"And the third?"
"A family claimed the captain publicly questioned whether their teenage son belonged in the premium cabin."
Malcolm closed his eyes briefly.
"How were they resolved?"
"All three were closed."
"Why?"
"Insufficient evidence."
"Was there witness information?"
"Yes."
"Was it examined?"
"Not consistently."
Elaine paused.
"There's another detail."
"What?"
"Two of the complaints were reviewed by the same regional manager."
"Who?"
"Gregory Mills."
Malcolm looked toward the window.
The name matched Luis's earlier statement.
He spoke slowly.
"Then we need to examine Gregory Mills's decisions."
"Agreed."
"Don't assume he acted improperly. Establish the record."
"That's exactly what we're doing."
Malcolm ended the call.
He sat quietly for several minutes.
The incident aboard Flight 418 had started with one captain and one passenger.
But the records suggested something broader.
The captain's conduct might not have been isolated.
The reporting process might not have been independent.
And managers who were supposed to protect professional standards might have been responsible for closing the very complaints that challenged them.
Malcolm opened his notebook.
He wrote:
A system does not become fair because it has a policy. It becomes fair when people can use that policy without fear.
He underlined the sentence.
Then he called Naomi.
"We need to prepare for a difficult meeting."
"With whom?"
"Gregory Mills."
Naomi paused.
"Do you want me there?"
"Yes."
"Should Richard attend?"
Malcolm considered it.
"Not yet."
"Why?"
"Because I want to understand the decisions before anyone starts defending them."
Naomi agreed.
The next morning, Gregory Mills would be asked to explain why so many complaints had disappeared without meaningful investigation.
And Malcolm suspected the answers would reach much farther than one captain.
THE MAN WHO HAD NEVER BEEN QUESTIONED
Gregory Mills arrived at Northstar headquarters at 8:15 a.m.
He wore a charcoal suit, a pale-blue shirt, and a silver watch.
At fifty-four, he had spent almost twenty-five years in the airline industry.
He began as a flight attendant before moving into cabin supervision.
His career had progressed steadily.
Regional supervisor.
Senior cabin manager.
Director of Northeast Guest Operations.
His current position gave him influence over more than four hundred flight attendants and several dozen cabin supervisors.
Gregory believed he understood people.
He believed he could identify difficult passengers within seconds.
He believed experienced employees deserved discretion.
And he believed the airline had become too sensitive about customer complaints.
He entered the conference room carrying a leather briefcase.
Naomi Bell was already seated.
Elaine Porter sat beside her.
Malcolm stood near the window.
Gregory approached with a practiced smile.
"Good morning, Mr. Reed."
"Good morning, Gregory."
"I understand we're discussing the Flight 418 situation."
"Among other things."
Gregory placed his briefcase on the table.
"I want to begin by saying that Captain Parker is an excellent pilot."
Malcolm gestured toward a chair.
"Please sit."
Gregory did.
Elaine opened her folder.
"Mr. Mills, we're reviewing several passenger complaints that were closed through your regional office."
Gregory nodded.
"I've heard about that."
"Good. Then let's begin with the oldest case."
Elaine displayed a record.
The complaint involved a passenger named Thomas Bennett.
Thirty months earlier, Bennett had traveled from Boston to Miami with his wife.
He had been assigned a premium cabin seat.
During boarding, Captain Parker had allegedly approached him and questioned whether he had been assigned the correct seat.
Bennett stated that the captain's tone was dismissive.
He also alleged that the captain asked whether he had purchased the ticket himself.
Gregory read the summary.
"I remember the general issue."
"How was it resolved?"
"We reviewed the reservation and found no discrepancy."
"Was the captain interviewed?"
Gregory nodded.
"Yes."
"Was the passenger interviewed?"
"I believe so."
Elaine looked at the record.
"There is no interview transcript."
Gregory frowned.
"It was a long time ago."
"Was a written statement collected?"
"I don't recall."
Elaine displayed another page.
"The case was closed two days after the complaint was submitted."
Gregory shrugged.
"That isn't unusual."
"Was the closure based on a completed investigation?"
"It was based on the information available."
"Which information?"
Gregory looked uncomfortable.
"We spoke with the captain."
"Did you speak with the cabin crew?"
"I don't remember."
"Did you examine the boarding records?"
"Probably."
"Did you contact the passenger?"
Gregory looked toward Naomi.
"Are these questions going to be about every individual complaint?"
Elaine answered.
"They are about complaints that were closed without a complete record."
Gregory leaned back.
"I understand. But you have to appreciate the realities of airline operations. We receive thousands of customer complaints. Not every disagreement can become a formal investigation."
"Agreed," Elaine said.
"Then we need reasonable judgment."
"Absolutely."
Elaine turned to another page.
"But judgment must be supported by evidence."
Gregory remained silent.
Malcolm finally spoke.
"Gregory, I want to ask you something."
"Certainly."
"What did you understand your responsibility to be when you received a complaint about a captain?"
Gregory answered immediately.
"To determine whether the employee had violated policy and whether the customer had a legitimate grievance."
"And if the captain's account differed from the passenger's?"
"We assessed credibility."
"How?"
"Experience. Operational history. Available documentation."
Malcolm nodded.