By midafternoon they reached a narrow gorge where the river ran between black cliffs. A bridge had once crossed it, but only two stone piers remained. Caleb dismounted to examine the far bank. Nora studied the photograph Keene had left her, then turned it upside down.
“This isn't the bridge,” she said.
“It looks like it.”
“Look at the shadows. The sun is behind the photographer. The water should be flowing toward him, but in this picture it's going away.”
Caleb took the photograph. The river had changed course after the avalanche, yet the cliff shapes matched. He followed her finger to a square shadow beneath the western pier. There, nearly hidden by willow branches, was a narrow maintenance opening.
They tied the horses and climbed down. Inside the opening, cold air smelled of wet stone and iron. A shallow channel carried water through the masonry, and a rusty chain hung from the ceiling. Nora knelt beside an old brass plate bolted to the wall.
“Flood bypass,” she read. “Manual release.”
Caleb remembered his father speaking of such a passage. It had been built to drain snowmelt away from the mine tunnel, but the company had sealed it after a costly inspection. If the bypass had failed, water might have undermined the timber supports before the avalanche.
Nora traced a fresh scratch on the bolt head. “Someone's been here recently.”
Footsteps sounded above them. Caleb extinguished the lantern with his fingers and drew Nora into the deeper shadow. Two men crossed the stones overhead. Their voices drifted down through the opening.
“The deputy says she was at Mercer's place,” one said.
“Then burn the place.”
“Not until the papers are found. Voss wants the girl alive.”
The other man spat. “And Mercer?”
“He can join his father.”
The footsteps receded. Nora remained perfectly still, her hand locked around Caleb's sleeve. He could feel her breathing quicken. The men had named their employer, and Caleb knew that name too. Gideon Voss was the railway promoter who had bought Saint Agnes's debts after the disaster. He was now the richest man in the county.
“We should go back,” Caleb whispered.
“No. We came for evidence.”
“Evidence isn't worth dying for.”
“Walter Keene may already have died for it.”
Caleb had no answer. He led her along the drainage passage until they found a small chamber where an iron lever protruded from the wall. Above it someone had carved the letters T.M. into the stone. Caleb touched the initials. His father had been there.
A metal box sat behind a loose brick. Inside were a broken pencil, a child's marble, and a page from a field notebook. Most of the writing had been blurred by water, but one sentence remained legible: THE GATE WAS CLOSED BY ORDER OF G.V. — NOT BY ENGINEERING ADVICE.
Nora held the page toward the light. “Gideon Voss.”
Caleb felt the cold of the stone through his coat. For twelve years he had believed that his father died under a cloud of doubt because the truth was lost. Now a single scrap of paper suggested that the truth had been hidden in plain sight.
They climbed out as twilight fell. On the far ridge, a rider watched them through field glasses. Caleb saw the glint of glass just before the figure vanished among the trees.
“They know where we are,” Nora said.
“Yes.”
“What do we do?”
He helped her into the saddle. “We stop moving like fugitives and start asking questions in public.”
“And if the public believes Voss?”
“Then we give them something harder to ignore than a rich man's promises.”
They rode toward Alder Creek under the first stars. Behind them, water whispered through the forgotten passage, carrying the sound of a mechanism that had once been trusted with seventeen lives.
Alder Creek smelled of coal smoke, wet leather, and bread from Mrs. Bell's bakery. Caleb had avoided the town for most of the previous year. Too many people still remembered the collapse as a simple story with a villain named Mercer. The town preferred simple stories; they allowed everyone to sleep.
Nora rode beside him beneath the swinging sign of the courthouse. She had borrowed a clean coat from Miguel's sister and covered the bruise on her cheek with a scarf. It did not hide the way she scanned every window. Caleb pointed toward a brick building across the street.
“Ada Bell works there in the mornings. She keeps the telegraph office.”
“Walter said she could be trusted.”
“Walter trusted you, too.”
“That didn't keep him safe.”
“No. But it brought you here.”
Inside the office, Ada Bell sat behind a desk crowded with telegram forms. She was a small woman with iron-gray hair and the commanding voice of a schoolmistress. When Nora spoke Walter Keene's name, Ada locked the front door and pulled down the shade.
“I wondered when someone would come,” she said.
“Do you know where he is?” Nora asked.
Ada hesitated. “I know where he was three days after they said he'd run away.”
She produced a telegram copied in her own hand. It had been sent from the freight station at Red Basin to a private address in Helena. The message was brief: THE WITNESS IS SECURED. HOLD THE SURVEY UNTIL VOSS RETURNS. Nora read it twice.
“Who sent it?”
“Silas Trent. He paid me to send it after hours.”
“Why keep a copy?” Caleb asked.
“Because he asked me not to.”
Ada had spent twenty years handling the town's secrets. She knew who sent money to estranged sons, who wrote apologies and never mailed them, and which businessmen demanded messages be destroyed. She had never thought of herself as brave, she said, until she saw Walter Keene dragged through the freight yard with his hands bound. She had been frightened then. She was still frightened now.
“I tried to follow,” she admitted. “Trent caught me looking. He said my nephew's apprenticeship could end if I interfered.”
“Your nephew works for Voss?” Nora asked.