"A witness states that you told him, 'Don't bother filing a complaint. Nobody is going to do anything.' Did you make that statement?"
Mercer stared at the table.
"I don't remember using those exact words."
"Did you tell him that filing a complaint would accomplish nothing?"
He hesitated.
"I may have said something about the process being difficult or time-consuming. I don't remember."
"Why would you have said that?"
Mercer took a breath.
"At the time, I may have believed the encounter was a minor disagreement. I might have been trying to calm the situation."
"Did you explain the complaint process to the young man?"
"No."
"Did you tell him he had the right to submit a complaint?"
"No."
"Did you encourage him to document what happened?"
"No."
Morales let the answers stand.
"Do you believe it is appropriate for a supervisor to discourage a resident from filing a complaint?"
"No," Mercer said quickly. "I would never intentionally prevent someone from reporting misconduct."
"That wasn't my question. Do you believe it is appropriate to tell someone that filing a complaint would accomplish nothing?"
Mercer looked down.
"No."
"Why not?"
"Because it could discourage them from reporting a legitimate concern."
Morales nodded.
"Did you review any complaint filed by Andre Mitchell?"
"I don't recognize the name."
She showed him the relevant administrative record.
Mercer studied the page.
"I remember reviewing a complaint from around that period, but I can't say with certainty that this was the same individual."
"The record indicates that you approved the administrative closure."
"Then I presumably reviewed the file that was presented to me."
"Do you remember what evidence you considered?"
"No."
"Do you remember whether the complainant was contacted?"
"No."
"Do you remember why the complaint was closed?"
Mercer remained silent for several seconds.
"Not specifically."
Morales looked at him.
"Sergeant, you have a long career and a generally positive record. This investigation is not asking you to deny your accomplishments. It is asking you to account for specific decisions."
Mercer lifted his head.
"I understand."
"Then I need you to consider whether your memory is incomplete because the events were routine, or whether the documentation was insufficient at the time."
He frowned.
"Are you suggesting I deliberately closed complaints without reading them?"
"I'm asking you to explain what you remember and what the records establish. I am not asking you to accept a conclusion that has not been reached."
Mercer leaned back.
For the first time during the interview, his confidence appeared to weaken.
"I handled a lot of administrative reviews," he said. "Sometimes dozens in a month. We were understaffed, and the paperwork never stopped. I relied on the information provided by the supervisors who prepared the files."
"Did you verify that required steps had been completed?"
"Not always independently."
"Did you ever return a complaint for additional information because the documentation was incomplete?"
"Yes."
"How did you decide which complaints required more review?"
Mercer paused.
"Experience. The seriousness of the allegation. Whether the available information appeared credible. Whether there was evidence that could be checked."
"Did you have written criteria?"
"We had procedures."
"Did you consistently apply them?"
Mercer looked at the folder in front of him.
"I believed I did."
The interview continued for another hour.
Mercer denied intentionally suppressing complaints. He acknowledged that his memory was incomplete and that his handling of some files might not have met the department's current expectations. He agreed that the documentation should have been clearer.
But he maintained that he had not deliberately attempted to protect Hale.
Morales made no final judgment.
She thanked him for participating and informed him that investigators might request additional information after reviewing the remaining records.
When Mercer left the room, he did not return immediately to his office.
He walked down the corridor and stopped beside a window overlooking the city.
He could see the bus shelter several blocks away.
For the first time, he tried to imagine the encounter from Andre Mitchell's perspective.
A young man waiting for a bus.
An officer demanding identification.
A second officer arriving and suggesting that a complaint would be pointless.
Then a letter announcing that the complaint had been closed because the young man had failed to attend a meeting he might never have known about.
Mercer had always thought of himself as someone who understood the practical realities of police work.
But he had spent years evaluating the efficiency of the process without asking whether the people affected by it had been treated fairly.
He had measured the workload.
He had measured the number of cases closed.
He had measured the time required to complete the paperwork.