planting in other men's fields — was that Hollis Crane, whose temper about lines and paper was famous,
whose orchard was his whole fortune, had staged the diversion himself: had laid his own board, in his
own ditch, to manufacture an outrage three weeks before a review, to put the company in the wrong and
Pruitt in the fire, and had then performed the discovery for witnesses like a man reading a part. It was a
better story than the truth, in the saloon sense. It had a villain the town already half believed in and a
motive made of arithmetic. Salome Duarte heard it at her own bar and set a bottle down hard, in the
manner that had once ended a wedding announcement, and said, "I have poured for that man six years.
Hollis Crane could no more act a part than my piano can. If the boy is a liar, the desert is wet," — but a
defense, in a dry week, is worth what water is worth, and gossip travels faster than either.
Hollis heard the story entire at the livery on Monday, standing in a circle of men who went quiet in
sections, like a wagon stopping. He stood in the middle of it and let it happen, exactly as he had stood in
the Esperanza in May, and Wren — who heard of the Monday circle only afterward, from Della, with
Della's own furious punctuation — understood that what she was angriest about was not the story. It was
that he had stood in it alone, out of a habit older than the marriage, and had come home and said nothing
until the beans were on the table, and then said it in the tone of a man reporting weather on a
neighboring ranch.
"You are doing it again," she said. "The unfinished room is not a room anymore, Hollis, it is a method.
You carry the worst of a thing alone until it is finished being dangerous, and then you present me the
receipt. I did the same for three years with a telegram. We are neither of us to do it anymore. That is not
a condition. The conditions are closed. Call it maintenance."
"Maintenance entered," he said, after a moment, with the ghost of the almost-smile. "Wren — if I had
answered those men on Monday the way my hands wanted to answer them, the answer would be in
Creed's file by Friday, with my name under it, in ink, under the heading interference. He does not need
to steal the land, do you see it? He needs me to mislay it. One fight. One shot at his rider on the road.
One night of riding out to settle the ditch with a rifle across the saddle, and the settlement is finished as a
disturbance the company cannot patent, and the land goes to the calm man with the option and the
folded hands. Every provocation since May has been a door he has been holding open for me, Wren. The
halter. The offer. The board. He is waiting for me to walk through one of them carrying my temper like a
lantern."
"Then we disappoint the door," she said. "Together. In full rooms. It is the only plan this house has
ever had and it has not lost yet."
Chapter Sixteen: Mateo's Witness
Mateo Reyes had not slept properly since the Friday of the board, and it was not the heat, and it was not
the baby, who was still three weeks from troubling anyone's sleep directly. It was a thing he had seen on
the Thursday night — the night before the board was found — and had been carrying since, the way
Hollis carried letters and Wren carried telegrams, in the hope that carrying it quietly would make it
smaller.
He had been up at the sheep shed in the dark hour before midnight, because a ewe was lambing out of
season and Lucia, who could no longer bend to such work, had sent him the way generals send scouts.
Coming down from the shed by the north path, without a lantern, because a man can walk his own
valley blind and a lantern makes him a target for every fool with an opinion, he had seen a rider on the
old ditch track above Las Palomas, where no rider had any lawful business at that hour — a man sitting
his horse perfectly still, above the head gate, for as long as it takes a ewe to settle: twenty minutes,
perhaps thirty. And the horse was a company horse, Mateo knew it by the brand he could not see, which
sounds like a lie and was the opposite: he knew it by the way it stood. Stage company stock was broken
to stand at a hitching rail for hours in the heat; it stood like furniture. No ranch horse in that valley stood
like furniture at midnight on a ditch track.
The rider had a length of something pale across his saddle — a board, Mateo had thought at the time,
and had thought it so idly, the way a man notes weather, that he had gone home and slept his four hours
and woken to a world in which boards had become evidence. He had said nothing on Friday, standing in
the spring with his wet boots, giving Hollis the oiled pin and the carried stones, because a man does not
enter in a register what he only thinks he saw, in the dark, from a hill, in lambing season. By Tuesday he
had thought it for five days, and thought it straight, and on Tuesday evening he rode to Las Palomas and
asked for Wren's register and Hollis's table, and he gave it all, in order, with the hours, and signed it, and