The old surveyor came forward slowly, leaning on a cane, his hands shaking, and took the oath in a voice that trembled and then steadied. Fremont watched him the way a man watches a horse he is not sure of.
Mr. Boone, Ethan said gently. "Did you survey the Dry River valley?"
I did. Twice. Once in 1868, for the territory, when the Accord was signed. And once again, nineteen years later, for the company.
And what did the company ask you to do, the second time?
Boone looked at the floor, then at the judge. "They paid me forty dollars. They asked me to move the markers. A quarter mile west, along the creek. Enough to put the spring on their side of the line. I was old. I was poor. I was afraid of them. I did it, and I have carried it like a stone in my boot ever since."
The courtroom went very still. Hollis was on his feet at once. "Your Honor, this man is a confessed fraud. His word is worthless — "
His word is corroborated, Mr. Hollis, Fremont said, "by the map in my hand, which shows the original markers, and by your own company's filing, which shows them moved. Sit down."
Boone went on, haltingly, naming the men who had paid him, the day, the place, the exact sum. He produced the company's own receipt, kept all these years in a tin box under his floor, and laid it on the desk. When he finished, he sat down as if a great weight had come off him, and Tala, watching from the bench, wept silently, with pride.
Ethan called Sheriff Calloway next. The sheriff testified that he had seen the company's papers and that the dates did not match the land-office ledger, that the seal on the filing was pressed over an older stamp, and that he had raised his doubts with Amos Grady and been told to mind his own jurisdiction.
Then Ethan called Amos Grady himself, brought from Juniper Flats under summons, a big man gone soft, his hands twisting a hat brim. Under Fremont's questioning, Grady broke. He admitted the company had paid him two hundred dollars, that he had altered the ledger and backdated the filing, and that the eviction order had been drawn on papers he knew were false. By the end of it, Hollis had stopped smiling, and the governor's aide was writing so fast his pencil snapped.
The gun boss was brought in under guard, his arm in its sling, and he took the oath with his good hand raised. He looked at Ethan for a long moment before he spoke, and in his face there was no defiance left, only a bleak, spent honesty.
Brandt ordered the dam, Driscoll said. "He ordered the raid. He told me the valley would fold if we hit them hard enough at dawn, and that the paper would hold whatever was left. He was wrong on both counts."
And the claim? Fremont asked.
A forgery, Driscoll said. "I knew it. I rode on it anyway. That is on me."
Fremont was silent for a long time after that. The courtroom held its breath. The bar of light from the high window had moved across the floor and now lay across the judge's desk, across the Accord and the map and the receipt, as if the sun itself were reading the evidence.
"This court finds that the filing of the Frontier Water and Cattle Company for the Dry River spring and valley is void. It was obtained by fraud, by the moving of survey markers, and by the alteration of land-office records. The Dry River Accord of 1868 stands. The spring and the valley belong to the Apache people who live there, as they have since before this territory had a name in any ledger.
Further, this court orders the company to remove the dam and every diversion it built upon the creek, at its own expense, within thirty days, and to restore the water to its natural course. The company will pay restitution for the cattle and goods taken from Cedar Ridge Ranch and from the valley. Warrants will issue for Silas Brandt and for Amos Grady, who will answer for forgery and fraud."""
And Mr. Cole, Fremont said, "your father kept his word for twenty years without ever speaking of it. This court is glad to have finally heard it."
Outside, on the courthouse steps, the light was gold and the air smelled of dust and cottonwood. Tala took Ethan's arm, and Kaya stood on his other side, and Ethan felt the weight of the last five weeks lift off his shoulders all at once, so suddenly that he had to sit down on the top step, and laugh, and then put his face in his hands.
We won, Tala whispered, as if she did not quite believe it.
We won, Ethan said. "The spring is theirs. The water runs. It's over."
But Kaya was already looking toward the road home. "Not over," she said. "Now we rebuild. And Brandt is still out there, running."
Let him run, Ethan said. "The law is coming after him, and the valley is standing. That is enough for today."
The news reached the valley before Ethan did.
It came by telegraph to Juniper Flats, and from there by Pete Aldana on a lathered horse, and Pete told it standing in his saddle in the middle of the settlement, shouting it over the heads of the people who ran out to meet him. The claim was void. The spring belonged to the valley. The dam was to come down.