They Laughed When the Mountain Trapper Chose the Woman No Man Wanted. By Spring, Stone Hollow Learned Why He Had Chosen Her.

Chapter 3

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Greta remembered the fire. She had been nineteen. Otto had told her lightning struck the roof, though there had been no storm.

“You knew?” she whispered.

“I suspected.”

“Then why did you come to Stone Hollow?”

“I came for proof.”

The truth struck with brutal clarity.

“The mules.”

Anders nodded. “The gray carries Samuel’s old brand beneath a newer one. Otto sold her without noticing.”

Greta backed away.

“You didn’t come looking for a wife.”

“No.”

“You used me.”

“At first, I meant only to buy the animals.”

“But then you saw the ugly strong woman and thought she might be useful.”

“I never thought you were ugly.”

“You married me to get close to Otto.”

“No.”

“You just admitted—”

“I married you because when I asked whether you wanted out, I already knew I couldn’t leave you there.”

Greta’s eyes filled with tears she hated him for seeing.

“You should have told me.”

“Yes.”

“You made me believe someone had finally chosen me.”

“I did choose you.”

“For what?”

“For every winter I have left.”

She turned away.

Anders reached for her, but his broken leg held him back.

Greta slept in the shed that night.

At dawn, she saddled the gray mule.

“Where are you going?” Anders asked from the doorway, leaning on a carved crutch.

“Stone Hollow.”

“You can’t cross the pass alone.”

“I crossed an avalanche alone.”

“Greta, Otto is dangerous.”

“He’s my brother.”

“That never stopped him from stealing your life.”

She looked at Anders, wounded anger burning behind her pale eyes.

“You don’t get to decide what truth costs me.”

Then she rode away.

The journey took five days.

When Greta entered Stone Hollow, the townspeople barely recognized her. Her shoulders were squared beneath a fur-lined coat. Her braid was threaded with frost. A rifle rested across her saddle.

Otto emerged from the saloon.

“Well,” he called, “the mountain man send you back already?”

Men laughed.

Greta dismounted.

“I know about Samuel Kade.”

Otto’s smile vanished.

The street fell silent.

“You’ve been listening to that mad trapper?”

“I saw the old brand beneath yours.”

Otto moved closer. “You don’t understand.”

“I understand you stole horses.”

His hand shot out and gripped her arm.

“You’ll come inside.”

Greta looked down at his fingers.

“Let go.”

He tightened them.

Greta struck his wrist aside and shoved him so hard he fell backward into the mud.

Gasps swept the street.

Otto rose with murder in his eyes.

Then a voice sounded behind Greta.

“That’s far enough.”

Anders stood at the edge of the boardwalk, pale from the journey, one hand gripping a crutch and the other resting near his holster.

Greta stared at him.

“You followed me?”

“Slowly.”

Otto laughed. “You’ve got nothing. A faded brand and an old grudge.”

“I have more than that,” Anders said.

He reached inside his coat and removed a sealed ledger.

Greta recognized it instantly.

It belonged to the livery.

“Where did you get that?” Otto demanded.

“Greta packed it.”

She turned toward Anders. “I did not.”

Anders looked at her.

“No. But someone did.”

A thin figure stepped from behind the mercantile.

Elsie Bell.

The delicate woman in the yellow dress carried a bundle of papers against her chest.

“My father kept Otto’s accounts,” she said. “Before he died, he told me where the second ledger was hidden.”

Otto went white.

Elsie opened the book.

Inside were dates, stolen brands, payments, and one final entry written twelve years earlier:

**Paid L. Halvorsen twenty dollars to bar the rear door before the fire.**

Greta’s knees nearly failed.

“L. Halvorsen,” she whispered.

Otto shook his head violently. “That could be anyone.”

A voice came from the crowd.

“No.”

An elderly woman pushed forward.

Greta recognized her aunt, Louisa Halvorsen, who had vanished from town after the fire and had been presumed dead.

Greta stared as though seeing a ghost.

Louisa’s face was scarred along one side.

“I barred the door,” she said.

The crowd recoiled.

“But Otto told me the stable was empty. He said Samuel had already gone home. When I heard him screaming, I tried to open it, but the roof came down.”

Greta looked at her brother.

“You knew Samuel was inside.”

Otto’s mouth opened, but nothing came out.

Louisa continued, her voice shaking. “Otto threatened to say Greta helped us if I spoke. She was nineteen. I ran because I thought silence would protect her.”

Greta’s gaze dropped to the mud.

All those years, she had believed herself unwanted because she was too large, too rough, too unfeminine.

But Otto had done more than insult her.

He had quietly driven away every man who showed interest.

Not from shame.

From fear.

**If Greta married, she might leave. If she left, Otto would lose the one person whose labor kept his stolen business alive.**

The truth was uglier than anything she had imagined.

Otto suddenly lunged toward Elsie and the ledger.

Greta moved first.

She caught him across the chest, turned with his momentum, and drove him face-first into the watering trough. Anders seized Otto’s arm as the sheriff rushed from the crowd.

Within seconds, iron cuffs closed around Greta’s brother’s wrists.

No gunshot was fired.

No blood touched the street.

Only mud and silence remained.

By spring, Otto had been convicted of theft, fraud, and Samuel Kade’s murder.

News in the same category

They Laughed When the Mountain Trapper Chose the Woman No Man Wanted. By Spring, Stone Hollow Learned Why He Had Chosen Her.

7 Part