Emory Tate's office with a clerk's precision: that Halloway, confronted that morning by the recorder
himself with the discrepancy of the seals, had resigned his commission within the hour and had named, in
a written statement now held at Tucson, the sum he was paid and the company agent who paid it, and had
described the original Missouri record brought to him for copying, in which the groom's name was
Thomas Hart, in which the bride was the groom's cousin by marriage and Jonas Hart's cousin by blood,
and in which no word had wanted altering except the one word on which the whole case had been built to
stand.
"One word moved sideways," Delgado said, "like a survey stake in the dark. The company's case, Your
Honor, in both its papers, is one crime in two coats: where the ground was occupied, they filed it empty;
where the groom was single, they married him. It is the same hand, the same ink, the same theory of the
territory - that paper arrives first, and the country is whatever arrived."
Judge Albie sat silent a while, with the two papers under his two hands, like a man holding down a
map in wind.
"Mr. Voss," he said at last. "Your company requested this hearing be expedited. I have granted the
request. Is there any part of the valley's evidence the company disputes as fact? Not as weight. As fact."
56
Fenner rose, and glanced at Voss, and got nothing from that quarter but a man studying his own hands
with the attention of a stranger. "The company," Fenner said, "withdraws the lease filing and the marriage
objection in their entirety, and asks the court's leave to - "
"The company will have leave to do a number of things," the judge said, "in a number of other rooms,
several of them in Tucson, where the recorder and a grand jury appear to be warming chairs for it. Here,
the company's requests are concluded." He turned the papers over, face down, both of them, with
deliberation. "This is my finding, and the clerk will record it. The grazing lease filed by Continental Land
and Water covering the Escondido valley is void on its face and fraudulent in its execution, and is struck
from the record. The water appropriation dependent on it falls with it. The occupancy of Chief Mahko's
people in the Escondido valley - their dwellings, fields, ditches, and grazing grounds - is a fact of record
in this territory as of this date, attested by this hearing, and any future filing describing that valley as
vacant or unoccupied will be received by the land office as a false statement made with knowledge. The
marriage objection raised against Jonas Hart is dismissed, the copy on which it rested being a forgery, and
Mr. Hart's name stands in this record as what the evidence shows it to be: a single man's, honestly come
by, with my apology for the week it has spent in the dock. The matters of the altered record, the false
lease, the cutting of fences and the firing of grass on occupied land are referred to the territorial
authorities, and Mr. Voss will remain in this town's custody of himself, on his own recognizance and his
lawyer's, until the marshal's office advises. This hearing is concluded. Somebody open a window. Thirty
years I have presided over paper, and this room smells of it."
The hall did not erupt. Hearings over stores in small towns rarely erupt; they exhale. Chairs scraped.
The coffee drinkers below were already repeating it through the floor. Desba, in the front row, sat down
suddenly on a bench she had been standing in front of, like a woman whose knees had filed a report of
their own. Mahko closed his eyes for a moment, and when he opened them he was looking at his
youngest daughter, who had not moved at all.
Saba rose, and crossed the dance floor, past the judge's table with its face-down papers, and stopped in
front of Jonas, who had been standing at the back with his hat in his hands for two hours in the approved
posture of a man whose name is being decided by other people in formal language.
"The examination is concluded, Mr. Hart," she said, in a voice clear enough for the front rows and
intended, he understood, for exactly them. "You are found to be a single man of Las Cruces horsebreaking, Missouri apple-throwing, and six hundred and twelve dollars, with no wife in any county that
keeps records, and one cousin in Tucson who buys hats and is going to receive a letter from me that will
scorch the paint off her door. The wedding that Mr. Voss interrupted will be held tomorrow at sundown,
57
in the valley, before the same witnesses, at the same fire - because I choose it, Mr. Hart, freely, for the
second time, and I want the territory's record to show that I was asked twice and answered twice, in case
anyone in Tucson is still confused about the difference between a woman and a filing."
The judge, gathering his docket, was heard by several reliable witnesses to say that in thirty years it
was the finest closing statement he had ever had stolen from him, and that he intended to attend, if the
chief would have him, to see how it ended.
58
C H A P T E R 1 7
The Last Errand
The riders came back to the valley on the last night before the wedding, and this time the valley was not
surprised, because Corley, who knew the company's arrangements the way a man knows the furniture of a
room he has decided to leave, had warned the priest's kitchen before he slept: if the hearing was lost,
there was a standing errand, paid in advance and deniable in arrears, for two of the company's benchcamp men. Not Voss's whole crew - most had drawn their pay that evening in San Tomas and scattered