“Choose One of My Three Daughters,” the Apache Chief Told the Cowboy — He Chose All Three, Then Rode Into War Beside Them

Chapter 19

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Ethan handed Miguel the reins and went around the side of the house, where Sheriff Ben Calloway stood looking out over the dry pasture with his thumbs hooked in his belt and his star catching the hard morning light. He was fifty-five and looked older this summer, the drought having carved deeper lines around his eyes. His shirt was clean but frayed at the collar. He had the air of a man who had ridden a long way on an errand he did not approve of, and who intended to discharge it as quickly as decency allowed.

Morning, Sheriff, Ethan said.

Morning, Ethan. Calloway did not turn at first. "Your cattle look thin."

Everybody's cattle look thin.

That is what I keep telling the company men. They seem to think the drought is a personal insult. Calloway turned then, and his eyes went over Ethan the way a doctor's eyes go over a patient — taking in the rifle, the dust, the valley road still on his boots. "You've been up at that Apache camp."

I live half my life up there now, Ben. You know that.

I know more than I want to know, and less than I need to. The sheriff jerked his chin toward the house. "Walk with me. Not inside. Walls have a way of remembering what was said in front of them."

They walked along the fence, past the corral where Pete Aldana was mending a bridle and trying very hard not to listen, and out toward the windmill, whose blades turned in slow, complaining circles. The heat was already building. It pressed down on the back of Ethan's neck like a hand, and the smell of dust and dry grass rose from the ground with every step.

I came to warn you, Calloway said, "and I came to tell you what I cannot do."

Go on.

Brandt was in Juniper Flats yesterday with two lawyers out of Tucson. They have a judge's order. Eviction. Ten days from the day it was served, and three of those days are already gone. He paused. "Driscoll wants me to ride up there with a posse and enforce it. He says the Apaches are squatters on company land, and that you are harboring them."

And what do you say?

I say the law is the law, and a judge's order is a judge's order, and I say it loud enough for Driscoll to hear. Calloway stopped walking. He looked at the windmill, at the sky, at anything but Ethan. "And then I come out here, alone, to say the other thing."

Ethan waited.

The other thing, Calloway said, "is that I have read those papers, Ethan. I have held them in my hands. And I do not like them."

Why not?

Because a land claim is a story, and this one does not tell straight. The sheriff's voice dropped. "The survey lines do not match the markers I rode past in eighty-two. The dates are too tidy. Grady's hand is all over the filing, and Grady has been spending money he does not earn. A clerk on twelve dollars a week does not buy a new saddle and a gold watch in the same month unless somebody is paying him to forget how to read."

Then arrest him, Ethan said.

For what? Spending money? For having poor handwriting? Calloway shook his head, weary. "I need proof, Ethan. Proof that would stand up in front of a judge who is not already bought. Without it, I am a sheriff with a suspicion, and suspicion does not stop a posse. It does not stop a bullet, either."

They had reached the windmill. Water dripped, slow and precious, from a loose joint into a trough, and a horsefly worried at the damp wood. Ethan put his hand on the warm metal of the tank and thought about the spring in the valley, running clear under the cottonwoods, and about the forty people who would die without it.

Driscoll will not wait for the ten days, Ethan said.

No, Calloway agreed. "He will not. That is the other reason I came. He has been recruiting riders out of the saloons in Dry River — hard men, the kind who will burn a hay store and call it an accident. If you give him an excuse, Ethan — one shot fired at a company man, one cut fence he can swear to — he will ride in there and finish this before any judge in Tucson ever hears the word Apache."

So I am to sit still and watch them die politely.

You are to be smarter than he is. Calloway finally met his eyes. "You have something, don't you? That paper your father kept. The one Brandt wants so badly."

Ethan said nothing.

Your father was a careful man, the sheriff went on. "He came to me once, years back, after he rode out to that valley. He said there were people living there who had a better right to the water than any company that ever printed a letterhead. He did not show me the paper. But he told me it existed, and he told me that if the day ever came when somebody tried to take that spring, the paper would matter more than a rifle."

It matters, Ethan said. "It is in my keeping."

Then keep it safe. And get it in front of a man who can act on it. Calloway glanced back toward the house, where Miguel still stood watching. "Because I will tell you plainly, Ethan, and you will hear it from no one else: I cannot prove those papers are forged. But I believe they are. And I will not ride against that valley on a lie."

News in the same category

“Choose One of My Three Daughters,” the Apache Chief Told the Cowboy — He Chose All Three, Then Rode Into War Beside Them

45 Part