“No. I gave him my name and explained the vehicle assignment. I showed Sergeant Price my business card after she arrived.”
Price made another note.
She did not rush through the questions.
That mattered to Marcus.
He had been interviewed often enough to recognize the difference between someone trying to discover what happened and someone trying to construct a convenient version of it.
When Price finished, she closed the notebook.
“Thank you. I'll make sure your statement is included.”
Marcus nodded.
“There's another issue.”
“What is it?”
“The patrol vehicle's recording equipment.”
Price glanced toward the cruiser.
“We'll preserve whatever recordings are available.”
“Did either officer have a body camera operating?”
Price turned toward Miller.
“Officer Miller?”
Miller looked uncomfortable.
“Mine wasn't activated, Sergeant.”
Price's expression tightened.
“Why not?”
“I didn't activate it when I arrived.”
“And Officer Dunley?”
Miller glanced toward his partner.
“I don't know whether his was activated.”
Price turned to Dunley.
“Officer, was your body camera activated?”
Dunley hesitated.
“No.”
The answer seemed to hang in the air.
Price looked at him for a long moment.
“Why?”
“I didn't believe it was necessary at the beginning.”
“Your policy requires activation during qualifying enforcement encounters.”
“It was a brief stop.”
“You placed a man in handcuffs and investigated a suspected stolen vehicle.”
Dunley folded his arms.
“The situation escalated.”
Price's voice remained controlled.
“An encounter does not become exempt from recording requirements because it escalates.”
Dunley looked away.
Marcus felt something cold settle in his chest.
The missing recordings did not prove that Dunley had deliberately concealed anything. A camera could fail. An officer could make a mistake. A policy could be misunderstood.
But the absence of a recording meant that the public would have to rely on other evidence: witness videos, dispatch logs, the documents, the written reports, and the accounts of everyone involved.
That made preservation even more important.
“Sergeant,” Marcus said, “I want the department to preserve all available records relating to this stop, including dispatch audio, vehicle-camera footage, computer-access logs, officer communications, and any system entries concerning the registration and VIN.”
Price nodded.
“I'll document that request.”
“I also want the department to record when the request was made and who received it.”
“That's reasonable.”
“And I want the original report retained if anyone later submits an amendment.”
Price's expression became more intent.
“You're concerned the report could be changed.”
“I'm concerned about any process in which the people whose conduct is being investigated control the only record of what happened.”
Price did not take offense.
She looked toward the patrol vehicle, where Dunley was now speaking quietly to Miller.
“I understand.”
Marcus studied her face.
“Do you?”
Price took a breath.
“I understand why you're asking. Whether the department can meet every request exactly as you've stated will depend on the records available and the applicable procedures. But I'm not going to tell you that the missing cameras don't matter.”
It was the first answer he had received that morning that did not attempt to minimize the situation.
He appreciated it.
“Thank you.”
Price returned to her notebook.
“There's one other thing I need to address. Because the incident involves an officer's use of restraints and a disputed basis for detention, I'll notify the duty lieutenant and request that the incident be reviewed by the appropriate unit.”
“Will Officer Dunley remain on duty?”
Price glanced at him.
“I don't make that determination alone.”
“Then I would like the person who does make it to know that the officer's conduct is now part of a documented complaint.”
“That will be included.”
Marcus nodded.
He had no desire to dictate an employment decision without an investigation. He knew that public outrage could become its own form of punishment, and he had seen how quickly accusations could harden into conclusions.
But fairness did not mean pretending that nothing had happened.
The officer had made a decision.
That decision had consequences.
The consequences needed to be examined.
A black SUV turned into the driveway and stopped behind Sergeant Price's vehicle.
The driver was Detective James Simmons.
Simmons was in his early fifties, with silver beginning to show at his temples. He wore a dark jacket over a pale blue shirt and carried a leather folder under one arm. He was the kind of man who rarely appeared hurried, even when he was moving quickly.
He had spent more than twenty-five years in law enforcement. He had investigated robberies, fraud, assaults, and public-corruption allegations. He had also worked enough internal cases to know that the first account of an incident was often the one people became most determined to defend.
He approached Price.
“Sergeant. Dispatch said you requested a detective.”