valley from the mesa with my water gone and it looked like the answer to a question I had been asking
eleven years. I did not think the question would involve a wedding. But a man does not get to choose the
shape of the answer. He only gets to choose whether to answer back."
"That," she said, "is nearly a proposal, Mr. Hart."
"It is nearly an explanation."
"I will store it with the explanations, then. They are breeding." And she touched her mare into a trot
that ended the conversation exactly where she wanted it ended, which Jonas was coming to recognize as
one of her governing skills.
That evening Mara found him washing up at the trough, and delivered herself of the family's view of
matters with the directness of a woman deputized by higher powers.
"My sister likes you," she said. "Do not let it go to your head. She liked a mule once, briefly, for its
honesty. I am telling you because she will not, and because Tomas is telling the young men that you are
here to steal the valley with a wedding ring, and you should know the ground you stand on in this place,
all of it, the soft parts included."
"Who is Tomas, when he is not telling tales?"
14
"He is the older Tomas. Little Tomas's uncle. He is a good hunter and a better rider and he believed,
since we were all children, that he would marry Saba one day and be the chief's son and a big man. Then
the Tonto boy made his story, and Tomas found that believing a thing in private and standing up for it in
front of laughing neighbors are different countries, and he has never crossed into the second one. He did
not defend her. He did not court her. He just waited for the story to die, and it has not died, and now you
are here refusing bargains and getting stitched, and it is eating him like a worm in an apple." She wrung
out her cloth. "He is not a bad man, Jonas Hart. He is a proud one, with a shame in him he has not paid
for yet. That kind can go either way, like weather."
"And Saba?" Jonas asked. "What does she say about Tomas?"
"She says Tomas is a man who loves the idea of her at a distance and fears the fact of her up close,
which is worse than not loving at all, because it wastes everybody's time including his own." Mara smiled
without much humor. "She is not cruel. She is only finished being patient. There is a difference, though
men keep failing to see it."
On the fourth evening, Saba took him up the path behind the dwellings to show him the place the
valley kept its history, which was not a building but a cottonwood, the oldest in the bottom, with a trunk
three men could not have circled and a hollow at its base where the band's children had been hiding
treasures, messages, and occasionally themselves for as long as anyone could remember. Someone,
generations back, had carved marks into the bark at a child's eye height, and the tree had grown around
them and carried them upward as it grew, so that the valley's oldest writing now sat too high to read
except as a reminder that it was there.
"My great-grandmother planted this tree from a slip," Saba said, "when the ditch was new. The ditch
came first. People think a valley begins with houses. It begins with water deciding to stay."
She showed him the ditch line running out of the river bend, the hand of it, the way the water was
divided by gates of woven willow into the family fields, each field named, each gate with its keeper and
its day. She showed him the upper field where the corn stood in hills the way her grandmother had taught,
beans climbing the stalks, squash covering the ground between, the three of them helping each other in a
system older than any paper in San Tomas. Jonas, who had farmed badly as a boy and cowboyed well as a
man, walked the rows with the respect due to a well-run outfit, and asked the questions of a man who
intended to be examined on the subject later, because by then he understood that everything she showed
him was a question wearing work clothes: these phrases about the valley were phrases about herself.
"If I asked you to leave all this," he said at last, "to come away and live on hired land in some town
where nobody knew your name, what would you say?"
15
"I would say you had not been listening under the cottonwood," she said. "And I would be right, and
we would both know it, and it would be the end of an otherwise promising acquaintance. This is not
scenery to me, Jonas. It is my mother in that ground by the hill. It is my grandmother in this tree. A man
who wants me wants the whole account, debts included. I would say the same to you, by the way.
Whatever ground your people are in, in Missouri. I do not get to leave it out of you just because it is far
away and badly kept."
He thought of the home place, sold for his father's debts while he was still too young to sign anything,
the house gone to strangers, the orchard his mother had planted going back to wilderness by inches, and
of how no one in eleven years of camps and outfits had ever once asked him to keep any of it, let alone
offered to count it as part of him. "My mother's orchard is probably a thicket by now," he said. "Nine
apple trees. She grafted them herself."
"Then we will go and see it someday," Saba said, as matter-of-factly as a woman discussing weather,