A Rookie Cop Aimed a Taser at Two Men on a Park Bench — Then One Said, “Make Sure Your Camera Catches This Part.”

Chapter 38

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

“They may disagree with the details. But if we expect the public to believe that the reforms are real, the results cannot be verified only by the people responsible for implementing them.”

Shaw looked toward the darkened windows.

“Then prepare the proposal.”

At the same time, Hale's formal interview was approaching.

His attorney advised him to answer questions accurately and avoid speculation. Hale agreed. He had no intention of claiming to remember details he could not recall, and he did not want to blame other officers for decisions he had made himself.

But he remained worried about the older complaints.

He knew that he had stopped people, asked questions, and sometimes demanded identification during his years on patrol. He believed most of those encounters had been justified. Yet he could not confidently reconstruct every one of them.

That uncertainty forced him to confront an uncomfortable truth: he had often treated his own memory as the most reliable account of his actions.

When he remembered an encounter as ordinary, he assumed the person involved probably remembered it that way, too. When he remembered someone as hostile, he assumed his report had captured the important facts. He rarely considered that his interpretation might have been incomplete or influenced by his own frustration.

Now he understood why the investigators wanted records, witness statements, and independent evidence.

Memory could explain a person's perspective. It could not replace an examination of what actually happened.

On the morning of the interview, Hale arrived early. He sat in a small waiting room with his hands folded, listening to the faint sound of telephones ringing in the corridor.

Morales entered at nine o'clock with an investigator from professional standards and an independent observer. Hale's representative was already seated at the table.

The interview began with the plaza encounter.

Morales asked Hale to describe what he had observed before approaching Marcus Reed and Daniel Brooks.

Hale said he had noticed two men sitting together in a public area and believed their behavior warranted further inquiry.

“What specific behavior caused you to suspect wrongdoing?” Morales asked.

Hale hesitated.

“They were sitting there talking.”

“Was sitting and talking a violation of any rule?”

“No.”

“Did you observe a crime being committed?”

“No.”

“Did you receive information suggesting that a crime had occurred?”

“No.”

“What, then, was the basis for your decision to approach them?”

Hale felt the familiar urge to defend himself, to explain that officers had to be alert, that circumstances could change quickly, and that waiting for certainty could sometimes mean missing an opportunity to prevent harm.

But none of those general statements answered the question.

“I believed the situation was suspicious,” he said.

“Can you identify the facts that made it suspicious?”

Hale looked down at the table.

“Not beyond the fact that they were there.”

Morales allowed a pause.

“Did either man threaten you?”

“No.”

“Did either man attempt to flee?”

“No.”

“Did either man refuse a lawful order?”

Hale's jaw tightened.

“I gave them instructions, and they questioned them.”

“That was not my question, Officer. Did they refuse a lawful order?”

“I don't know that I can characterize it that way.”

“Did you explain the legal basis for requiring identification?”

“No.”

“Why not?”

Hale took a breath.

“Because I believed they should cooperate with me.”

The words sounded different when spoken in the quiet room.

Morales continued.

“Is cooperation the same as a legal obligation to identify oneself?”

“No.”

“Did you treat their questions as evidence of wrongdoing?”

“I think I treated them as a challenge to my authority.”

“Why?”

Hale looked at her.

“Because I expected them to do what I asked.”

“And when they asked you to explain the reason?”

“I became frustrated.”

“Did that frustration affect your conduct?”

“Yes.”

It was the first answer he gave without qualification.

Morales moved to the moment when Marcus identified himself as deputy commissioner.

“What changed when you learned his position?”

“I realized I had made a serious mistake.”

“What mistake?”

Hale looked at the table again.

“I had approached the situation with an assumption, and I hadn't established a lawful basis for the demands I was making.”

“Would your approach have been justified if Mr. Reed had not been a deputy commissioner?”

Hale felt the question settle over the room.

“No,” he said eventually. “His position didn't create the problem. It exposed it.”

The investigator beside Morales looked up from his notes.

Morales did not react visibly. She simply continued with the next question.

“Do you believe an ordinary resident should be expected to tolerate the same treatment?”

“No.”

“Why not?”

“Because the person has a right to be treated lawfully and respectfully regardless of who they are.”

News in the same category

A Rookie Cop Aimed a Taser at Two Men on a Park Bench — Then One Said, “Make Sure Your Camera Catches This Part.”

45 Part