Cop Cuffed a Black Woman for “Driving a Car Too Nice” — Unaware She Was a Powerful Executive

Chapter 27

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The stop, they told her, was unlawful in its detention and in its handcuffing. The initial stop itself had been examined against the stated justification, and the detention had been prolonged beyond what that justification could support, without the additional facts that the law and department policy required for such a prolongation. The decision to order Faith Anderson from her vehicle and to place her in handcuffs had not been supported by the circumstances as established by the record: there had been no observed conduct that justified that level of restraint, no articulated threat that matched the response, and no explanation in the contemporaneous record that filled the gap between what had been seen and what had been done. The handcuffs, in particular, had transformed a traffic encounter into a detention of a different character, and the review found that transformation unjustified. The officials did not describe this finding as a technicality, and Faith was grateful for that, because it was not a technicality to the person standing handcuffed beside a road at night. It was the core of what had happened, and naming it plainly was the first step toward addressing it.

They told her, further, that the search threat had been improper. No consent had been given, no lawful basis for a search had been established on the facts known at the time, and the raising of a search in that context had been coercive in its effect, even if the search itself had not ultimately been carried out. The review found that a citizen in Faith's position could reasonably have understood the mention of a search as pressure to comply with an expanding encounter, and that department policy did not permit such pressure to substitute for lawful justification. They also addressed the recording gaps, finding that the late activation of a body camera and the incomplete dashcam coverage had violated policy in part and had hindered the review, and they recommended corrective training and supervision on recording, separate from any discipline arising from the stop itself. They addressed the pattern as well, finding that the prior stops of Black drivers in expensive cars, with thin justification and complaints closed without findings, constituted a pattern that required supervisory review and a re-examination of those closed files, and that the department's failure to identify that pattern earlier was a systemic shortcoming, not merely an individual one. Sergeant Price's conduct on the night was found to have been corrective once he arrived, but his prior supervision was noted as an area for improvement, and Deputy Cole's candor was noted in the record with the respect it deserved, along with a recommendation that no adverse action be taken against her for telling the truth.

Finally, they told Faith that a formal hearing had been scheduled. The hearing would consider the findings, would hear from the parties as the process allowed, and would determine the appropriate discipline and corrective measures for Whitaker, as well as any broader measures arising from the systemic findings. They gave her the date and the procedure, they explained her rights as a complainant to be present and to be heard within the limits of that procedure, and they told her that she would receive the hearing's outcome in writing. They did not promise her a particular outcome, and she did not ask for one. She thanked them for the thoroughness of the review, for the honesty about the gaps, and for the care with which they had treated the prior drivers whose statements had given the pattern its human shape. She asked only that the department contact Denise Harper and Marcus Bell and Angela Ross directly, to tell them what had been found and what would happen next, because they had deserved a call years earlier and they deserved one now. The officials agreed, and they noted her request in the file.

News in the same category

Cop Cuffed a Black Woman for “Driving a Car Too Nice” — Unaware She Was a Powerful Executive

45 Part