seventeen to nine -- I have heard those numbers all night in this room already, out of Gus like a rosary, and I'll
say what I said in ninety-nine and what I'll say in a courtroom if you make me: a rule that can only be kept by
stopping men from voting is not a rule.
It's a gravestone. And gravestones --" he laid his own hand down, flat and broad, on the Meridian folder, and
spoke, for the first time that night, not to Willa but past her, around the horseshoe, to the faces he knew wanted
feeding -- "gravestones don't pay for a roof. This hall needs a roof. This hall needs a septic field that passes
inspection, and a bar lease that isn't month to month with a landlord in Billings who'd sell this frontage out from
under us for a car wash. The county is going to reassess this land whether we sell it or not, and the taxes on
eleven acres of commercial frontage will eat this club in four years, and everybody at this table who isn't
romantic or eighty knows it. Meridian is offering four hundred and ten thousand dollars. Not someday. Now.
Four hundred and ten thousand, and the hall leased back to us for five years at a dollar a year while we find
ground we can afford, and a dividend -- yes, Willa, a dividend, I'll use the word in front of you, I'm not ashamed
of it -- a dividend to every patched member who has paid his dues into this place and swept its floors and buried
its dead, to do with as he sees fit.
There are men at this table with kids in braces and mortgages under water and mothers in care in Roundup."
His eyes found Gus's, deliberately, and held them, and the cruelty of it was that it was not cruelty, it was
arithmetic, and Gus knew the weight of that arithmetic in his own body's ledger better than any man alive. "You
had twenty-six years to object to the direction of this club, Willa Hart. You objected once, beautifully, and left.
Where was the trust when the escort work started? Where was the objection when the bar went in? A trustee
who sleeps for a quarter of a century -- my lawyer has a word for it, and the word isn't founder."
"Asleep," Willa said. It was the answer nobody in the room had prepared for, least of all Vance, whose
argument had been built, as good arguments are, to meet a denial. "Say the word whole, Roland. Your lawyer's
word is laches, or estoppel, and I know both of them, because I am not the only person in this valley who can
hire a lawyer and I did not spend the bus ride down here doing needlework. Yes. I slept. I will tell this room
why, since the room has been told, for twenty-six years, a version with the hard parts smoothed off it like a
stone in a pocket." She looked down at her hands where they lay on the charter, and for the first time that night
something went through her face that was not for the room, that belonged to a kitchen in Missoula in the small
hours and to a cedar chest and to a year, 1997, in which she had buried her husband in March and discovered,
by October, that grief is not a country a person visits but a climate she lives in, that it had soaked into the club
for her too, that every chair in this hall had Ellis not sitting in it.
"Ellis died," she said. "Then the club I had left in my heart before I left it in fact voted to be paid for the road
and to make this ground saleable, both in one year, and I stood up and did my duty by my own seventh rule, and
I walked out, and I found -- I am not proud of this, let the book show that too, Lorna -- I found that not looking
at it was the only way I could sleep. Clara asked me once why I never drove down, not once, not for Founders
Day, not for Gus when Marjory died, and I told her the club had made its choice. That was a lie of the kind you
tell a niece to spare her the real one. The real one is that I was afraid if I walked into this hall I would beg. Not
for my seat. For the sight of it. For one more evening of it as it was, at any price the present cared to charge me,
and I did not trust my own hands not to sign whatever was put under them for the sake of sitting here again
among the -- among the furniture of my life.
So I stayed away entirely, the way a drunkard stays away entire, and I let the trust sleep with me, and that is
my fault, and it is entered now, in front of witnesses, by my own mouth: I slept." She raised her head. "But the
trust, Roland, was not written for trustees who never sleep. It was written by a man who stammered over every
word a stranger ever asked of him and not over one word of this, and it says in person, at a called meeting,
before the vote. It does not say every year. It does not say without ceasing. It says before the vote. Look at