THE STRANGER ON THE ROAN MARE

Chapter 5

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

She was next in line. She had known it since Rourke's first visit, and now she knew it the way you know a thing you have already counted: with certainty, and without surprise.

She thought about the order of it, because order mattered. First the cattle, a few head at a time, so few that a man could tell himself it was rustlers or coyotes or bad luck. Then the beating, or the fright, so that the owner stopped sleeping and started jumping at sounds. Then the sheriff, with his word โ€” unfortunate โ€” which was not a finding but a door closing. Then Rourke, with his paper and his smile, offering the only door left open. It was a machine, and it ran on patience, and Clara understood machines. A machine could be broken, but only if you found the part that mattered and took it out of the works. She did not yet know which part mattered. She knew only that she would not walk through his door, and that knowing was a beginning, even if it was not yet a plan. And a beginning, she told herself as she turned her horse toward home, was more than Rourke had left either of her neighbors. Ashford had not always been a coward, she thought. Once he had been a deputy who rode hard and asked questions. Something had changed him โ€” a debt, a threat, a promise โ€” and whatever it was, it had made him Rourke's man in everything but name.

Amos rode up beside her. He had been quiet since Delaney's, and his quiet was the kind that meant he was thinking hard.

Well? he said.

Well, Clara said. "We've seen the pattern."

And?

And we don't walk through his door.

Amos nodded. He looked at the empty house, at the sale notice fluttering, at the dust on the road.

Then we'd best watch the fences double, he said. "And the cattle triple."

We will, Clara said. She turned her horse toward home, toward her own fifty-eight head, toward the hill where Thomas was buried and the house that needed shingles and the land that was hers by law and by work. "We will."

The cattle went missing on a Tuesday.

Clara counted at dawn, the way she always counted, standing at the corral fence with the ledger in her head and the boys moving through the herd behind her. Fifty-eight head on Monday. Fifty-five on Tuesday. Two cows and a yearling, gone as if the dry ground had swallowed them, and the ground had not swallowed anything. The ground in Red Hollow in the summer of 1884 was hard as brick, and it kept a record of everything that crossed it.

Three head, Wade said. He was nineteen, the oldest of the boys, tall and steady, with his father's rifle slung across his back. "Gone from the north pasture."

Nat, seventeen, quiet and quick, pointed at the fence line. "Wire's down over there. Look."

Clara walked the fence with Amos beside her, and the boys trailing, and she saw what Nat had seen: three strands of wire cut clean, not broken, not rusted through, but cut with a tool, the ends bright where the cutters had bitten. Beside the cut, in the dust, was a boot print she did not recognize โ€” narrow, with a city-made sole, nothing like the broad work boots her boys wore or the worn boots Amos favored. She knelt and looked at it for a long time, memorizing the shape of it, the way the heel had pressed deeper on one side, as if the man who made it had been hurrying.

That's not one of ours, Amos said quietly.

No, Clara said. "It's not."

Luke, sixteen, the youngest, stood a little apart from the others, his face pale under his hat. He was a good boy, earnest and eager, but he was sixteen, and sixteen is an age when fear sits close to the surface. "Do you think they'll come back tonight?" he asked.

Maybe, Clara said. She did not lie to the boys. Lying to them would have been kinder in the moment and crueler in the end, because they would have learned not to believe her, and belief was the only wage she could pay them that mattered. "So we watch."

Wade took the news the way he took most news, with a nod and a tightening of his jaw. Nat went quiet, which was his way of being afraid, and he checked his rifle twice before noon, as if the checking itself were a kind of courage. Luke tried to joke about it and failed, and then he went to the barn and stayed there a long while, and when he came out his eyes were red, though he would have denied it if anyone had asked. Clara did not ask. She gave them work instead, because work was the only medicine she trusted for fear. She sent Wade to ride the south line, Nat to mend the corral gate, and Luke to count the feed sacks twice, and she told them all, plainly, that fear was not shameful and panic was not permitted, and that there was a difference, and they should learn it.

That night they watched. Clara organized the watch the way Thomas had once organized it, in shifts, two at a time, with the bunkhouse lamp kept low and the rifles cleaned and ready. She took the middle shift herself, with Wade, and they sat on the porch with the dark all around them and the cattle restless in the corral, and the windmill turning slow above the well.

News in the same category

THE STRANGER ON THE ROAN MARE

45 Part