“Not necessarily. Your travel profile has restricted visibility, but certain senior operations employees can access it when an exception is required.”
“Could Captain Parker see it?”
“Possibly, depending on which screen he used.”
Malcolm looked out the window.
“Find out exactly what he could see and when he saw it.”
“Do you believe he knew who you were before he challenged you?”
“I don't know.”
“Would it change the investigation if he didn't?”
Malcolm took a moment to answer.
“It might change the explanation. It should not change the standard.”
Natalie entered the instruction into her tablet.
The car merged onto the highway.
For several minutes, neither spoke.
Then Natalie said, “I read the old employee review after your message came through.”
“And?”
“It isn't as reassuring as the summary made it sound.”
“What did you find?”
“Several employees described a pattern in which complaints were closed after managers spoke privately with the people involved. There are also references to schedule changes following complaints.”
“Was retaliation confirmed?”
“Not formally.”
“Why not?”
“Because the investigators couldn't establish a connection between the complaints and the schedule changes.”
Malcolm frowned.
“Did they examine the timing?”
“According to the report, yes. But the records were incomplete.”
“Incomplete how?”
Natalie glanced at her notes.
“Some schedule amendments had no recorded explanation. A few employee statements were missing from the final files. In several cases, the employee was described as unwilling to cooperate, even though the file did not contain a request for further information.”
Malcolm felt the familiar pressure building behind his eyes.
“Who approved the review?”
“Human Resources, Legal, and the Operations Compliance Committee.”
“And who approved the final summary?”
“Chief Operating Officer Richard Haines.”
Malcolm wrote the name down.
“Get me the original review, every draft, and the underlying records.”
Natalie nodded.
“There's something else I should tell you. The chief operating officer has already requested a meeting with you tomorrow.”
“Did he mention Flight 418?”
“No. He said he wanted to discuss the employee review.”
Malcolm looked at her.
“How convenient.”
Natalie did not smile.
“Would you like me to postpone the leadership meeting?”
“No. Keep it.”
“Do you want me to invite legal counsel?”
“Yes, but not the company's regular internal investigator. I want an independent reviewer with no prior relationship to the executives involved.”
“I'll begin looking.”
Malcolm leaned back.
He had spent eighteen months trying to understand Northstar's problems. Now, within a single afternoon, several previously disconnected concerns had begun to form a pattern.
An employee review that could not explain missing records.
A complaint process that seemed to protect managers more effectively than employees.
A corporate communications team that wanted to choose a conclusion before collecting evidence.
And a captain who had believed that his authority gave him the right to decide which passenger belonged in first class.
Perhaps the incident had not revealed an isolated failure.
Perhaps it had revealed the same problem at several levels of the organization.
Northstar had become skilled at protecting its image.
Malcolm wanted to know whether it was equally committed to protecting people.
That evening, he met Arthur Whitmore in a private conference room at the hotel.
Arthur was sixty-four, silver-haired, and impeccably dressed. He had served on Northstar's board for eleven years and had supported Reed Capital's acquisition when several other investors believed the airline was too troubled to rescue.
He greeted Malcolm warmly.
“I'm glad you're safe.”
“Thank you.”
“I understand the incident was unpleasant.”
“It was revealing.”
Arthur's smile faded slightly.
“Let's be careful with that word. One employee's behavior should not define an entire company.”
“I agree.”
“Good. Because I want to avoid an overreaction.”
Malcolm sat down.
“What would an appropriate reaction look like?”
“A formal review, perhaps a conversation with the captain, and a reminder about customer service.”
“Would that be enough if the incident reflected a wider pattern?”
Arthur folded his hands.
“We don't know that it does.”
“That's why I want an investigation.”
Arthur exhaled.
“Malcolm, the airline has been through a difficult period. We've stabilized the finances, rebuilt several routes, and restored confidence among our creditors. A public controversy could undo some of that progress.”
“Are you suggesting we avoid investigating the incident because the findings might be embarrassing?”
“I'm suggesting that leadership requires proportion.”
“And I agree. Proportion begins with facts.”
Arthur studied him.
“You've always been thorough.”
“I intend to remain that way.”
“What do you want from the board?”
“An independent review of the incident, a preservation order for relevant records, and an examination of the employee complaint process.”
Arthur's expression became more serious.
“That is a much larger undertaking than a passenger complaint.”
“Perhaps the complaint has exposed a larger problem.”
“And if it hasn't?”
“Then the evidence will show that.”
Arthur leaned back.
“I'll speak with the other directors.”
“Please do.”
The meeting ended without agreement.