An Empty Chair

Chapter 17

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Diane had known this speech was coming. She had been composing her answer since seven in the morning, in the shower, in the car, at the cold coffee, and what she heard herself say was not the composition but the thing underneath it, which was simpler. "Pop. If we handle it in a room, then the next twenty-three-year-old who writes a memo like that learns that the memo is where honesty goes to be handled. In a room. By the family." She put her hand flat on the clerk's two paragraphs. "She did everything right. She wrote it down. She dated it. She cited the policy. She sent it to the person whose job it is, which is me. There is exactly one move available to me that does not make a liar out of the manual we hand people like her on their first day, and it's to have this looked at by somebody who owes this family nothing. Not our lawyer. Not the board. Somebody from outside the whole braid, with a written protocol, whose findings we publish to the board whether we like them or not."

"The name, Di."

"The name is the reason." Her voice did not rise. It went lower, which in Diane was the sound of the final setting of a load. "Mom's name is all over this building in every way that matters, you said it yourself. So let me tell you what else has her name on it: nobody signs, nobody owes, nobody proves they're hungry. The pantry had no transcription step, Pop. There was no office between the pencil and the truth. She wrote the initials herself, in the book, in the basement. That's the founding document of this place -- not the charter, her book. And if there's a desk in this building where the numbers get rewritten to suit the family, then the family is the thing that has to be looked at, by outsiders, in writing, or her book is just a decoration we keep in a frame."

Henryk was quiet for a long time. Diane watched him look at the photograph -- his wife young, himself young, the basement, the bread -- and she watched him make the crossing that she had made at seven that morning, and she did not hurry him, because she knew the toll. At last he said, "Who?"

"Judge Anders. Retired. County circuit, twenty-six years on the bench, then she did the review for the diocese and the one for the transit authority, and both of those institutions hated what she found and printed it anyway, which is the entire reference I need. She has never taken a dollar from us, never sat on anything of ours, never been to the dinner. She owes the family nothing. She barely owes the city anything anymore. She'll want a protocol in writing before she'll look at a single page."

"She will find what she finds," Henryk said, in the tone of a man sentencing a structure he built to an inspection he expects it to fail.

"Yes," Diane said.

"And the candidates. The boy. The one from the lobby." He turned his glasses over in his hands. "The hub man. Boateng. If his number was-- if he was wronged, Di, he was wronged in my lobby on my day by my--" He stopped. Diane did not finish it for him. "Steffi wrote his family in her book," he said at last, very quietly. "I think. The initials. I have not looked. Thirty years I have not opened that box. But I think his people are in her book. And if this building fed a boy on Thursdays and then rewrote his score on a Tuesday--" The sentence defeated him. He put his glasses back on, which was his way of ending meetings, and said, "Call the judge. Do it today. Before I learn to argue better." And then, as Diane reached for the phone, he added, "One thing. Whatever she finds about Brenda. Brenda sat at the back of the funeral, standing. Remember it in whatever room you are in when you decide things. Not instead of the findings. Alongside."

Judge Marian Anders -- retired, seventy-one, with a voice that made court reporters sit up straighter in their memories -- accepted the engagement on a Thursday, subject to conditions she dictated before she heard a single fact, and the conditions, typed on her own letterhead and signed by Diane before any file changed hands, were the review itself in miniature: all interviews under the protocol, recorded, with the interviewee entitled to the transcript; all documents produced to be logged on receipt, copies to the review, originals to remain where they lay; no interim reports to anyone, including the executive director, including the founder, especially including the chairman of the board; findings to be delivered in writing, in full, to the entire board at once, and to no one else first, not even in summary, not even as a courtesy; and the review, not the Alliance, would notify any candidate whose file was found to have been altered, in writing, in plain language, with the corrected figure stated. Diane signed it with the feeling of a person locking a door from the outside with her own house inside it. "Your father built an organization that feeds people without asking them to sign anything," the judge said, reading the signature. "Admirable. It has caused exactly the record-keeping culture one would expect. We will proceed anyway."

News in the same category

An Empty Chair

45 Part