"Nice interior," he said, his voice carrying a note of sarcasm. "Leather seats. All the extras. You must have done well for yourself." He said it as if doing well were itself suspicious, as if success required an explanation that a person like Faith owed to a stranger in a uniform. She did not answer the taunt. She stood with her shoulders back, her chin level, her breathing even, and she waited for him to return to the actual business of the stop, if there was any.
From the patrol car, the second deputy emerged, younger, quieter, a woman of twenty-nine with a face that had not yet hardened into the mask her partner wore. Deputy Jenna Cole, twenty-nine years old, walked toward them with steps that were slower than Whitaker's, more hesitant, as if she were approaching a situation she was not sure she wanted to be part of. She stood a few feet back, her hands at her sides, her eyes moving between Whitaker and Faith, and Faith noticed the uncertainty in her expression immediately. It was the look of someone who had been trained to follow orders and was beginning to wonder, in real time, whether the orders she was witnessing were right.
Whitaker turned to her, holding Faith's license and registration as if they were evidence. "She says it's hers," he said, with a laugh that held no humor. "Says she bought it herself. You believe that? A car like this, out here, with her driving?" Jenna Cole did not laugh. She looked at the papers, then at Faith, then back at Whitaker, and her brow furrowed slightly. "Tom," she said quietly, her voice low enough that it was almost a murmur, "the registration matches the license. The name is the same. The insurance is current. I don't see a problem with the paperwork." She said it carefully, as if she were offering an observation rather than a challenge, and Faith appreciated the distinction. Jenna Cole was not defending her, exactly. She was stating a fact, and in a situation where facts were being ignored, stating a fact felt like a small act of courage.
Whitaker's jaw tightened. "The paperwork can be faked," he said, dismissively, waving a hand as if the documents in his own hand meant nothing. "Anybody can print paperwork. That doesn't make the car hers. I want to check the vehicle identification number, and I want to look in the trunk. If she's got nothing to hide, she won't mind." He turned back to Faith, his eyes narrowing. "You mind if I look in the trunk?"
Faith met his gaze directly, without flinching, without looking away. She thought of what was in the trunk, the gift wrapped in flowered paper, the cake she had baked with such care, her father's Bible wrapped in cloth, all of them innocent, all of them precious, all of them none of this man's business unless he had a lawful reason to look. She kept her voice calm, even, and respectful, the voice she used when she needed to be clear without being confrontational. "Deputy, I do not consent to a search of my car or my trunk," she said. "My documents are valid, I have committed no violation that you have told me about, and I would like to know the reason I was stopped before we discuss a search. I am happy to cooperate with a lawful order, but I am asking, respectfully, that you state the basis for this stop."
The refusal, polite as it was, seemed to ignite something in Whitaker. His face darkened, and he stepped closer to her, invading the space she had been holding with such discipline. "You refusing a lawful order?" he demanded, his voice rising. "You think you can tell me what I can and can't do on my road? I don't need your permission to do my job. I can search this car if I have reason to believe it's stolen, and right now I have plenty of reason." He gestured again at the Mercedes, as if the car itself were the reason, as if its value were probable cause. "A car this nice doesn't just show up on a back road in Louisa County without somebody asking questions. So I'm asking questions, and you're going to answer them, or this is going to get a lot harder for you."
Faith did not step back. She held her ground, not aggressively, but firmly, the way a person stands when they know their rights and intend to exercise them without surrendering their dignity to do so. "I am not refusing a lawful order, Deputy," she said, her voice still steady, though she could feel her heart beating faster now, not from fear but from the effort of remaining calm while being treated as a suspect for no reason she could discern. "I am asking for the reason for the stop, and I am stating that I do not consent to a search. Those are my rights, and I am exercising them respectfully. If you have a lawful basis to search, I would ask you to state it. If you do not, I would ask to be allowed to continue on my way."