"Did you consider that a passenger might be reluctant to challenge a captain publicly?"
Gregory paused.
"Possibly."
"Did you consider that a junior flight attendant might be reluctant to contradict a senior pilot?"
"That's possible."
"Did your procedure account for that?"
Gregory shifted.
"Our procedure was designed to be practical."
Malcolm looked at him.
"Was it designed to be independent?"
Gregory hesitated.
"Management has to be involved."
"That wasn't my question."
Gregory looked toward Elaine.
She waited.
Finally, he said:
"No. Not always."
Elaine made a note.
Malcolm leaned back.
"Let's discuss Captain Parker's most recent complaint."
Gregory's expression changed.
"Which one?"
"The family who reported that he questioned whether their teenage son belonged in the premium cabin."
Gregory looked down at the document.
"I remember that case."
"What happened?"
"The family was unhappy with the captain's communication."
"Was the son assigned a valid seat?"
"Yes."
"Was the ticket purchased normally?"
"Yes."
"Was there a security issue?"
"No."
"Was there a medical issue?"
"No."
"Then what was the reason for questioning his presence in the cabin?"
Gregory folded his hands.
"I believe the captain was attempting to prevent confusion."
"Was there confusion?"
"I don't know."
"Did you investigate?"
"We reviewed the complaint."
"That wasn't my question."
Gregory looked irritated.
"We spoke with Captain Parker."
"Did you speak with the family?"
"I believe customer relations handled that."
"Did you review the crew statements?"
Gregory looked at the record.
"No."
"Why not?"
"Because the matter was considered a customer-service issue rather than a conduct investigation."
Malcolm stared at him.
"Who made that classification?"
"I did."
"Based on what?"
Gregory hesitated.
"The captain's explanation."
The room became quiet.
Elaine closed her folder.
"Mr. Mills, you classified the complaint as a customer-service issue because the captain said it was a customer-service issue?"
Gregory's face reddened.
"That's not how I would describe it."
"Then how would you describe it?"
Gregory looked toward Malcolm.
"I've spent twenty-five years in this industry. I know how difficult passengers can be. Some people deliberately create problems. They challenge employees, record conversations, and use complaints to demand compensation."
Malcolm nodded.
"Those passengers exist."
Gregory seemed relieved.
"Exactly."
"But so do employees who abuse their authority."
Gregory stopped speaking.
Malcolm continued.
"Your job was not to decide that one side was automatically right. Your job was to establish what happened."
Gregory looked down.
"I made decisions based on the information I had."
"Then let's examine how you obtained that information."
Elaine opened another document.
It contained a list of complaints associated with Gregory's regional office.
There were twenty-three cases in which a passenger had alleged unequal treatment.
Seventeen had been closed without a formal interview of the employee who submitted the report.
Eleven had been categorized as customer-service misunderstandings.
Seven involved Captain Parker.
Five involved other senior crew members.
Gregory studied the list.
"These numbers are misleading."
Elaine remained calm.
"Why?"
"Because they don't include the context."
"That's why we're interviewing you."
Gregory looked toward Malcolm.
"Are you suggesting I deliberately protected certain employees?"
Malcolm answered carefully.
"I'm suggesting that your decisions deserve examination."
"That's not the same thing."
"Correct."
Gregory leaned back.
"Then I hope this investigation recognizes the pressure regional managers operate under."
"It will."
"Because we have staffing shortages, schedule disruptions, passenger conflicts, and operational targets. Sometimes you have to make quick decisions."
Malcolm nodded.
"That is true."
Gregory seemed encouraged.
But Malcolm continued.
"However, speed cannot become an excuse for unfairness."
Gregory's expression changed.
After Gregory left the room, Elaine turned toward Malcolm.
"He is defensive."
"That doesn't establish misconduct."
"No. But the records are concerning."
Naomi opened her laptop.
"There's something else."
Malcolm looked at her.
"What?"
"Gregory has a strong performance history. His region consistently reports high complaint closure rates."
"How high?"
"Between ninety-two and ninety-six percent."
Elaine looked at the data.
"That's unusually consistent."
Naomi nodded.
"His department also received several internal awards for customer-service efficiency."
Malcolm looked toward the screen.
"Who evaluated those awards?"
"Richard Coleman approved the regional performance criteria."
The room became quiet.
Malcolm leaned forward.
"Does Richard have direct authority over Gregory?"
"Yes."
"Then we need to examine the incentive structure."
Elaine opened another document.
"I already requested the regional performance framework."
She displayed a table.
Regional managers were evaluated on several measures:
-
Passenger complaint closure rate.
-
Average complaint resolution time.
-
Customer satisfaction scores.
-
Crew productivity.
-
Operational efficiency.
There was no separate measure for the quality of investigations.
There was no meaningful penalty for closing a complaint without a documented review.
There was no independent measurement of whether employees felt safe reporting misconduct.
Malcolm stared at the table.
"Who designed this?"
Naomi answered.
"Operations and customer experience, with approval from the executive committee."
Malcolm recognized the implication.
The problem might not be confined to Gregory.
It might be embedded in the way Northstar measured management success.
He looked toward Elaine.
"Can you determine whether the incentives influenced complaint classifications?"
"Yes. It will take time."
"Take it."
Naomi closed her laptop.
"We may need to speak with Richard."
Malcolm nodded.
"But first, I want to speak with some of the people whose complaints were closed."