Then she looked toward the neighboring houses.
“Come inside.”
Her kitchen smelled of cinnamon and freshly baked bread.
Helen closed the curtains before sitting down.
Maya noticed.
“Are you concerned someone might see us?”
Helen folded her hands.
“I've been concerned about that for years.”
“Tell me why.”
Helen stared at the table.
“When I worked in records, complaints came through several channels. Some were submitted in person. Some arrived by mail. Others came through supervisors.”
Maya nodded.
“Those procedures are documented.”
“The official procedures are.”
“What happened outside them?”
Helen swallowed.
“There was another process.”
Maya waited.
Helen continued.
“When certain complaints involved officers considered valuable to the department, they weren't always entered into the tracking system immediately.”
“Who decided that?”
“Supervisors.”
“Which supervisors?”
Helen looked at her.
“Richard Halden was one of them.”
Maya opened her notebook.
“What happened to those complaints?”
“Some were reviewed informally. Some were returned to the complainants. Others were placed in blue folders.”
“Why blue?”
“That was simply the color of the folders we used for pending administrative correspondence.”
“And where were they stored?”
Helen hesitated.
“In a locked cabinet near the old records office.”
Maya felt her attention sharpen.
“Do those folders still exist?”
“I don't know.”
“When did you last see them?”
“About three months before I retired.”
“Who had access?”
Helen looked away.
“Halden. The records supervisor. A few senior administrators.”
Maya leaned forward.
“Mrs. Brooks, why didn't you mention this during our earlier interviews?”
Helen's eyes filled with tears.
“Because I was afraid.”
“Of Halden?”
“Of what would happen if I accused the department of hiding complaints and couldn't prove it.”
Maya waited.
Helen reached into her handbag and removed a small envelope.
Inside was an old photograph.
It showed a filing cabinet with several blue folders arranged on a shelf.
Maya examined it.
“Where did this come from?”
“I took it before I retired.”
“Why?”
“Because I thought someone might eventually need to know those files existed.”
Maya looked at the photograph again.
On the top folder, a handwritten label was partially visible.
The name was unmistakable.
VANCE, MARK.
Carter convened an emergency meeting the following afternoon.
Maya placed the photograph on the conference table.
Leah Morgan examined it.
“Can we establish when it was taken?”
“Helen says she still has the original image file,” Maya replied.
“Good. We'll need to preserve that.”
Thomas Reed studied the cabinet.
“I recognize the room.”
Maya turned.
“From what?”
“Old departmental floor plans. The records office was relocated during a renovation.”
“Where did the files go?”
“That's what we need to find out.”
Carter looked at Maya.
“What else did Brooks tell you?”
“She believes some complaints were diverted before formal registration.”
“Believes?”
“She personally handled several folders, but she doesn't know what happened after they left her office.”
“Then we need corroboration.”
Morgan nodded.
“I can compare correspondence logs, complaint numbers, and archived administrative records.”
Reed added, “And I can review the department's document migration records.”
Carter looked around the table.
“Proceed through the proper channels. No shortcuts.”
Maya understood why he emphasized that point.
The first investigation had succeeded because the team had distinguished suspicion from proof.
The second investigation would require the same discipline.
But the potential implications were serious.
If complaints had been deliberately kept outside the official tracking system, the public record of officer misconduct might be incomplete.
And if that practice extended beyond Vance, the department's problems could be far larger than anyone had admitted.
Richard Halden was eating breakfast when he saw the news report.
The television above the diner counter showed a photograph of the Bellhaven Police Department.
A reporter explained that federal investigators were examining additional administrative records connected to earlier misconduct allegations.
Halden lowered his coffee cup.
The waitress approached.
“Everything all right, Lieutenant?”
“Fine.”
He had retired from the department shortly after Vance was placed on administrative leave.
His retirement had been described publicly as a personal decision.
Privately, Halden had expected investigators to examine his complaint reviews.
He had prepared explanations.
He had consulted an attorney.
He had convinced himself that his decisions were defensible.
But the news report mentioned missing complaints.
Halden stared at the screen.
He knew exactly what that meant.
For years, he had told himself that informal complaint reviews were a practical necessity.
The department was understaffed.
Supervisors were overwhelmed.
Some complaints were incomplete.
Others involved disagreements that could be resolved without formal investigation.
Those explanations had gradually become habits.
And habits had become a system.
At first, Halden had believed he was protecting the department from unnecessary controversy.