Two Freezing Twin Girls Asked Me To Give Santa Their Address — Then Whispered A Terrifying Secret About Their Mother

Chapter 29

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"The monster is in a cage forever," Hazel announced, "and Mommy was the bravest one in the whole building. Nora did a drawing of it."

"I drew the sun," Nora said, and held up a page of yellow so complete it had corners, "because we are outside now."

We stood there in the sun she had drawn, the five of us, in front of a building that had finally said out loud what a five-year-old had whispered on a street corner, and Clara turned her face up to the light like a woman reading it for the first time.

That night, back at the penthouse, she put Nora's drawing in a frame Mrs. Alvarez produced from somewhere, as Mrs. Alvarez produced everything, and hung it in the hall where the girls would pass it every morning.

"It's not a picture of the courthouse," Nora explained to me, in case I had misunderstood the commission. "It's a picture of after."

After. I thought about the word all evening, and about how the children had begun, without any of us teaching them, to divide their lives that way, and how everything on our side of that line was warm.

The summer came in like forgiveness.

After the trial, after the courthouse steps and the cameras, Clara slept for two days at the penthouse, and when she finally woke, there was a color in her face I had never seen before, not even in the good weeks of spring.

She came down to breakfast in a plain blue dress, the barefoot twins trailing behind her like ducklings, and said, out of nowhere, "The girls have never seen the sea."

"The sea is large," Hazel informed me, in case I had missed it. "Bigger than the park. Bigger than the whole city, probably."

"Probably," I agreed.

So we went to East Hampton.

Marcus drove, because Marcus always drove, and because he claimed the Long Island Expressway in July required a professional temperament. The girls pressed their faces to the windows the whole way and narrated everything they saw.

"That cloud looks like a sheep."

"That one looks like a sheep too."

"All the clouds are sheep, Nora."

""That one is a sheep with a hat."

Marcus stopped once, at a farm stand, because Hazel had read the word peaches off a sign at forty miles an hour and announced that stopping was now legally required.

He bought a bag of them without comment and handed it back over the seat, and Nora ate hers with the solemn concentration of a girl who intended to remember it."

The estate sat above the water, white and quiet, with a lawn that ran down past the pool to a private stretch of sand. I had owned it for eleven years and used it perhaps nine times, always alone, always for less than a week, always as a place to be unreachable in.

Hazel stood at the edge of the surf in her new swimsuit and treated the Atlantic Ocean as a personal challenge.

"It is going to knock me down," she announced.

"It is not."

"It is, but I am going to stand up every time."

Nora hid behind my leg and watched the waves the way she used to watch strangers, with one thumb near her mouth and her whole heart in her eyes. But she did not run. That was the thing about that summer. She did not run from anything anymore.

She gathered shells instead, with the gravity of a jeweler selecting stones, and presented each one to Clara for inspection, and by the end of the first day there was a line of them along the terrace rail, catalogued by size, guarded by Nora against all seagulls.

We hired a swim instructor, a patient woman named June who had taught half the children on the island, and within two weeks Hazel was paddling across the shallow end of the pool with her chin up and her face set like a small admiral.

Nora took longer. Nora always took longer, and then did things all at once, completely, as if she had been practicing in secret.

One morning she let go of the pool's edge, pushed off without a word to anyone, and swam four unaided strokes into June's waiting arms, and came up sputtering and shining.

"I did it," she said, astonished. "Hazel. Hazel, I did it."

"I saw," Hazel said, with enormous dignity. "I always knew."

Clara learned too, more slowly, in the evenings when the pool was empty. She had never been taught as a girl. She floated on her back that July with her hair spread out in the water and her eyes closed, laughing up at the sky like the illness had been something that happened to somebody else.

Nine months before, she had been coughing blood into a cloth in a basement. I did not say it aloud. Some measurements a man keeps to himself, like prayers.

And then Nora began to sing.

It started in the bath, of all places. Mrs. Alvarez reported it like a weather event. Then in the garden, among the roses, in a serious conversation with a butterfly. Then everywhere, all the time, as if a tap had been turned on somewhere inside her that had been shut for five years.

She had a small, clear, fearless voice, and she sang songs from the radio, songs June taught her, songs she plainly invented on the spot about the cat, the sea, the weather, my shoes.

The girl who had not spoken a word to a stranger in January sang at the breakfast table in July, with jam on her chin, at full and glorious volume.

"She found her voice in the water," Clara said one evening, watching them chase each other across the lawn in the last of the light. "Both of them did. I think they were just waiting to feel safe enough to be loud."

News in the same category

Two Freezing Twin Girls Asked Me To Give Santa Their Address — Then Whispered A Terrifying Secret About Their Mother

45 Part