When Billionaire Adrian Cole Stepped Into the Hartwell Mansion and Asked, in Front of Two Senators, Three CEOs, and Half of Asheville's Old-Money Society, "Where Is Madeline Hartwell?" Her Father Laughed Because He Honestly Thought Adrian Had Gotten the Name Wrong

Chapter 30

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Ms. Chen came back the next day with a second auditor, a quiet young man who spoke only when he had a number to give, and together they went through the Harbor Hands files grant by grant, all two hundred and fourteen of them, checking each receipt against each bank transfer, each approval against each signature. They worked without stopping for lunch. They asked me questions about the eight hundred and twenty dollars for Sarah's grandson, and about the six hundred dollars for the post office box, and about a grant of forty dollars for a bus pass for a boy in Swannanoa, and I answered all of them, because there was nothing in those files I was afraid to explain. Late in the afternoon, Ms. Chen closed the last folder and looked at me across the desk, and she said, "In fifteen years of auditing charities, Ms. Hartwell, I have never seen records this clean. Most organizations keep records to satisfy the law. You kept them as if the people you served might one day ask to see them." I thanked her, and after she left I sat alone in the office and thought about what she had said, and about the difference between a charity that kept its books for the law and a charity that kept them for the people, and I knew which one I had built.

The lawsuit was filed. The audit was under way. The smear was still spreading. And tomorrow night, four hundred people would gather in a ballroom to celebrate the Whitmore Gala, and my family would be there, and I had a decision to make about whether I would be there too.

The Wall Street Journal called on a Friday afternoon. Not a reporter from the local paper, not a blogger, but a woman from the Journal's financial investigations desk, and she did not ask me about the smear. She asked me about the shell companies.

"Ms. Hartwell, we have documents showing that three Delaware-registered entities received payments from the Hartwell Foundation and returned funds to accounts associated with your family's travel and personal expenses. Can you confirm that you provided these documents to your attorneys?"

I said that I could not comment on an ongoing legal matter, which was the sentence Marcus had taught me, and she said she understood, and then she asked me three more questions anyway, and I gave her the same sentence three more times, and then she thanked me and hung up.

Marcus called within the hour. He did not sound worried. He sounded like a man who had been waiting for this call for a very long time.

"The Journal has the evidence," he said. "Not all of it. Enough of it. The filings, the bank records, the travel receipts. Someone leaked it, and I am not going to ask you who, because it does not matter. What matters is that a national paper is about to print what your father has been hiding for four years, and once it is printed, it cannot be unprinted."

She asked me about the travel next, and about the filings, and about whether I had ever raised concerns with my father about the way the foundation spent its money, and I gave her the same sentence again, but inside my own head I was answering honestly. Yes, I had raised concerns. I had raised them at the dinner table when I was twenty-two, and my father had told me to mind my own business. I had raised them again when I was twenty-seven, and Claire had laughed and told me I did not understand how the world worked. I had raised them a third time, in writing, in a letter I had left on my father's desk, and the letter had disappeared, and no one had ever mentioned it again. I had learned, over the years, that raising concerns inside my family was like shouting into a room full of people wearing earplugs. They heard only what they wanted to hear. The Journal was different. The Journal listened, and the Journal checked, and the Journal wrote things down, and once something is written down in a paper that four hundred people at a gala will read over breakfast, it cannot be unheard.

I asked him who had leaked it. He paused, and then he said, "Let's just say that not everyone inside Hartwell Properties is loyal to your father anymore. Some people kept copies of things because they knew, sooner or later, someone would ask."

News in the same category

When Billionaire Adrian Cole Stepped Into the Hartwell Mansion and Asked, in Front of Two Senators, Three CEOs, and Half of Asheville's Old-Money Society, "Where Is Madeline Hartwell?" Her Father Laughed Because He Honestly Thought Adrian Had Gotten the Name Wrong

45 Part