It worked. For three summers it worked in fairgrounds and rodeo grounds and, increasingly — because the money was better and the crowds already understood rifles the way they understood weather — on shooting ranges across the middle of the country, where the Challenge ran as an exhibition between the sanctioned events, and the volunteers were drawn, as the posters Kyle wrote himself put it, from the ranks of the brave, the young-at-heart, and the young. That last word did a great deal of quiet work in the sentence. Kyle's eye, trained by three years of doorways, went always to the same raw material: age, visible and undoubtable, in a body the crowd had already decided was past it. A seventy-year-old in a team jacket was no good; he looked like he might win. A sixty-year-old with a veteran's cap was no good either; the crowd respected the cap, and respect was friction, and friction slowed the laugh. What Kyle needed, and knew he needed, and would not have been able to say aloud in a boardroom though he said it freely to his crew at midnight, was someone the crowd could feel sorry for and superior to in the same glance. Somebody frail. Somebody quaint. Somebody whose failure could be loved, in the comments, as inspiration, and mocked, in the comments, as comedy — for the comments, Kyle understood better than any television producer he had ever worked for, could be made to mean whichever of those the reader arrived wanting, and both kinds of reader stopped, and stayed, and shared.
He had a crew of four and a system, and the system had a name for such people. On the whiteboard in the trailer, under the columns for weather and gate and sponsor obligations, there was a column headed PICK, and the pick was made before noon on show days, and the word the crew used — Kyle had started it as a joke in Indiana and it had hardened, the way jokes do in workplaces, into vocabulary — was a soft one. "He's soft," Kyle would say, scanning a morning crowd. "She's soft. No — her. Look at the hands." It meant: this one will not make trouble. This one will smile when the laugh comes, because people of that generation were raised to smile when a room turned on them, and will thank me afterwards for the attention, and will be safely in a car home before the video is even cut. Soft people did not write letters. Soft people did not telephone boards.
Except that this summer, some of them had.
The folder lived, though Kyle did not know it in any detail, in the bottom drawer of Ruth Ellery's desk in the range office, and it was not thick. That was the thing Kyle would have pointed to, if anyone had ever sat him down and made the case against him, and it was a true thing, as far as it went. It was not thick. Eleven pages, that summer, across nine ranges in six states. A letter from a daughter in Topeka whose father, a retired music teacher of seventy-nine, had come home from Kyle's show and not spoken at supper and been found, at midnight, sitting in his car in the garage with the engine off and his good hat still on his head, because at his age a man has a limited number of afternoons left in which he expects to be treated as a man, and one of Kyle's had been spent being called Grandpa by a stranger with a microphone while his grandchildren watched. A printed email from a man in Oklahoma who wrote, in the careful capitals of the self-taught typist, that he had not minded losing and had minded, very much, being prevented from standing up from the bench when he wanted to stand, by a hand on his shoulder and a voice saying stay with me, folks, he's not done. Two complaint forms in Ruth's own handwriting, taken down over the telephone from people who would not write, who said only that it hadn't been right, that the laughing had gone on too long, that somebody should have stepped in. Somebody should have stepped in. That sentence, in its various wordings, was in the folder five times.
Ruth had read the folder. Ruth, who took the range's bookings and checked its shooters in and knew the names of people's grandchildren and the dates of their operations, had done more than read it: she had sent it, twice, up the small, creaking chain of the range's administration — once in June and once in July — with a covering note in her neat, clerk's hand that said, This is a pattern, and patterns are our business before they are anybody else's emergency. Twice it had come back to her drawer with a paper clip on it and no reply written anywhere, because the gate receipts were real and the board was tired and the sponsor's money paid for the junior programme's ammunition, and because everybody concerned, Ruth included, understood that a folder eleven pages thick is easy to leave in a drawer until the day it is eleven hundred.
She had tried Kyle himself, once, that morning — before the gates, in the lee of his trailer, with two paper cups of coffee in her hands like an offering. She was not a fool. She knew better than to open with the folder.
"You've got a big crowd coming today," she said, and handed him a cup. "Board members. The patron's coming too, we're told. General Locke. He doesn't come every year."
"General." Kyle rolled the word around with pleasure. "Does he do photos? A general in the clip is gold, Ruth. A general is class. Puts us in a whole different — "