The evening of the party, my mother laid the cream dress on my bed like a verdict. It was the color of unbuttered toast, high at the neck, long in the sleeve, the kind of dress meant to make a woman disappear in a bright room. I stood in my bedroom and looked at it, and then I looked at the closet door, behind which hung the emerald-green silk slip dress Naomi had given me for my birthday. It was the only beautiful thing I owned that no one in this house had chosen for me.
"You will wear the cream," my mother had said that morning, her voice flat as a ruler. "The emerald is too much. People will stare."
She said it as if people staring at me were a natural disaster we had to plan around, like rain on the gardenias. Five thousand imported gardenias, white as new linen, filled the ballroom downstairs, and the whole mansion smelled of them, sweet and cold at once. The chandeliers had been polished until they threw light across the ceiling in little hard diamonds. In the hallway, the caterers moved like ghosts in black and white, and from below I could hear the string quartet tuning, the low groan of a cello finding its note.
My name is Madeline Hartwell. I am thirty-one years old, the youngest daughter of Grant and Evelyn Hartwell, and I have lived in this house in Biltmore Forest, Asheville, North Carolina, for every one of those thirty-one years. My father is the chief executive of Hartwell Properties. My mother wears silver St. John and a diamond bracelet and has perfected the art of smiling at people while looking straight through them. My eldest sister, Claire, is the crown jewel of the family, in crimson tonight, and she runs the Hartwell Foundation the way other women run a salon: as a room where everyone important comes to be seen.
And I am the one who is not seen.
Naomi had given me the emerald dress in a plain brown box, with no card, because she knew my mother would read a card. "It is silk," she had said, pressing it into my hands in the back of her little shop, her voice low. "Emerald green. The color of the river after rain. Try it on when you are alone, and look at yourself, and remember that this is what you look like when nobody is telling you who to be." I had tried it on that night, in my bedroom, with the door locked, and I had stood in front of the mirror and barely recognized the woman looking back at me. She was not the forgotten daughter. She was not the girl in the service corridor. She was beautiful, and she was angry, and she was alive.
I had never worn it out of the house. My mother had found it once, hanging in the closet, and her face had gone still in the way it does when she is deciding whether to shout or to be cold. She chose cold. "That dress is not you, Madeline," she had said. "You are not a woman who wears emerald silk to a party. You are a Hartwell daughter. You wear cream. You blend in. You do not make a display of yourself." And then she had taken it off the hanger and folded it away, into the back of the closet, where it had hung ever since, waiting.
I thought of Ruth, my grandmother, as I stood there. Ruth had been the only person in this house who had ever looked at me and seen a person instead of a problem. She had died six years ago, when I was twenty-five, on a rainy afternoon, and I had stood at her burial with rain running down my face and thought: now there is nobody left who knows who I am. After she died, the house had gone quiet in a different way. Not peaceful quiet. The quiet of a room where someone has stopped speaking and everyone is pretending not to notice.
I put on the cream dress. I did what I was told, the way I had done what I was told for thirty-one years. I went down the back stairs, the service stairs, because that was my route. The ballroom was already filling. Two senators. Three bank presidents. Half of Asheville's old-money society, moving through the white light in their evening clothes, their laughter low and polished. The Hartwell mansion had never looked more like a palace, and I had never felt more like a servant in it.
My mother found me near the kitchen door. "Stay out of sight," she said, not unkindly, which was worse. "Stay in the service corridor. If Mr. Cole asks after anyone, he means Claire or Mason. You know how these men are. They get names wrong."
"Yes, Mother," I said.
She straightened my sleeve with two fingers, the way you might straighten a painting that hangs crooked. "Good girl."