He had never seen the stranger before.
Yet something in the man's expression suggested recognition.
As though he had been waiting for Nathaniel to appear.
The rancher gathered the reins.
"Come on, Solomon."
They rode home beneath a sky beginning to darken.
Behind them, the red-bearded man entered the sheriff's office through the rear door.
The first strange tracks appeared five days after Ashkai's family departed.
Nathaniel found them near the northern boundary of Silver Hollow.
Three horses had approached from the southeast, crossed a narrow wash, and stopped on a ridge overlooking the ranch.
The riders had remained there long enough for their animals to shift repeatedly in the dirt.
Then they departed.
Nathaniel knelt beside the tracks.
He examined the shoe marks.
All three horses had been shod recently.
One carried a distinctive triangular nail pattern.
Nathaniel had seen similar work at the livery in Dry Creek.
He looked toward the ridge.
Someone had been watching his property.
Not merely passing.
He followed the tracks until they reached rocky ground.
Then they disappeared.
He returned home unsettled.
That afternoon, he found a broken branch near the western fence.
Freshly snapped.
A small strip of dark cloth caught on its edge.
He placed it inside his pocket.
Then rode to town.
Sheriff Kessler listened as Nathaniel described the tracks.
The sheriff leaned back in his chair.
"Probably travelers."
Nathaniel frowned.
"Travelers don't sit above my ranch for an hour watching the barns."
Kessler smiled faintly.
"How do you know it was an hour?"
"The horses left enough marks to show they stood around a while."
The sheriff considered.
"Maybe they were looking for water."
"Then why not come to the gate?"
Kessler sighed.
"Nathaniel, you spent years scouting. You know how easy it is to mistake ordinary movement for danger."
The rancher remained silent.
He did know.
War had taught him suspicion.
Sometimes the habit made life difficult.
But he had also survived because he noticed things others ignored.
He looked toward Kessler.
"Just thought you should know."
The sheriff nodded.
"And I appreciate it."
Nathaniel stood.
Before he left, Kessler added, "By the way, ever consider selling that western pasture?"
The question surprised him.
"What?"
"Your land."
Nathaniel frowned.
"No."
Kessler shrugged.
"Just asking. Some investors are looking at property near the ridge."
The rancher considered.
"Why?"
"Possible freight development."
Nathaniel nodded slowly.
"Not interested."
Kessler smiled.
"Fair enough."
The conversation seemed ordinary.
A friendly question.
Nothing more.
But later, riding home, Nathaniel remembered it.
The tracks on the ridge.
The sheriff dismissing them.
Then casually asking about his property.
He shook his head.
He was becoming suspicious of everyone.
That was no way to live.
Yet something continued troubling him.
A week later, a calf disappeared.
Nathaniel discovered the loss while counting his herd.
Thirty animals.
Then twenty-nine.
He rode the southern pasture twice.
No sign of a dead calf.
No predator tracks.
No blood.
Only hoofprints from several shod horses leading toward the lower road.
Someone had taken it.
Nathaniel followed the tracks for nearly three miles.
They eventually joined a well-used freight route.
There, the evidence became difficult to distinguish.
He returned to Dry Creek.
The town was already full of rumors.
Edwin Moss had lost two goats.
Another rancher reported a missing horse.
A farmer claimed someone entered his barn during the night.
People blamed Apache raiders almost immediately.
Nathaniel listened.
Then spoke.
"Did anyone see who took them?"
Moss frowned.
"No."
"Then how do you know?"
The cattleman glared.
"Who else?"
Nathaniel looked toward him.
"Grant Harlan's gang, perhaps."
Moss snorted.
"Could be working together."
"Could be."
Nathaniel folded his arms.
"But there's no proof of that either."
The discussion grew tense.
Then Sheriff Kessler entered the saloon.
He announced that Harlan had been spotted near the southern road.
The room became quiet.
Nathaniel watched.
The sheriff spoke carefully about the need for vigilance.
People should secure livestock.
Travel in groups.
Report strangers.
All reasonable advice.
Yet Nathaniel noticed something peculiar.
Kessler never suggested organizing a serious investigation into the thefts.
He spoke only about guarding what remained.
It was as though he expected the losses to continue.
Nathaniel looked toward him.
For a moment, he considered asking why.
Then stopped.
The sheriff had served Dry Creek for years.
He had helped settle disputes.
Protected travelers.
Assisted after storms.
Nathaniel trusted him.
Surely he was reading too much into ordinary caution.
He returned to the ranch before dark.
That evening, while repairing a saddle, he found Eli's blue stone inside his coat.
He turned it over.
The white stripe resembled a narrow river crossing.
He smiled faintly.
The boy's gift had become something he carried without thinking.
Then he looked toward the western mountains.
He wondered whether the six travelers had reached their relatives.
Whether Tomas's wound had healed.
Whether little Nia still played with the wooden horse.
He hoped so.
He had no reason to expect another meeting.
But he liked imagining them safe.
Outside, Solomon lifted his head.
The horse stared toward the northern ridge.
Nathaniel stopped working.
A distant light appeared among the rocks.
Then vanished.
He stood.
For several seconds, he watched.
Nothing.
He took a slow breath.
Then whispered, "What are you hiding out there?"
The mountains gave no answer.
The first clue to the larger mystery came from a dead surveyor's notebook.
Nathaniel found it accidentally.
He had ridden west to inspect a section of fencing damaged by winter runoff.
The trail crossed a narrow canyon where spring floods sometimes left driftwood and broken wagon parts trapped against rocks.
That afternoon, he noticed a piece of leather beneath a fallen tree.
At first, he thought it was a discarded saddlebag.
He dismounted.
Pulled it free.
Then discovered a small notebook inside.
Its pages were swollen by water.
Several were torn.
But the cover remained intact.
A name had been written across the first page.
Henry Talbot — Territorial Surveying Office.
Nathaniel frowned.
He recognized the surname.
Talbot had worked in the region nearly two years earlier, examining routes for a proposed freight road.