woke to find both true. The troughs were clean. The mill was turning. The cattle drank.