She did not, at this point, think fraud. Fraud was a word for television. What she thought was what she had been raised to think: there is a discrepancy; discrepancies have sources; sources can be asked; asking goes in writing. She wrote the email at 11:20 on a Tuesday morning, and she wrote it with the full liturgy: polite, factual, filed. Subject: Score discrepancy, Coordinator search, file copy request. Body: the outcome memo of record lists Candidate B.K. at 71; the outcome letter issued to the candidate cites 68; the foundation schedule requires a single figure of record; could HR confirm which figure is correct, and could she be provided the original panel score sheets for the cycle so the schedule could be built from source documents, per the foundation's documentation standard. She sent it to Brenda Holt. She saved it to the compliance folder. She noted it in her work log, with the time, because her father had once won a grievance on the strength of a work log and the story was family scripture.
Brenda answered in person, which Megan noted also. Brenda came down the corridor with two coffees, which was her management style, caffeine as diplomacy, and stood in the doorway of the data office with the smile that, in another part of this story, did not move. "Sweetheart, you are overthinking a typo," she said. "The panels score on paper, my office transcribes, things get smudged. Sixty-eight, seventy-one, it's the same candidate not advancing either way. Use the memo number for the foundation, it's cleaner. And the originals--" she made a small gesture, regretful, worldly "--privacy protocol. Scores are personal data. The sheets are destroyed after transcription, same cycle, so no one can go fishing in people's files later. It's actually a protection for the candidates. Your dad would appreciate that, I think. Protection." She set one of the coffees on Megan's desk, in the manner of a treaty, and went back down the corridor.
Megan drank the coffee. She was twenty-three, not stupid, and not prone to confusing a beverage with an answer. Then she opened her work log and wrote, in the plain style she used for entries she expected to be read by strangers someday: "10/14, 11:41. B.H. responded verbally to my email of 11:20. States discrepancy is a typo; directs use of memo figure; states original panel sheets are destroyed after transcription per privacy protocol; no written confirmation provided." Then she sat for a while with the toothache. Sixty-eight or seventy-one was, by itself, nothing: a smudge, as Brenda said. The toothache was not the number. The toothache was that two numbers existed for the same man on the same morning, in documents issued by the same office, and the office, when asked in writing to say which one was real and to produce the source, had sent a person with coffee instead of a reply, and had explained that the sources no longer existed, had in fact been destroyed as a kindness. Her father's catechism had a codicil for this, too, though she had to supply it herself, because her father had never worked anywhere that destroyed its own sources: if the answer is a shrug, write the shrug down, and send the question higher.
She wrote the second memo on Friday. It was two paragraphs. It recited the discrepancy, the request, the verbal response, and the protocol as described to her, and it asked, with a politeness so complete it was load-bearing, whether the destruction of original panel score sheets was consistent with the Alliance's document retention policy, a copy of which she attached, highlighting -- she was her father's daughter; the highlighting was meticulous -- the section that required personnel selection records to be retained, originals included, for four years. She addressed it to Diane Kessler, Executive Director. She sent it through the internal system, which time-stamped it. She saved a copy to the compliance folder and a copy to a folder of her own. Then she went back to the service counts for the annual report, because the report was due and the work was the work, and she did not tell anyone what she had done, and she was, by the time the weekend came, more frightened than she had expected to be, and also -- this surprised her, and would have made her father put down his paper and look at her properly -- steadier.