“I did. We have a disputed vehicle stop involving Officer Dunley. The vehicle's authorization has been verified, but the detention and the use of restraints are being questioned.”
Simmons looked toward Marcus.
“That's Mr. Cole?”
“Yes.”
Simmons studied him for a moment, then extended his hand.
“Detective James Simmons.”
Marcus shook it.
“Marcus Cole.”
“I know.”
Marcus raised an eyebrow.
Simmons gave a small, tired smile.
“Cole Automotive Holdings has been in the news recently. Your company supplied the electric cruisers for the northern district pilot program.”
“That's one of our contracts.”
“I worked on the evaluation committee for that program.”
“Then you know the vehicles are built for long shifts.”
“I do. The battery performance has been better than expected.”
For a moment, the conversation resembled two professionals discussing a technical project.
Then Simmons glanced at Marcus's wrists.
The smile disappeared.
“I'm sorry this happened.”
Marcus nodded.
“Thank you.”
Simmons turned to Price.
“Walk me through it.”
Price explained the sequence as she understood it. She described the stop, the paperwork, the lack of active body cameras, the verification of the registration, and the removal of the handcuffs.
Simmons listened without interrupting.
When she finished, he asked Miller a few direct questions. He asked what he had seen, what he had personally verified, and when he had done it.
Miller answered carefully.
He admitted that the paperwork had been available early in the encounter. He confirmed that the vehicle identification number matched the system record. He also acknowledged that Dunley had refused his initial suggestion to run the registration.
Dunley objected.
“I did not refuse to investigate the vehicle.”
Simmons turned toward him.
“Did you run the registration before placing the driver in handcuffs?”
“No.”
“Did you examine the authorization form before placing him in handcuffs?”
“I looked at it.”
“Did you verify it?”
“Not immediately.”
“Why not?”
“Because I had concerns about the circumstances.”
“What circumstances?”
Dunley glanced at Marcus.
“The vehicle was unusual. The driver did not appear to be the typical owner of something like that.”
Simmons did not move.
“Explain what you mean by that.”
Dunley shifted his jaw.
“I mean the car was worth a significant amount of money, and I wanted to make sure everything was legitimate.”
“Was the driver in violation of a traffic law?”
“I didn't stop him for a traffic violation.”
“Was there an outstanding theft report?”
“Not that I knew of.”
“Did the vehicle's VIN return as stolen?”
“No.”
“Did the driver provide documents indicating authorization to use it?”
“Yes.”
“Then what specific fact caused you to believe the vehicle might be stolen?”
Dunley stared at him.
For several seconds, he said nothing.
Finally, he replied, “The overall situation.”
Simmons nodded slowly.
“That's not a specific fact.”
Dunley looked toward Sergeant Price.
“This is turning into an interrogation.”
“No,” Simmons said. “It's becoming a record of what happened.”
The words were delivered without anger.
That made them difficult to dismiss.
Marcus watched Simmons carefully. He had met many investigators who were skilled at sounding neutral while quietly steering a conversation toward a predetermined conclusion. Simmons was different, at least so far. He appeared willing to let the answers stand on their own.
That was all Marcus could reasonably ask at this stage.
The detective closed his folder.
“Mr. Cole, I would like to arrange a formal interview with you. I'll also speak with Miss Reed and the other witnesses. We need to secure the available recordings and documents before drawing conclusions.”
“I agree.”
“Do you have legal representation?”
“Yes.”
“Would you prefer to have your attorney present?”
“I'll coordinate with counsel and provide a statement through the appropriate process. I also want to make sure that any witness who is worried about retaliation has a way to report that concern.”
Simmons looked toward Tessa.
“Is that something you're worried about, Miss Reed?”
Tessa hesitated.
She glanced at Grant Holloway, who stood near the showroom entrance with his arms crossed.
“I don't know yet,” she admitted.
Simmons nodded.
“That's an honest answer. You don't have to decide everything on the sidewalk. But if anyone pressures you to change your account or discourages you from providing evidence, document it and contact the investigator assigned to this matter.”
Tessa felt a little of the tension leave her shoulders.
“Thank you.”
Marcus turned toward her.
“You did the right thing by telling the truth.”
She looked uncomfortable.
“I almost went inside.”
“But you didn't.”
“I was afraid I might lose my job.”
Marcus did not offer an easy promise.
“I can't tell you that there won't be consequences. I can tell you that you shouldn't have to choose between your livelihood and an honest account of what you witnessed.”
Tessa looked down at her phone.
“I recorded most of it.”
“Keep the original.”
“I will.”