“Choose One of My Three Daughters,” the Apache Chief Told the Cowboy — He Chose All Three, Then Rode Into War Beside Them

Chapter 11

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

They withdrew the way they had come, slow and silent, and did not mount until the dam was hidden behind the hill.

On the ride back, Kaya spoke more than she had on the way out.

My mother used to say that water remembers where it belongs, she said. "She said you can dam it and ditch it and sell it, but it will always try to come home. I did not understand her when I was a girl. I thought she was talking about rivers."

And now?

Now I think she was talking about people.

They came into the valley in the hard light of late morning. Women stood in the doorways of the shelters, and the men of the watch stood near the cottonwoods, rifles in their hands, watching the ridge.

Ethan dismounted and went straight to Tomas. He did not speak first. He unwrapped the neckerchief and laid the branded plank, the cartridge, and the torn canvas on the flat stone beside the spring, where everyone could see them. The wood was still damp from the ditch. The brand stood out black and unmistakable in the sun.

It is true, Ethan said. "They have dammed the creek below the willow bend. Five armed men. The water is cut off and ditched west, to the company ground. The bed below the dam is dry."

A murmur went through the people gathered there, not loud, but deep, like wind moving through a stand of trees before a storm. Tomas looked down at the plank for a long moment, then lifted his gaze to the faces around him, to the elders, to the mothers holding their children, to Kaya standing dusty and straight at Ethan's shoulder.

Then he turned, and his voice carried across the spring and into every shelter in the valley.

Call the council, Tomas said. "Tonight, under the cottonwoods. Every family. We will hear what has been seen, and we will decide what we are."

The council gathered under the cottonwoods as the heat broke and the long shadows laid themselves across the spring.

The people came quietly, family by family, and took their places in a wide circle, the elders in the inner ring, the young men of the watch standing behind them, the women with children settled close to the fire. No one spoke out of turn. The air smelled of woodsmoke and roasting corn and the clean smell of spring water moving over stone.

Tomas sat at the head of the circle, with old Nascha at his right hand. Aiyana sat with Sona beside her, her medicine basket at her feet. Kaya sat near the watch, her rifle across her knees. Tala sat near the fire, her hands folded, missing nothing.

Tomas spoke first, and his voice was low, but it reached every ear.

You have heard what was seen at the creek, he said. "The dam is real. The water is taken. The company does not hide its hand anymore. We have thirty days, and already they spend those days cutting the ground from under us. We must decide how we will stand."

He turned to Ethan. "You came to us following horses. You stayed to warn us. You have ridden with my daughter and brought back proof. Before this council, I will ask you the question I asked you in private, and I will ask it so all may hear the answer."

The circle went very still. Even the children stopped fidgeting.

Yesterday I offered you a choice, Tomas said. "Choose one of my three daughters. Choose a wife, and a place among us, and a share in what we defend. I ask you now, before your neighbors and mine: what is your answer?"

Ethan stood. His mouth was dry, but his father's words were steady in his mind. He looked around the circle slowly, letting the silence hold, because he understood that what he said next would be a promise made in public, and it would have to be kept in public.

Chief Tomas, he said, "I have spent a night and a morning thinking about your offer, and I have spent it by listening. I listened to Aiyana at the spring, and I heard a healer who carries the lives of this valley in her hands. I listened to Kaya on the watch, and I heard a scout who would die on a ridge before she let harm reach the people below it. I listened to Tala by the fire, and I heard a voice that can carry this valley's story to people who have never seen it.

He paused, and when he spoke again, his voice was clear and certain.

I will not choose one of your daughters, Chief. I choose all three. Not as property. Not as a prize. As partners. I will stand beside Aiyana, and beside Kaya, and beside Tala, and they will stand beside me, and together we will stand beside this valley. That is my answer. If the council will not have it, I will still stand with the valley. But I will not pretend that one woman could carry what these three carry, and I will not insult them by choosing among them as if they were horses in a corral.

A sound went around the circle, sharp and startled, like breath drawn in all at once. Chato, standing with the young men, gave a short, bitter laugh and said something under his breath that Ethan did not catch. An elder near Nascha shook his head slowly. A woman near the fire pressed a hand to her mouth.

News in the same category

“Choose One of My Three Daughters,” the Apache Chief Told the Cowboy — He Chose All Three, Then Rode Into War Beside Them

45 Part