In the winter, the bookkeeper brought Octavia a discrepancy, small and puzzling, in the accounts for the month, and Octavia thanked her, and they investigated it together, and they found that it was a simple error, a deposit recorded twice, and they corrected it, and Octavia told the bookkeeper that she was glad she had brought it, and that she should always bring discrepancies, no matter how small, and the bookkeeper said that she would, and Octavia thought about how different this was from the year before, when a bookkeeper had flagged discrepancies and been told they were timing differences, and she thought about how a shop's culture is built not by policies on a wall but by what happens when a person brings a problem, and about how the bookkeeper's willingness to bring a small error was proof that the culture had changed, more proof than any policy could give.
The apprentices, by then, were teaching each other, which is the sign that teaching has taken root, and Octavia watched them with pleasure: the young woman who had started in a bead shop showing the new apprentice how to hold a loupe, the young man who had repaired watches in his garage showing another how to test a clasp, the new apprentices asking questions that Octavia herself had asked twenty years earlier, at a mall kiosk, of a bench jeweler who had taught her to look first and speak second. She thought about Ansel, and about the kiosk, and about the years between, and she thought that a trade is a long conversation, carried on across benches and across generations, and that her part in it was to keep the conversation honest, and to pass it on, and to make sure that the next person who picked up a loupe would be taught to look at the stone, not at the customer, and to judge the one and welcome the other.
In the spring, Octavia began holding a small open evening at the shop once a month, not a sale and not a party, but an hour when anyone could come in, look at the bench through the glass, ask questions about stones, and handle the tools under supervision. She had the idea from the trade school, where the instructors had told her that most people had never seen a jeweler work, and that the mystery of the trade was part of what made it intimidating. The first evening, only a handful of people came, mostly regular customers and one curious neighbor, and Octavia showed them how a stone is set, how a ring is sized, how an appraisal is written, and they asked questions, and they left pleased, and the second evening more people came, and by the summer the evenings had become a fixture, small and unadvertised, known by word of mouth, and the shop had a new kind of customer: people who had come to look and stayed to buy, not because they had been sold anything but because they had been taught something, and because teaching, Octavia had learned, is the most honest form of selling there is.
One evening, a young man came in who had never been in a jewelry store before, and he told Octavia so, plainly, and he asked whether he was allowed to be there, and Octavia told him that he was, and she showed him a tray of stones, and she let him hold a loupe, and she showed him how to look at a stone's inclusions, and he looked, and he said that he had always thought jewelry was for other people, and Octavia said that it was for anyone who wanted it, and that the shop's cases opened for anyone who asked, and he nodded, and he came back the following month, and he brought a friend, and Octavia thought about the fourteen customers in Tamsin's notebook, and about how many people had decided, over the years, that jewelry was for other people, because someone at a counter had decided it for them, and about how the open evenings were, in their small way, an answer to that decision, not a reversal of it, because a reversal would require finding every person who had been turned away, which was impossible, but an answer, because a door opened is a door opened, even if not everyone who was once shut out walks back through it.