To get her attention. He held the phrase up and looked at it, this man who had raised three children and buried a father and kept a marriage and a mortgage on a patrolman's pay, and the phrase looked back at him with its face uncovered. His attention had never been the problem. He had had her attention from the first shout. The baton had not been swung at the car to get anything. It had been swung at the insult — at the intolerable, snow-dusted fact of a woman who would not arrange her face into fear for him — and the car had simply been standing where the insult was, the way innocent things so often stand in the path of a blow aimed at something else.
The alarm screamed. The strobes found his face and let it go, found it and let it go. His breathing was slowing into something worse than panic, which is a man's breathing when the body has finished spending itself and handed the situation over to the mind, and the mind has read it.
"She was leaving," he said, out loud, to the street, to the phones, to the doorman, trying the first sentence of the story in the open air to see if it would stand in snow. His voice sounded strange to him, too loud and too thin at once. "She was — I told her —"
Nobody answered him. The kid on the delivery bike looked down at his phone to check it was recording. The woman in the leopard-print coat had taken her hand down from her mouth, slowly, and she was looking at him over the cratered ruin of the windshield with her sunglasses back in place, and her stillness now was a different substance from the stillness of five minutes ago. Then she had been a woman declining to be moved. Now she was a woman watching a thing finish happening, the way you watch weather pass over a house you own, and in that stillness was every lawyer, every camera, every dollar and every year of building herself that she had not needed to use this morning and would not need to lift a finger to use now, because he had done the lifting for her, with his own right arm, in front of all these witnesses.
Imani stood with the cold working through the thin soles of her boots and did the thing she had done at every disaster of her professional life, from the brownstone with the rotted joists to the site where the crane had come down in the night: she inventoried. The windshield was gone, in the only sense that mattered — not out of the frame, but gone the way a window in a flooded house is gone, present and useless. The bonnet wore its drift of glass. The alarm would run until someone stopped it, and the only person with the key was a young man indoors who did not yet know. The car's soft grey paint, which she had chosen because Henry had once, forty years ago, driven a film director for a summer in a grey car and spoken of it ever since as the colour of being trusted — the paint was unmarked. That was the obscenity of the inventory, the line in it that her eye kept returning to: everything else was perfect. The car stood at the kerb gleaming and strobing and ruined in exactly one place, the way a man is ruined in exactly one place, the place where the blow lands.
She thought of her father at his kitchen table, this morning, seventy years old and unaware, probably wearing the good cardigan already because a man who has worn other men's evenings for a living dresses early for his own. She thought of the drive she had rehearsed all week — down out of the city in the blue hour, the car she'd kept secret through three months of hints she refused to take, pulling up outside the house he had paid off in his sixties on a chauffeur's money, and Henry coming down the steps with his hand already rising to his mouth in exactly the gesture she had made thirty seconds ago, the family's gesture, the one they all made when the world showed them something too big to say. She had rehearsed handing him the key. She had rehearsed not crying until the second corner. Standing in the snow with glass dust shining on the shoulders of her coat, she understood that the rehearsal was over and the evening would now be something else — and that this, more than the money, more than the coat or the shouting or the finger in her face, was what the man with the baton had actually taken, and taken without ever knowing it existed.