Cop Cuffed a Black Woman for “Driving a Car Too Nice” — Unaware She Was a Powerful Executive

Chapter 21

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Deputy Jenna Cole, twenty-nine, was interviewed next, and her interview was the one the investigator would later remember most clearly. Cole arrived early, sat down, and asked for a glass of water, and then she told the truth in full, even though she could feel, with every sentence, what it might cost her. She described the stop as she had seen it from the passenger side of the patrol car: the black Mercedes AMG S-Class, the way it had been traveling, the absence of any erratic driving that she had observed, and the thinness of the stated reason for the stop. She described Deputy Tom Whitaker's tone as it hardened, the order to step from the vehicle, and her own unease as the encounter escalated. She said she had wanted to intervene, and that she had not, and she did not dress that failure up as something else. She had been the junior deputy on scene, she said, and she had been afraid of contradicting her senior partner in front of a motorist, and afraid, too, of what a reputation for disloyalty could do to a young deputy's career in a small department. She said she had thought about Faith Anderson afterward, about the calm with which the woman had spoken, and about the fact that she had not learned until later that the woman was a lieutenant general with thirty-four years of service. Cole said that fact should not have mattered, and that it shamed her to realize how much easier it would have been to speak up if she had known. She said the woman's rank had not made the stop wrong; the stop had been wrong on its own terms, and she was sorry she had not said so at the roadside. The investigator asked her whether she understood that her statement could affect her standing in the department, and Cole nodded and said she did, and that she would give the same statement again. When she left the building, she did not look relieved. She looked like someone who had chosen a harder road and knew it.

Whitaker's interview came last among the deputies, and it was longer than the others. Tom Whitaker, forty-one, sat across from the investigator with the posture of a man accustomed to being believed, and he defended himself with the language of instinct and training. He said he had observed something that raised his suspicion, that he had acted on that suspicion as he had been trained to act, and that the handcuffs had been a safety measure rather than a punishment. He said he had not known who Faith Anderson was, and that he would have treated any driver the same way under the same circumstances. The investigator pressed him, gently but persistently, on the specifics: what exactly he had seen, what exactly had justified prolonging the detention, what exactly had justified the cuffs, and why a search had been raised when no contraband had been observed and no consent had been given. Whitaker's answers grew less precise as the questions grew more specific. He fell back on phrases he had used for years, phrases about officer safety and about the unpredictability of roadside encounters, and there was truth in those phrases in the abstract, but the investigator noted, without saying so aloud, that they did not attach themselves cleanly to the facts of this particular night. Whitaker did not raise his voice, and he did not lie outright about the sequence of events; he shaded them, the way people shade events when they are trying to protect both their record and their self-respect. He said he had followed his training, and he believed, or had taught himself to believe, that he had. When the interview ended, he asked whether the complaint would become public, and the investigator told him that the process would follow department policy and the law. Whitaker nodded, thanked him, and left, and no one in the building could tell whether he was angry or frightened, because he had learned to hide both behind the same steady face.

News in the same category

Cop Cuffed a Black Woman for “Driving a Car Too Nice” — Unaware She Was a Powerful Executive

45 Part