Silas crouched beside her. "Are you certain?"
She did not look up. "I copied his hand for six years. I know the way he makes his sevens. I know the way he crosses his t's when he is in a hurry. I know—" She stopped, and her hands began to shake, just a little at first, then harder, until the paper trembled in the lantern light. "This is Amos Hart's handwriting."
Anna leaned closer. "What does it say, Mrs. Mercer?"
Eleanor read aloud, slowly, as if each word cost her something. "Payment received from Benjamin Mercer. Six hundred dollars. For cattle sold at Casper, October." She turned the paper over. In the margin, in the same hand but smaller, hurried, were different figures. "And here—here it says the same payment was recorded as nine hundred dollars. Paid to Amos Hart for investment."
Silas felt something cold settle in his chest. "The same payment, written two ways."
Yes. Eleanor set that sheet aside and took another. Her movements were quick now, almost frantic, the careful woman from the saloon gone, replaced by someone who had waited six years for a page like this and was afraid it would turn to smoke if she did not read it fast enough. "This one lists a land deed. Benjamin's north pasture. Transferred to a company in Cheyenne." She looked up. "Benjamin never sold his north pasture. He told me—no, he told Silas, in a letter. He loved that pasture. He said it was the best grass on the ranch."
How do you know what Benjamin said in a letter?
Eleanor flushed, but she did not stop reading. "You told me. On the ride north. You said Benjamin wrote to you last spring, asking you to stay, saying he needed help."
Silas nodded slowly. He had said that. He had almost forgotten saying it, in the rush of the wedding and the snow and Grace lost in the cottonwoods, but Eleanor had remembered every word. She remembered everything. That was the kind of woman she was.
She spread the papers on the floor around her, one by one, until the lantern light fell on a small, ragged map of numbers and names. Some were in Amos's hand. Some were in a different hand, stiff and official, the hand of a man used to signing documents other men were afraid to question.
These were altered, Eleanor said. Her voice steadied as she spoke, the way a voice steadies when it finds a truth it can stand on. "Look. Here is my father's copy. Here is the county copy. The figures do not match. The county copy is higher. Always higher. And the difference—" She ran her finger down a column, adding in her head the way Amos had taught her, when she was a girl sitting at his knee with a slate. "The difference went somewhere else."
She lifted another sheet, one with a list of names down the left-hand side, and her finger stopped halfway down. "Here. Thomas Abernathy. He paid four hundred dollars for grazing rights. The county copy says he paid six hundred, and that the extra two hundred went to my father." Her voice grew steadier as the numbers lined up in her mind, the way they always had when Amos set her a sum at the kitchen table and waited for her to find the error. "And here, Mrs. Calloway, a widow. She paid in eggs and butter, because she had no cash. The county copy says she paid in coin. Someone turned her eggs into money on paper, Silas. Someone who knew no one would ask a widow to prove what she had paid."
Silas took the sheet from her and held it closer to the lantern. The handwriting in the margin was his brother's, he realised, the same cramped hand that had written to him last spring. Benjamin had been keeping his own record, in secret, in the margins of his father's enemy's papers, and he had hidden it under his own floor because he had known, even then, that a man who asked questions about Whitcomb did not live long enough to ask them twice.
How many names? Silas asked.
So far, seven, Eleanor said. "Seven families who paid one thing and were recorded as paying another. And every time, the difference is written in the same hand, and every time, the extra money is said to have gone to Amos Hart." She looked up at him, and in the lantern light her eyes were bright with anger and grief both, the anger of a daughter and the grief of a woman who had spent six years believing that the world had simply been cruel, when all along it had been cheated. "My father did not steal from these people, Silas. He was the excuse for stealing from them."
Silas looked at the papers, then at her, then at Anna, who was watching them both with an expression far too old for nine years. He thought of Whitcomb standing in this same kitchen only hours before, buttoning his coat, smiling his thin smile, saying that some graves were safer unopened.
Put them back, Silas said quietly. "All of them. In the box. Exactly as we found them."
Eleanor stared at him. "But—"
Not yet, he said. "Not until we understand what we are holding. If Whitcomb knows we have this, he will not wait thirty days."
She hesitated, then nodded, and together they gathered the papers, folding them as they had been folded, laying them back in the iron box in the order they had found them. Anna helped, her small hands careful, and Thomas came in from the kitchen and watched without speaking, his wooden horse tucked under his arm.