An Empty Chair

Chapter 20

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The summary found that across three hiring cycles, the scores of eleven candidates had been altered after panel, in the office of the human resources manager, who had re-copied -- "transcribed" -- the panel score sheets onto summaries in which selected candidates' figures were raised and others lowered, after which the original sheets were destroyed, on her initials, in the weeks following each panel. It found that no written instruction to alter scores existed, and that the absence was itself a finding: that over years, through remarks at dinners, through a pattern of inquiries about "our people," through thanks given and withheld, the chairman of the board had established within the administration a standing expectation that candidates connected to the Alliance's family of funders would be looked after in its processes; that the expectation had been understood, correctly, as the price of goodwill; and that it had been executed by an employee who believed, not without evidence, that executing it was her function and her protection. It found that the panels themselves had been honest, their records kept honestly by several panelists in private notebooks the institution had never asked for and had benefited from without knowing. It found that the discrepancy had come to light because one employee had asked one question in writing. It named, as the summary's final institutional finding, the sentence that Diane had already said to the wall of her office: the Alliance's founding practice had been that truth entered its books at the hand of the person who witnessed it, and the transcription step -- the office between the pencil and the truth -- was where the organization had stored its one corruptible room.

Then the findings did the small, specific work. Regarding Candidate Donnelly, P.: the panel score of 74 awarded by her panel had been raised in transcription to 87; the review found no evidence that the candidate knew of, requested, or benefited knowingly from the alteration; her belief in her advancement was, on the evidence, sincere. Her candidacy, however, having been advanced on a figure that was not hers, could not stand, and the cycle's results as a whole were void. Regarding eleven named candidates, corrected figures were stated. Regarding the human resources manager: the findings were referred, with the full record, to the board for employment action and to the district attorney for whatever review that office deemed appropriate; the summary noted, without adornment, that the manager had declined, on counsel's advice, to be interviewed a second time. Regarding the chairman: the findings were addressed to the board entire, and the summary's last paragraph was a single sentence, which the judge read at exactly the pace she had read everything else: that an expectation maintained without instruction is still an instruction, and is in some respects a worse one, since it allows everyone involved to believe that no one gave it.

The board sat with it. Then it did what boards do when the paper in front of them has been built to leave no exits: it acted, in order, in a single long meeting that ran past seven. Brenda Holt's employment was terminated, effective that day, for falsification of organizational records and destruction of records under retention; the referral to prosecutors stood as the review had made it. Martin Donnelly listened to the vote on his own position with the stillness of a man at a bedside, and then he resigned as chairman, effective immediately, in a letter of four sentences that the minutes recorded in full, the fourth of which said only that the wing would be renamed at the board's discretion and that he concurred. The renaming took longer than the resignation. It was the executive director who ended it, at half past six, with her father's boiler-lore practicality surfacing in a boardroom at the worst moment of her professional life: "We will call it the Lisbon Wing," Diane said. "For the basement. That's the address where the work started, and the work is the only name that was ever load-bearing in this family." The vote carried, eleven to one, the one being a member who had wanted time, which everyone understood to mean wanted the evening to be shorter than it was.

News in the same category

An Empty Chair

45 Part