While I was sitting in seat 1A waiting for Northstar Airways Flight 418 to depart, the captain stepped into first class

Chapter 10

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

“Were those decisions documented?”

“They should have been.”

“Were they?”

Vanessa looked down.

“Not always.”

Malcolm felt the weight of the answer settle between them.

“Thank you for being honest.”

She gave a small, uncertain nod.

“I haven't told you everything.”

Malcolm waited.

“There was an internal review two years ago. It identified weaknesses in the complaint system, including incomplete records and inconsistent follow-up. The review recommended an independent reporting channel.”

“Was that recommendation implemented?”

“Partially.”

“What does partially mean?”

“We updated the reporting guidelines, but we did not establish the independent channel.”

“Why not?”

“The executive committee decided that the existing process could be improved without creating another reporting structure.”

“Who made that decision?”

Vanessa closed her eyes briefly.

“Richard Haines chaired the committee.”

“Was the board informed?”

“I don't know.”

Malcolm stood.

“I would like a copy of that review.”

“I'll find it.”

“Please do not summarize it.”

“I understand.”

He opened the door.

As Vanessa followed him into the corridor, she spoke again.

“Mr. Reed?”

“Yes?”

“If you proceed with this investigation, people will become defensive. Some will tell you that the problems are exaggerated. Others will say you're using one incident to justify changes you've wanted to make for a long time.”

“Do you believe the problems are exaggerated?”

“I believe there are people who have been trying to report them for years.”

“Then what do you think I should do?”

Vanessa's eyes were tired.

“Listen to them before they decide you're just another executive who wants a report that says everything is fine.”

Malcolm nodded.

“That is exactly what I intend to do.”

Later that morning, Natalie brought him the first set of records.

They met in a private office on the executive floor. She placed a thick binder on the table and opened her tablet.

“The initial search returned forty-three complaints involving discrimination, retaliation, or inappropriate treatment by supervisors,” she said.

“Over what period?”

“Three years.”

“How many were confirmed?”

“Seven.”

“How many were dismissed?”

“Twenty-nine.”

“And the remaining seven?”

“Withdrawn, transferred, or closed for administrative reasons.”

Malcolm studied the summary.

“Why were twenty-nine dismissed?”

“The reasons vary. Insufficient evidence, inconsistent accounts, no corroborating witnesses, or the employee declining to participate.”

“Were the employees who declined to participate asked why?”

“Not consistently.”

“Were any of the accused managers promoted afterward?”

Natalie looked at the spreadsheet.

“Five received promotions or expanded responsibilities. Three transferred to different departments. One left the company.”

“Were any of the employees who filed complaints disciplined?”

“Yes. Eleven received formal performance warnings within six months of filing.”

Malcolm remained silent.

“Is that unusual?” Natalie asked.

“It could be. We need to know what happened in each case.”

She turned to another page.

“There is a further issue. Several complaints reference the same senior manager, but they were assigned to different investigators. The files don't indicate whether anyone examined the pattern across cases.”

“Who was the manager?”

“Richard Haines appears in two files. Vanessa Cole appears in one. The remaining references involve regional operations directors.”

Malcolm closed the binder.

“Have the original files been preserved?”

“We've issued a preservation notice. But we haven't confirmed that every archived document is intact.”

“Why not?”

“Some older records were migrated between systems. Others were moved to a third-party storage provider.”

“Who controls access?”

“Records management and the relevant department heads.”

Malcolm remembered the contractor in the lobby.

Depends which floor you're on.

He opened the binder again.

“Find the records management contractor who spoke to me this morning.”

Natalie looked surprised.

“Do you know his name?”

“No. He was carrying a stack of documents near the lobby elevators. His badge said records management.”

“I'll check the visitor log.”

“And Natalie?”

“Yes?”

“From this point forward, no executive should be able to alter, delete, or relocate relevant records without a documented preservation process and independent oversight.”

“Understood.”

She left to make the arrangements.

Malcolm spent the next hour reading the complaint summaries.

One file concerned a flight attendant who had reported a captain for making derogatory remarks about passengers. The employee's complaint had been marked resolved after a private meeting with the captain. Three weeks later, the employee's schedule had been changed, reducing the number of preferred international assignments.

Another file concerned a ground operations supervisor who had challenged a manager's instruction to bypass a safety check. The complaint had been dismissed as a communication issue. The supervisor had resigned four months later.

A third involved a passenger who claimed that a crew member had treated him with unusual hostility. The airline had issued a refund and closed the case, but no interview with the crew had been recorded.

Different people. Different circumstances.

The same recurring problem: the organization seemed more interested in ending complaints than understanding them.

At noon, Natalie returned.

News in the same category

While I was sitting in seat 1A waiting for Northstar Airways Flight 418 to depart, the captain stepped into first class

30 Part