What the Sheriff Locked in Cedar County Jail

Chapter 25

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Grace Ellison was the hardest part to talk about, even in my own head, because her courage had cost her more than mine had cost me. She was forty-four, a dispatcher, and she had kept a duplicate log when the official jail log started to lose entries. She had handed that duplicate over only through her lawyer, and I understood why. She still had to work in that building, or near it, and she still had neighbors who knew her name. When Delgado confirmed that the duplicate log matched the gaps in the official record — the missing breath test result of zero point zero zero, the missing phone call that I had been denied for eleven hours, the missing inhaler request, the missing envelope — I felt something loosen in my chest that I had not realized was still tight. It was not relief, exactly. It was proof that I had not imagined the night, that the paper had been keeping a second story all along, written by a woman who had been afraid and had written it down anyway. I never met Grace face to face during that phase. Delgado said that was deliberate, to protect her, and I respected it, even though part of me wanted to sit across from her and say thank you with my own voice. Grant told me there would be a time for that, later, if Grace wanted it. I hoped she would.

The investigation deepened in ways that were not dramatic on the surface. There were no sudden raids, no flashing lights outside my house, no scenes that would look good on television. There were subpoenas, and bank records, and tow logs from Griggs Towing that did not match the county's payment records, and interviews that lasted three hours and covered twenty minutes of real time. Wayne Griggs, fifty years old, owner of the towing company that had charged me six hundred eighty-five dollars plus three hundred ten dollars and then more in storage and fees that never quite added up, stopped returning Grant's calls and started returning them through a lawyer. Deputy Ray Mercer, forty-seven, who had been at the booking desk that night, gave a statement that Delgado described to Grant only as inconsistent with the log. Brantley, thirty-four, gave a statement that was shorter than Mercer's and, according to Grant, careful in the way a statement is careful when the person giving it knows that other people have already given theirs. Sheriff Wade Hollis, fifty-eight, gave a statement through counsel and said, in essence, that his office had followed procedure, that any discrepancies were clerical, and that I was mistaken about the stop, the search, and the money. I read Grant's summary of that statement twice, sitting at my kitchen table after Jordan had gone to bed, and I felt a cold, clean anger that was different from the fear I had felt in the cell. Clerical. As if a missing envelope and a missing inhaler and a missing eleven hours of phone calls were typos.

It was during that stretch, when the federal case was still being built and the grand jury had not yet been seated, that Hollis filed his countersuit. Or rather, his lawyer filed a defamation claim against me, saying that my complaints and my statements to investigators had damaged his reputation and his office, and asking for damages. Grant called me at work, between patients, and told me in the calm voice he uses when he does not want me to panic in a hallway. I stood in the supply room with a chart in my hand and listened, and for a moment the whole hospital seemed very far away. A countersuit was a tactic, Grant said. It was meant to make me quiet, to make me weigh the cost of speaking against the cost of being sued, to make other witnesses wonder whether speaking would bring a lawsuit to their own door. Monica called me that evening and said the same thing in blunter language, the way a sister and a civil-rights attorney can say it at the same time. They want you to flinch, she said. Do not flinch. I did not flinch in that conversation. Later, alone in my car in the hospital parking lot, I cried for about five minutes, not because I thought Hollis would win but because I was tired of being the person who had to keep proving that what happened to her had happened.

The dismissal, when it came, did not feel like a celebration. It felt like a door closing quietly. A judge reviewed the claim, heard Grant's argument that my complaints to law enforcement and to investigators were protected, that truth was a defense, and that the paper and the video and the log supported what I had said, and dismissed the defamation claim. Grant called me with the news, and Monica texted me a single line that said simply that it was done. I sat on my porch with my mother that evening, drinking sweet tea that had gone warm, and Ruth said that some victories do not need noise. She was right. I did not feel triumphant. I felt steadier, as if one more weight that had been hung on me to slow me down had been cut loose. The other witnesses heard about the dismissal too, and Grant told me later that it mattered to them more than any speech could have. If Denise could be sued for speaking and still keep speaking, then maybe they could too.

News in the same category

What the Sheriff Locked in Cedar County Jail

45 Part