Maya showed her the photograph.
Margaret examined it.
“I remember that meeting.”
Maya leaned forward.
“You were there?”
“Yes.”
“Can you identify the people?”
Margaret pointed to Warren, Halden, and Cross.
Then she indicated the woman taking notes.
“That's me.”
Maya looked at the photograph again.
“Do you remember what the meeting concerned?”
Margaret hesitated.
“Several pending complaints.”
“Against whom?”
“I don't remember every name.”
“Was Mark Vance discussed?”
“Yes.”
Maya kept her voice neutral.
“What was your role?”
“I was responsible for preparing administrative summaries.”
“Were minutes taken?”
Margaret looked at the photograph.
“Yes.”
“Do you know where they are?”
“No.”
“Were they placed in the official records system?”
“They should have been.”
Maya waited.
Margaret looked toward the café entrance.
Then she said, “There was a disagreement about how much information should be retained.”
“Between whom?”
“Cross and me.”
“What was the disagreement?”
Margaret folded her hands.
“I believed that documents should be preserved according to the applicable retention requirements. Cross was concerned that informal notes could be misunderstood if released without context.”
“Did he instruct you to destroy anything?”
“No.”
“Did he instruct you to alter anything?”
“No.”
Maya nodded.
“Then what happened?”
“Some meeting notes were consolidated into summaries. I wasn't comfortable with how much detail was omitted.”
“Did you raise that concern?”
“Yes.”
“With Cross?”
“And my supervisor.”
“What did they say?”
“That the summaries were sufficient.”
Maya studied her.
“Do you still have copies?”
Margaret looked down.
“I retained some records that I was permitted to keep, including correspondence about my concerns. I didn't take confidential client files when I left.”
“Would you be willing to identify those records through the proper process?”
Margaret nodded.
“Yes.”
For the first time, Maya had something more substantial than an anonymous photograph.
A former employee had described a specific disagreement about record preservation.
It still did not establish criminal misconduct.
But it justified asking whether the official records accurately reflected the meetings.
Two days later, Maya brought the information to Marquez.
Her supervisor read the summary.
Then she asked, “Did Sloan allege intentional destruction?”
“No.”
“Alteration?”
“No.”
“False statements?”
“She described omissions from summaries, but she hasn't established that the omissions were unlawful.”
Marquez nodded.
“That's an important distinction.”
“I agree.”
“Have you reviewed the city's retention policy from that period?”
“Not yet.”
“Then do that.”
Maya looked up.
Marquez continued.
“And coordinate with the appropriate legal personnel before seeking privileged or confidential materials.”
Maya nodded.
“Understood.”
Marquez closed the folder.
“I'm authorizing a limited preliminary assessment. Nothing more.”
“Thank you.”
“Don't thank me yet.”
Marquez leaned forward.
“If the evidence doesn't support further inquiry, we stop.”
Maya met her eyes.
“Agreed.”
The preliminary assessment lasted seven weeks.
Most of the work was ordinary.
Public records requests.
Policy comparisons.
Interviews conducted through authorized channels.
Review of court filings.
Examination of document retention schedules.
There were no dramatic confrontations.
No secret meetings in dark parking garages.
No sudden confessions.
But the records revealed something important.
During several years of Bellhaven's history, the city attorney's office had used different procedures for preserving informal meeting notes.
Some documents were retained in central archives.
Others remained in individual departmental files.
Some summaries referenced attachments that could no longer be located.
The gaps did not automatically prove misconduct.
Records could be misplaced through negligence, poor organization, or routine administrative failures.
But they made it difficult to reconstruct how certain decisions had been made.
Maya and her team identified six meetings involving police complaints for which the available summaries appeared incomplete.
Three involved Mark Vance.
Two involved Edward Warren.
One concerned a broader discussion of complaint classification.
Nathaniel Cross had attended all six.
So had Margaret Sloan.
And in four of the meetings, Richard Halden was listed as a participant.
Maya placed the records on a conference table.
Marquez examined them.
“What's your conclusion?”
“That the recordkeeping process was inconsistent and may have affected later reviews.”
“Do you have evidence Cross intentionally concealed information?”
“No.”
“Then don't write that he did.”
“I haven't.”
Marquez nodded.
“Good.”
Maya looked at the documents.
“But there may be people who remember what was discussed.”
“Then identify them.”
The first witness was a retired municipal administrator named Paul Whitaker.
He had attended one of the meetings as a representative of the city manager's office.
Whitaker remembered the discussion because it had become unusually tense.
According to him, the meeting concerned a series of complaints against Vance.
Halden argued that the allegations lacked sufficient evidence.
Margaret Sloan questioned whether the underlying records were complete.
Cross advised the city to avoid making conclusions until the legal issues were reviewed.