Octavia closed the notebook and sat in the quiet office for a long time. She thought about the Tuesday visit, about the invented appointment rule, about the way Hugh had looked at her clothes and decided, in a second, that she was not a customer worth a case key. She thought about Tamsin, who had shown her a pendant with care and had not looked at her clothes at all. And she thought about the shop she had bought, which was not only a name and a lease and a set of cases, but a set of obligations: to the customers who had trusted it with their repairs, to the consignors who had trusted it with their pieces, to the staff who worked there, and to the Carrows, who had trusted her to keep it honest. She put the notebook in her own bag, not in the safe, and she finished the inventory, and she locked the shop, and she walked home through the Pearl District in the evening light, past the restaurants filling with dinner crowds, with the notebook heavy in her bag and a decision forming in her mind. She would not confront Hugh that night, and she would not go to the police that night either. She would do what she had always done when a stone did not test clean: she would gather more evidence, carefully, and she would check every figure before she spoke, because an accusation made without proof was worse than no accusation at all, and because the people who would be hurt by a false step were not only Hugh.
The next morning she went back to the shop's records with fresh eyes. She pulled the appraisal files, which she had not yet examined closely, and she went through them one by one. Aster and Grey offered insurance appraisals, a service for which customers paid between one hundred and fifty and four hundred dollars, depending on the piece. The procedure, as written in the operations manual, was clear: the appraisal was to be prepared by a qualified appraiser, filed with the shop's records, and a copy given to the customer, with the filing recorded in a separate log. Octavia found the forms, dozens of them, each with a customer's name, a description of a piece, and a fee marked as paid. What she did not find, for a large number of them, was any corresponding filing. She checked the filing log, and she checked the filing cabinet, and she checked the digital folder where the Carrows had told her the appraisals were stored. For twenty-nine appraisals over two years, there was a form and a fee and nothing else: no filed document, no copy on record, no entry in the log. The fees on those forms added to twelve thousand six hundred dollars. The customers had paid for a service they had not received, and the money, so far as she could tell from the shop's accounts, had not gone into the shop's revenue at all. It had gone, like the payments marked W, somewhere it should not have gone. She copied the figures into her own notebook, in her own hand, and she noted the names and dates, and she did not yet allow herself to name what she was looking at, because naming it too early would make her careless, and carelessness was the one thing she could not afford.