"My book says three hundred," she said. "And my book was kept every night on the trail, not made up this morning in an office. Count them again, slowly, with my men watching. Or we will drive them to the town scale, lot by lot, and count them through the gate where every man in Abilene can see the number."
The buyer looked at her, and then at the book, and then at Knut, who stood behind her with his arms crossed and said nothing at all, which was, Tove thought, the most useful thing a man could say in a bargain. The buyer's smile thinned. He had met women before who kept books, but he had not met many who kept them nightly, in ink, with the storm and the river written in beside the numbers.
He tried one more way, the last way buyers try, and it was the quietest of all. "I could pay you in thirty days," he said, "on account, once the cattle are shipped and the rail receipts are in. That's how the big outfits do it. Cash on the table is a small man's bargain."
Tove closed her book, gently, the way a woman closes a book she means to keep. "I am not a big outfit," she said. "I am a ranch with one herd and four men to pay, and I pay them in cash, counted aloud, because that was the agreement. So I will be paid in cash, counted aloud, because that is the agreement I make here. You will weigh on the town scale, you will count through the gate, and you will pay on the weight and the count that show there. Or my herd walks out of your pens and into another buyer's, and Abilene will know why."
It was not a threat. It was a fact, stated the way facts are stated when a woman has the numbers to back them. The buyer studied her face for a long moment, and whatever he saw there — the tally book, the steady voice, the old hand standing silent behind her — decided him.
Before he gave in, he tried one more thing, because buyers always try one more thing. "Split the herd, then," he said. "I'll pay prime price for the prime steers and take the rest as culls at half. That's a fair offer for a mixed lot."
Tove shook her head. "They are not a mixed lot. They are one herd, driven one trail, counted one book. You do not get to cut my herd in half with a word and pay me for the better half. One herd, one price, weighed true and counted aloud. That is the bargain I make, and it is the only one I make."
The scale hand, who had stood by his scale through all of it saying nothing, cleared his throat then, and said, quietly, "The town scale reads true, ma'am. I run it myself, and it answers to no buyer."
Tove nodded to him, and the buyer, who had no more ways left that did not involve admitting what his own scale had done, looked at the pens, looked at the book, and looked at the gate through which the whole town could watch.
"We'll reweigh on the town scale," he said at last. "Lot by lot, through the gate, counted aloud. And I'll pay the fair price on the weight that shows there."
It took the rest of the afternoon. The cattle went through the gate in lots, counted aloud by Tove's men and the buyer's men together, and the town scale, which belonged to no buyer, read true. The first lot went through, and the scale hand called the weight, and Tove wrote it in her book beside the weight the buyer's scale had shown that morning, and the difference stood there on the page, plain as a fence line, for any man to see. The second lot went through, and the third, and each time the town scale read heavier than the buyer's scale had read, by the same steady margin she had noticed that morning. The buyer's men counted the head through the gate, calling each ten aloud, and Tove's men counted beside them, and the numbers matched lot by lot, because a herd counted twice by honest men comes out the same number both times.