written them. It ended mid-sentence. He had never finished it, and he had never burned it, and for two
years it had lived in the land book like a stone in a shoe a man has decided to walk with.
"You did not send it because of the last page," Wren said, when he had done.
"I did not send it because of the first three," he said.
"You did not send it," she said, gently, in the tone of a woman entering a figure in its correct column
at last, "because whichever page you sent, the letter was about getting an answer. And you did not want
an answer, Hollis. You wanted the question to stay open. A man with an open question in Ohio does not
have to finish a room in Arizona. I know this system. I kept a copy of a telegram for three years on
exactly the same principle."
They were quiet together a while, in the way that had become theirs, which was not an empty quiet but a
working one. Then he took a sheet of the company's contract paper — the last in the drawer — and he
wrote, at the table, in her presence, a letter of eight lines. It wished his brother and Clara well, in plain
words, without decoration. It released a small debt of his brother's that the old letter had itemized like a
charge sheet. It said the land in Arizona was proving out, and that he was married, and that his wife's
name was Wren. He signed it, and folded it, and addressed it in his surveyor's hand, and that afternoon
they rode to town together and he posted it at the express office while she stood in the doorway and
watched him do it, which was the whole ceremony, and sufficient.
"Entered," she said, on the ride home.
"Closed," he said, and the word surprised him by being true.
The journey to Prescott for the preliminary hearing took two days by wagon and one night in a
roadhouse where the beds had opinions. The hearing itself was not the review — Creed had been precise
about that in his notice, in his small forger-proof hand. It was a taking of the shape of the protest: the
company's board would hear what grounds were offered, fix the scope of the review, and set its date. No
ruling would be made. Hollis had read the notice four times. Wren had read it once and memorized it,
which she did not mention.
Prescott smelled of pine and courthouse dust and other people's business. The hearing room was over
the land office, with a stove that had been lit out of habit and a clerk who took the names. August Pruitt
was already there when they came in, in his good suit, with a folder tied in ribbon, and he rose —
courteous, always courteous — and inclined his head to Wren with a gravity that in any other man
would have been respect.
"Mrs. Crane," he said. "I am sorry for the necessity."
"You are not," Wren said, pleasantly and clearly, in a voice that carried exactly as far as the clerk's desk
and no farther. "But it was handsomely said, Mr. Pruitt, and I shall remember it as the best thing you
have said to me. Shall we sit down?"
Josiah Creed presided with two company men beside him who said nothing and missed nothing. The
grounds were read. The first ground — marriage as device — Creed dealt with in ten minutes, and the
ten minutes were a small education in watching a ledger-keeper fence. Was the marriage lawful? It was.
Was it recorded? It was. Did the parties reside upon the parcel? The inspector's own line said they did,
and the inspector was present and stood on his line. Then the first ground, Creed observed, reduced itself
to an argument about motive, and the company's terms did not undertake to inspect motives where
residence and legality were established — unless the second ground bore on good faith, which was a
question of fact, and to the facts of the second ground the review would confine itself.
"Name them, then," Creed said. "Plainly. This board does not review clouds."
And August Pruitt, in the good suit, with his brother's name in his mouth like a stone, named them.
The Dodge City office. The night of the third of October, 1881. A warning held forty minutes. A train
lost. Three men dead, one of them nineteen years old, one of them his. The operator's name on the
inquiry report: Halloway. He did not raise his voice. He did not need to. It was the worst ten minutes
Wren had sat through since the room with no windows, and she sat through it with her hands folded and
her face arranged in the stillness the town had mistaken for six years for an absence of anything
underneath, and Hollis, beside her, put his hand flat on the table where she could see it, palm down, still,
as she had once arranged her own where he could see them, and left it there until Pruitt had finished.
"Mrs. Crane," Creed said, when the naming was done. "The review will ask whether the settlement was
entered in good faith by persons of settled character. That is the scope. It is not a retrial of a railway
inquiry, and this board has no power and no appetite to make it one. But a protestant may put in
documents, and so may you. If there is a record that speaks, Mrs. Crane, I advise you — as the inspector
of this file, not as your friend, a relation in which I do not stand — to bring the record. Boards believe
paper. It is their religion. It is, on my better days, mine."
"I understand you, Mr. Creed," Wren said.