After the witnesses, the prosecution turned to the evidence itself, and Special Agent Karen Delgado took the stand to present the federal investigation in a manner so orderly that it felt like watching a nurse lay out instruments before a procedure, each item in its place, each label clear. Delgado, forty-four, spoke without flourish, walking the jury through the audit that had followed the state investigation begun by Agent David Okonkwo, forty-one, whose early work had secured the dashcam and the cloud video before either could be lost or disputed. Delgado explained how investigators had gathered tow records, seizure logs, dispatch entries, bank deposits, and victim statements, and how, line by line, the numbers had added up to three hundred and eighteen thousand six hundred dollars taken from twenty-seven motorists over three years. She broke the total down carefully, because a large number can sound abstract until it is divided into its parts, and she showed the jury the fifty-eight thousand dollars in duplicate invoices from Griggs Towing, bills issued twice for the same tow, the same night, the same vehicle, with only the invoice numbers changed. She showed them the forty-one thousand five hundred dollars in unlogged cash seizures, money taken during stops and never entered into any official record, money that existed only in victims' memories and in the gaps where entries should have been. She showed them how the pattern repeated: a stop on a minor pretext, a tow ordered quickly, a seizure recorded incompletely or not at all, a bill inflated or duplicated, a complaint filed and then filed away. She connected my case to that pattern without overstating it, showing that my Griggs bill, six hundred and eighty-five dollars plus three hundred and ten dollars, sat inside the same system as Rosa's overcharge and James's double tow, and that Grace's missing one thousand two hundred dollar envelope sat inside the same gap as Terrence's unlogged cash. Okonkwo testified after her, more briefly, confirming the chain of custody for the dashcam and the cloud video, confirming that Jordan's upload had been verified with its original metadata, confirming that his written warning after the following near Meridian had been issued because following a complainant's family is intimidation whether or not it ends in a second arrest. The defence cross-examined both agents, suggesting that an audit can mistake sloppy bookkeeping for crime, that duplicate invoices might be clerical, that unlogged cash might be lost paperwork, but Delgado answered each suggestion with a document, and Okonkwo answered each with a date, and by the end of their testimony the word sloppy sounded thin in that courtroom, because sloppiness does not repeat itself in the same direction, toward the same tow company, for three years, across twenty-seven people.
The defence case, when it came, was shorter than I had feared, and in some ways that made it harder to listen to, because it did not try to explain the audit or the log or the dashcam. Instead, it tried to shrink them. Sheriff Hollis did not testify, which was his right, and his lawyers argued through witnesses and argument that stops involve judgment, that dispatch logs involve human error, that tow billing involves confusion between companies and counties, and that a sheriff managing a busy office cannot be held responsible for every entry a deputy or a contractor makes. Deputy Brantley testified briefly, saying he had acted on what he believed at the time, that the stop had seemed justified in the moment, that the detention had followed procedure as he understood it. Deputy Mercer testified similarly, his answers careful, his memory selective on the points that mattered most, the inhaler, the phone call, the delay. Wayne Griggs testified that his billing had been complex, that duplicate invoices were mistakes caught too late, that he had never intended to overcharge anyone. Each of them, in turn, asked the jury to believe that a system producing three hundred and eighteen thousand six hundred dollars in unexplained takings was the result of mistakes rather than design, and each of them avoided looking directly at Grace's log or Earl's video when those exhibits were mentioned. I sat in the second row and listened, and I thought about how different their testimony sounded from the testimony of the people who had nothing to gain: Earl, who had no connection to me; Grace, who risked her job; Rosa and Terrence and Alicia and James, who had come forward knowing they would be questioned. The defence witnesses spoke in generalities. The prosecution witnesses spoke in times and numbers and documents. I did not know what the jury would decide, and Samuel had warned me not to try to read their faces, but I could not help noticing that during the defence case several jurors stopped taking notes, as if they had already heard the part that mattered and were waiting for the argument to end.