Finally Trent said, “A woman alone in these mountains can come to harm.”
Caleb held his gaze. “That's true.”
The deputy wheeled his horse. The others followed, though the stranger turned once to study the cabin roof. Caleb waited until the last hoofbeat faded before lowering the rifle. He knew better than to believe the search was over.
Nora emerged from the cellar shaking with anger. “They'll return.”
“Yes.”
“You should have handed me over. They could burn this place.”
“They might.”
“Then why didn't you?”
Caleb looked at the compass in her hand and the dark bruises on her face. Beyond the clearing the clouds were opening, revealing a ridge striped with old snow. He remembered his mother saying that courage was rarely loud; often it was merely the decision not to close a door.
“Because,” he said, “you asked for shelter, and they asked for you.”
That evening he repaired the mare's shoe and moved the horses into a concealed ravine. Nora made soup from beans and the last onion in the pantry. They ate without discussing the men. At dusk she placed the brass compass between them and opened its hinged lid. Beneath the needle was a folded strip of paper marked with coordinates and one sentence in a precise hand: THE PASSAGE WAS NEVER SAFE.
Caleb knew the coordinates. They pointed toward the abandoned Saint Agnes mine, where an avalanche had killed seventeen men twelve winters earlier. His father had been blamed for the disaster. Caleb had spent half his life trying not to think about that place.
Nora watched recognition cross his face. “You know it.”
He touched the paper but did not take it. “I know the mountain.”
“Then you know why they want this.”
“No,” he answered, hearing the old mine in the silence between them. “But I intend to find out.”
At dawn the valley lay beneath a crust of white frost. Caleb had slept in the stable, giving Nora the cabin and its single narrow bed. He woke to the sound of a hammer and found her outside fastening a loose shutter with a bent nail. Her movements were careful, but she had removed the bandage from her wrist and tied her hair back with a piece of blue ribbon.
“You could have woken me,” he said.
“You could have asked me to leave.”
“Are we going to have this argument every morning?”
“Perhaps until I know whether you mean what you say.”
Caleb handed her a proper nail. “Then we'd better get you a better hammer.”
They worked through breakfast, reinforcing the shutter and packing supplies for a journey neither had yet agreed to make. Caleb knew the abandoned mine road well enough to find it blindfolded. His father, Thomas Mercer, had worked as an engineer for the Saint Agnes Company before the collapse. In the official account, Thomas had approved the timber supports despite warnings from miners. He had died of fever two years later, still insisting that his inspection report had been altered.
Nora listened while Caleb explained this. She did not interrupt until he mentioned the report.
“Was the inspector's name Walter Keene?”
Caleb stopped winding rope. “Yes.”
“He was my employer.”
She drew the torn envelope from her pocket. Inside was a photograph of a stone bridge, a narrow sheet of figures, and a receipt bearing Keene's signature. Nora explained that she had worked as a draftsman's assistant at a rail survey office in Helena. Keene had hired her because she could copy maps without changing their scale and because, he said, she had a conscience. Six weeks earlier he had shown her discrepancies in the mine's original safety calculations. A new railway spur was being planned through the same mountain, and the investors intended to reuse an old tunnel that had never been stabilized.
“Keene was going to testify,” she said. “Then he disappeared.”
“Disappeared how?”
“He left his boardinghouse one night and never came back. Two men searched the office the next morning. They said he had stolen payroll money. I found his notes beneath the drawing board before they reached me.”
“And Trent?”
“He stopped my train outside Alder Creek. Said he had a warrant. When I asked to see it, one of the men hit me.”
Caleb's jaw tightened. “How did you escape?”
“I opened the baggage door while they argued over my satchel. The train was moving slowly near a grade. I jumped into a ditch, found a horse at a deserted farm, and rode until I couldn't see the tracks.”
“You stole a horse.”
“I left my watch and a note.”
“That might not persuade the owner.”
“It was a good watch.”
Caleb almost smiled. Then he unfolded the sheet of figures. He recognized his father's handwriting in the margin: a small, angular notation beside the load calculations. Thomas had used a distinctive symbol for water pressure, a triangle crossed with a line. The symbol appeared three times.
“These are copies,” Caleb said. “Where are the originals?”
Nora looked toward the mountain. “Keene believed they were sealed in an inspection chest somewhere near the mine. He said the company couldn't destroy them without revealing the alteration.”
“Why not?”
“Because the new railway investors requested an audit. Someone needs to produce the old papers to prove the tunnel is safe.”
“Then they're gambling that nobody knows where to look.”
“Or that anybody who knows will be frightened into silence.”
Caleb thought of Trent and the stranger in the red scarf. “That gamble has worked before.”
They rode after noon, taking a cattle trail that bypassed the main road. Nora rode the dun mare, whom she called Penny after learning the animal had no name on her borrowed halter. Caleb carried a second rifle and enough food for three days. He told his ranch foreman, Miguel Santos, only that he was checking the upper grazing leases. Miguel was a man of few questions and a sharp eye. He noticed Nora's injuries and said simply that the ranch would be ready if they needed it.