You have thirty days to satisfy the debt, he said, and he looked at Silas when he said it, but his eyes flicked to Eleanor, as if to remind her that the debt was not the only thing at stake. "Thirty days, Mr. Mercer. After that, the ranch will be sold, and the children will be removed, marriage certificate or no marriage certificate."
Then he looked directly at Eleanor, and his voice dropped, low and quiet, and Eleanor felt a chill run down her spine that had nothing to do with the cold.
And Mrs. Mercer? he said.
Yes? Eleanor asked, and she forced herself to meet his gaze, to not look away, to not show him how frightened she was.
Some graves are safer unopened, Whitcomb said, and he smiled, a thin, cold smile, and then he left, and the door closed behind him, and the riders disappeared into the snow, their hoofbeats fading into the wind, until the only sound was the children's breathing and the soup simmering on the stove.
Silas closed the door, slowly, and he turned toward Eleanor, and his face was dark, and his eyes were narrowed, and Eleanor saw in them suspicion, and hurt, and the beginning of anger, and she braced herself, because she knew what he was going to say before he said it.
You married me because you knew something was hidden here, Silas said, and his voice was low, and it was not a question.
No, Eleanor said, and she shook her head, and she stepped toward him, her hands out, palms up, as if to show him she was hiding nothing. "Don't lie, Silas. I didn't know. I swear to you, I didn't know this was Benjamin's ranch until we arrived. I didn't know my father had ever been here. I didn't know Whitcomb would come. I married you because—"
Because what? Silas asked, and he cut her off, and his voice rose, and for a moment he looked like a man who had been betrayed, who had ridden three hundred miles and married a stranger and brought her to his brother's house, only to discover that she had secrets of her own, secrets that might put his brother's children in danger.
Because children shouldn't lose their family twice, Eleanor said, and her voice was quiet, and she said it simply, and Silas stared at her, and his anger faltered, just slightly, and she saw doubt flicker across his face, doubt about his accusation, doubt about himself, doubt about everything he thought he knew.
He wanted to believe her. Eleanor could see it in his eyes, the way he wanted to believe her, the way he wanted to trust her, the way he wanted this marriage, however strange its beginning, to be honest. But he had been betrayed before, by his own choices, by his absence, by the cattle contracts that had kept him away, and trust did not come easily to him now.
Then Anna spoke from behind them, her voice small and clear, cutting through the tension like a knife through cloth.
My papa found something before he died, Anna said, and everyone turned, and the nine-year-old girl stood beside the stove, her blanket wrapped around her shoulders, her hair loose, her eyes wide and serious, and she pointed toward the floor, toward the boards beneath Benjamin's bedroom, and her voice did not waver.
What? Silas asked, and he stepped toward her, his anger forgotten, his suspicion forgotten, his eyes fixed on his niece.
Anna pointed again, more firmly this time, her finger steady, her gaze steady, and she said, in a voice that was both frightened and certain, "A box."
Eleanor looked at Silas, and Silas looked at Eleanor, and in that moment, neither of them spoke, because they both understood what Anna meant, and what it might mean for all of them: that Benjamin had found something before he died, something he had hidden beneath the floor, something that might prove Amos Hart innocent, or prove Whitcomb guilty, or prove both, and that the proof her father had written about, hidden where the Mercer family would never think to look, might have been here all along, beneath their feet, waiting to be found.
Silas crossed the kitchen in three strides and knelt before Anna, so that his eyes were level with hers, and he put his hands gently on her shoulders, and his voice, when he spoke, was soft, and careful, as if he were speaking to a frightened animal that might bolt if he moved too fast. "Anna," he said, "are you sure? Did your papa show you a box? Did he tell you what was in it?"
Anna shook her head, slowly, her blanket slipping from her shoulders, her hair falling across her face. "He didn't show me," she whispered. "I heard him, one night, when Mama was sick. He was in his bedroom, and the floor was creaking, and I peeked through the door, and he was lifting a plank, and putting a box underneath, and he said, 'If anything happens to me, Anna, remember this. Remember where it is.' And then he saw me, and he put his finger to his lips, and he said, 'Don't tell anyone, not yet. Not until the right person comes.'"
Eleanor felt her breath catch, and she looked at Silas, and she saw her own hope reflected in his eyes, hope mixed with fear, because a box beneath the floor could hold proof, or it could hold nothing, or it could hold something that would put them all in greater danger than they were already in. Whitcomb had said some graves were safer unopened, and Eleanor knew, with a cold certainty, that he had not been speaking of graves at all, but of boxes, and of ledgers, and of truths that men like him would kill to keep buried.