At least, that was the story people told in Dry Creek.
Nathaniel had crossed the pass twice during his years as a scout. He remembered the cliffs, the difficult footing, and the strange way voices echoed through the canyon.
Now he stood beside Deputy Daniel Price and Peter Lang, examining Henry Talbot's unfinished survey.
The younger deputy traced a narrow line through the mountains.
"Harlan says Talbot was held here."
Nathaniel nodded.
"Yes."
Lang looked pale.
He had traveled from Miller's Crossing after receiving word of the arrests. When he learned that his former employer might still be alive, he insisted on helping identify the mine structures.
Price had been reluctant.
Lang was a civilian.
The region was dangerous.
And the search might involve armed men who had not yet surrendered.
But Lang possessed information the officers lacked.
He knew Talbot's final survey route.
He had helped measure the canyon.
And he remembered which entrances were unstable.
Now he pointed toward the northern slope.
"There's a second opening."
Nathaniel leaned closer.
"Where?"
"Above the old ventilation shaft."
Price frowned.
"Does it reach the lower workings?"
"Perhaps. I never explored it."
He hesitated.
"Henry believed the upper tunnel connected to the main shaft, but the company never provided a complete engineering plan."
Nathaniel studied him.
"What was the company mining?"
Lang lowered his eyes.
"Silver, officially."
"Unofficially?"
The survey assistant considered.
"Henry suspected there were more valuable deposits than the investors admitted."
Nathaniel looked toward the map.
That explained the pressure to acquire surrounding land.
But not why Talbot had been held for two years.
Unless the men controlling the operation needed his expertise to conceal the true mineral boundaries.
Price folded the map.
"We're not going in without proper preparation."
Nathaniel nodded.
The deputy continued.
"I've requested assistance from the territorial marshal. We need authority to inspect the site, enough personnel to protect anyone held there, and someone familiar with dangerous mine structures."
Lang agreed immediately.
Nathaniel felt impatient.
Every delay might endanger Talbot.
But he had survived enough fighting to know that rushing blindly into an unknown tunnel could create another tragedy.
He looked toward the hills.
"What can we do now?"
Price considered.
"Document the entrances and approach roads from a safe distance. Identify whether people are moving supplies. And send the information to the officers organizing the search."
Nathaniel nodded.
It was not dramatic.
But it was sensible.
Two days later, they reached Widow's Gate.
Nathaniel traveled with Price, Lang, and two experienced local guides. Ashkai had offered to share information about the surrounding routes, and one of his relatives, a middle-aged horseman named Daniel Nantan, accompanied the party after agreeing on the purpose of the journey.
The group did not attempt to enter the mine.
Instead, they examined the surrounding country.
Nathaniel noticed wagon tracks before they reached the basin.
Fresh.
Heavy.
Recently used.
He dismounted.
The wheel ruts were deep, suggesting substantial loads.
Lang crouched beside him.
"Those aren't old."
Nathaniel shook his head.
"No."
They followed the trail to a sheltered overlook.
Below stood the abandoned mining station.
Or what appeared abandoned from the main road.
The headframe leaned.
Several buildings had collapsed.
A broken ore cart rested beside rusted tracks.
But smoke rose from one chimney.
Two horses stood near a storage shed.
And men moved supplies between a wagon and the lower entrance.
Price watched through his field glass.
"Three visible."
Nathaniel studied the scene.
"Probably more inside."
Lang's hands began trembling.
For a moment, he seemed unable to breathe.
Then he pointed toward a building beside the main shaft.
"That was Henry's office."
Price looked at him.
"Are you certain?"
"Yes."
Lang swallowed.
"We kept our instruments there."
Nathaniel examined the structure.
One window was boarded.
Another showed light.
For two years, Lang had imagined Talbot dead.
Now the building where they once worked was occupied.
The young man leaned against a rock.
Nathaniel touched his shoulder.
"Easy."
Lang looked toward him.
"What if he's there?"
The rancher considered.
"Then we'll do everything we can to get him out."
"And if he isn't?"
Nathaniel did not answer immediately.
Then said, "We'll keep looking at the evidence."
Lang nodded.
They recorded what they saw.
Wagon movements.
Visible guards.
Occupied buildings.
Possible access routes.
Then withdrew before nightfall.
No shots were fired.
Nobody was confronted.
But they had confirmed one essential fact.
The supposedly abandoned mine was active.
And someone had been using it while the public was told the site was closed.
Back at Silver Hollow, Miriam read the report beside the kitchen table.
Nathaniel had repaired the broken windows with temporary boards.
The porch remained damaged.
The kitchen smelled of fresh bread.
Several of Ashkai's relatives had helped restore the cattle fence, and for the first time in years the ranch felt like a place where people came and went rather than a fortress against the world.
Miriam examined the report.
"Do you think Talbot is there?"
Nathaniel sat opposite her.
"I hope so."
She studied him.
"You sound uncertain."
"I am."
He rubbed his hands together.
"Harlan could be lying. Or Talbot might have been moved."
Miriam nodded.
Then looked toward Caroline's photograph.
For a moment, her expression softened.
"Carrie would've wanted the truth found."
Nathaniel glanced toward the mantel.
"Yes."
Miriam continued.
"But she would've wanted you alive afterward."
He smiled faintly.
"She used to say that."
"I know."
For several seconds, they sat quietly.
Then Nathaniel looked toward the map.
He had spent years believing his life's greatest struggle ended when Caroline died.
Now he found himself involved in something that reached beyond his property.
A missing surveyor.
A corrupt sheriff.
An outlaw gang.
Disputed water routes.
Families whose travel access had been threatened.
And a possible mineral scheme hidden beneath the western ridge.
He felt the old temptation to retreat.
To close the door.
Feed his cattle.
Let someone else handle the trouble.
Then he remembered six exhausted travelers standing at his fence.
Little Nia collapsing in the heat.
Eli offering him a blue stone.
Caroline's final note.
He took a breath.
He had already made his choice.
He would see the matter through as far as he could safely and responsibly help.
Even if it meant discovering truths he wished were different.
The search of Widow's Gate began six days after the siege at Silver Hollow.
By then, the territorial marshal's office had reviewed the available statements, including those from Grant Harlan, Peter Lang, Nathaniel Reed, and several witnesses connected to the freight operation.
The investigation concerned possible unlawful detention, theft, assault, and the use of false or altered land records.
The active mine and recent supply movements added urgency.
Marshal Edwin Shaw led the party.
He was a deliberate man in his fifties who preferred clear information to dramatic speeches. He had spent most of his career learning that an operation succeeded or failed according to what people understood before they arrived.
Price accompanied him.
So did several officers and a qualified mine foreman named Gabriel Ortega.
Nathaniel and Lang provided information about the location and older surveys but remained outside the most dangerous sections while the officers secured the site.
The approach took place early in the morning.