“The court can hear your testimony before he has time to act.”
Fitch shook his head. “You don't understand. My daughter has a lung sickness. We moved here because the air is dry. If we lose the house, she may not survive another winter.”
Caleb's anger eased into something heavier. He remembered the ranch boys hauling burning hay and Miguel standing beside the well. Every decision in this fight reached people who had not chosen it.
“Come to my ranch,” he said. “You and your daughter. We have a warm room, and Dr. Shaw can visit.”
Fitch stared at him. “Why would you do that?”
“Because I need your testimony. And because a child shouldn't pay for what her father did.”
The man sat on a feed barrel, covering his face with his hands. Nora waited. She had learned that people sometimes needed a moment in which no one demanded anything of them.
At last Fitch agreed. He went to the house to pack while Caleb saddled a spare mule from the barn. Nora helped the girl, whose name was Lily, fold a quilt and gather three treasured books. Lily asked whether there were horses at the ranch.
“More than you can count from the porch,” Nora told her.
“I can count very high.”
“Then we'll find out how high.”
They were preparing to leave when the dog began barking again. A wagon appeared on the road, driven by a man in a brown coat. He stopped beside the orchard and raised both hands to show he was unarmed.
“Message for Mr. Fitch,” he called. “From the freight company.”
Caleb moved between the wagon and the house. “Leave it on the gate.”
The man did so, then turned his wagon around. Nora waited until he was out of sight before retrieving the envelope. Inside was a blank sheet and a small brass button. Fitch recognized the button immediately. It had come from the coat his older brother wore when he vanished from Red Basin two years earlier.
“They told me he went west,” Fitch whispered.
Nora felt the air leave her lungs. The threat was no longer about land. It was about a man who might have disappeared because he knew too much.
Caleb took the button and examined its worn back. “Could someone else have had his coat?”
“Maybe. But why send this now?”
“To make you afraid,” Nora said. “Or to tell you they know where you are.”
They set out quickly, taking the creek bed rather than the main road. Lily rode the mule with her quilt wrapped around her shoulders. Fitch carried the biscuit tin beneath his coat. Caleb stayed behind the group, watching the ridge. Nora rode beside Lily, telling her about the barn cats and the apple trees at the Mercer ranch.
Halfway home they found a fallen pine blocking the narrow pass. Caleb dismounted to inspect it. The cut was fresh and straight. Someone had felled the tree deliberately.
“Back,” he ordered.
A shot cracked from the rocks above. The bullet struck the mule's saddle horn. Lily screamed. Caleb pulled the child behind the fallen trunk while Nora dragged Fitch toward a shallow ditch. Another shot splintered the bark near her hand.
Caleb fired toward the muzzle flash, not to hit the shooter but to force him behind cover. Then he shouted to Nora, “Take the creek bed. I'll follow.”
She refused to leave until he moved. Together they lifted Lily onto Penny, where the girl clung to Nora's waist. Fitch led the mule, and Caleb covered the retreat. The attackers fired twice more, then stopped. They had expected frightened riders to scatter; instead the group moved as one.
They reached open ground after sunset. Caleb's sleeve was torn, and a thin line of blood marked his upper arm where a splinter had cut him. Nora cleaned the wound at the creek. Lily watched with solemn attention.
“Are you going to die?” the child asked.
“Not from this,” Caleb said. “I've had worse from a stubborn fence.”
Lily considered that. “Then I don't like fences.”
“Neither do I, sometimes.”
They arrived at the ranch long after dark. Miguel met them with lanterns, and the cook prepared a meal for the newcomers. Fitch placed the original order in Caleb's hands before entering the house.
“Take it to the judge,” he said. “Tell him everything. Even the part I did.”
Caleb looked at the document, then at the exhausted man who had finally chosen to speak. “You can tell him yourself.”
Fitch nodded. “I will.”
Nora watched Lily fall asleep beside the kitchen stove, her quilt tucked beneath her chin. The rescue had not ended with finding a paper. It had brought a frightened family into their care and placed another life within reach of Voss's men. Yet for the first time, the missing order existed outside the company's control.
In the morning, Nora thought, they would take it into court. Tonight she sat beside the stove and listened to the small, steady breathing of a child who had survived the road.
The hearing resumed beneath a sky the color of pewter. Rain drummed against the courthouse windows, and the public gallery filled before the clerk opened the doors. Miners came in work clothes, ranch families in their Sunday coats, and railway men with grease still on their cuffs. Word of the original gate order had traveled through the county overnight. Some people came hoping to see Voss disgraced. Others came hoping the document was false, because their wages depended on the railway he promised.
Judge Harrow called the room to order. Bellamy rose at once to challenge the authenticity of the paper. He argued that a document kept for twelve years in a hollow tree could not be trusted.
Nora expected this. She had prepared a chain of testimony rather than a dramatic speech. Ruth identified the paper stock used by the Saint Agnes office. Keene identified the engineering notation. Fitch admitted that he had removed the page from the official file and explained why. Finally Caleb identified his father's handwriting, describing the peculiar way Thomas crossed the letter t in technical notes.