He had not planned to become involved in the investigation. When the review unit first contacted him, he had nearly declined. He had a full-time job, a family to support, and little desire to revisit an encounter that had occurred when he was younger.
But he had kept a copy of the complaint he submitted as a college student. He had also saved the email that told him his complaint had been closed because he had failed to attend an interview.
The email had bothered him for years because he remembered no invitation to attend one.
He brought the message to the review team.
The investigator examined the date and asked whether Andre had changed his email address during that period.
“No,” he replied. “I used the same address throughout college.”
“Did you receive any telephone call or letter inviting you to an interview?”
“Not that I remember.”
“Would you have attended if you had received the notice?”
Andre gave a short laugh without humor.
“I filed the complaint because I wanted someone to ask me what happened. Why would I ignore the interview?”
The investigator nodded, acknowledging the question without pretending to know the answer.
Andre then described the encounter itself. He had been waiting at a bus shelter after finishing classes. An officer approached him and asked what he was doing in the area. Andre explained that he was waiting for a bus. The officer told him to move along, although the shelter was open to the public and there was no indication that it was closed or restricted.
When Andre asked whether he had violated a rule, the officer became irritated.
A second officer arrived several minutes later. Andre now believed that officer had been Sergeant Mercer.
“He told me not to bother filing a complaint,” Andre said. “He said nobody was going to do anything.”
The investigator asked whether Andre was certain about the words.
“I'm certain about the meaning. I can't promise that every word is exact. It was years ago. But I remember how he said it. He didn't sound like someone explaining a process. He sounded like someone telling me that I was wasting my time.”
“What happened after that?”
“I took the bus.”
“Did you feel free to remain at the shelter?”
Andre thought for a moment.
“I could have refused to leave. I suppose I had that physical ability. But I didn't know what would happen if I did. The officer had already made it clear that he was unhappy with my questions. I wasn't going to risk being arrested just to prove a point.”
The investigator wrote down his answer.
Andre leaned forward.
“I want to make something clear. I'm not saying every officer treated me that way. I've had good experiences with police, too. But the good experiences don't cancel out the bad ones. And when a supervisor tells you that a complaint won't matter, it changes how you think about every encounter afterward.”
“Can you explain that?”
Andre looked toward the window.
“You stop thinking about what the rules say. You start thinking about how much trouble it might cause to insist on them.”
The investigator let the silence remain.
Andre continued.
“After that incident, I stopped asking officers why they wanted something. If they told me to move, I moved. If they asked for identification, I tried to figure out whether refusing would make things worse. I told myself I was being practical.”
“Do you still feel that way?”
“Sometimes. Habits don't disappear because a department changes a policy.”
When the interview ended, Andre received a copy of his statement and confirmation that his original complaint would remain open until the review was complete.
He placed both documents in a folder.
Before leaving, he turned to the investigator.
“Will Sergeant Mercer be told what I said?”
“He will be given an opportunity to respond to the allegations in accordance with the investigation procedures.”
Andre nodded.
“Good. He should have that opportunity.”
The investigator appeared surprised.
Andre explained.
“I don't want the department to do to him what I felt it did to me. I want the evidence examined. If he said those things, I want that acknowledged. If he didn't, I want that established as fairly as possible. Otherwise, we're just repeating the same problem with different people.”
His answer became an important reminder to the review team. The people who had been harmed by a flawed process were not necessarily asking for punishment without limits. Many were asking for something more difficult: a process that could tell the truth even when the truth was inconvenient.