Warren wanted the matter resolved quickly.
“Did anyone propose destroying records?” Maya asked.
“No.”
“Did anyone suggest changing a complaint finding?”
“Not that I remember.”
“Then what concerned you?”
Whitaker looked down.
“The attitude.”
“What attitude?”
“That the complaints themselves were the problem.”
Maya waited.
Whitaker continued.
“People kept talking about how the allegations might damage the department's reputation. I don't remember much discussion about whether the allegations were true.”
“Did you raise that concern?”
“No.”
“Why not?”
Whitaker gave a tired smile.
“I was a junior administrator. I didn't think anyone wanted my opinion.”
Maya wrote the answer.
It was another familiar explanation.
People had noticed problems.
But too many had decided that speaking up was someone else's responsibility.
The second witness was less cooperative.
Former assistant city manager Gregory Lane agreed to an interview but arrived with an attorney.
He denied remembering most of the meetings.
He described the complaint process as ordinary.
He insisted that no one had intentionally concealed evidence.
When Maya asked about missing attachments, he said he had no knowledge of them.
The interview ended without a breakthrough.
But three days later, Lane's attorney contacted the investigators.
His client had located an old calendar entry.
Attached to it was a memorandum prepared before one of the disputed meetings.
The memorandum identified concerns about missing camera recordings and inconsistent arrest reports.
It also recommended that the city obtain an independent assessment.
The recommendation had not appeared in the final meeting summary.
Maya examined the document.
“Who prepared this?” she asked.
The signature belonged to Paul Whitaker.
The same administrator who had described the meeting's atmosphere.
The omission was significant.
But the question remained whether it had been deliberate.
Nathaniel Cross agreed to a formal interview after several weeks of correspondence through counsel.
He arrived at the federal building wearing a navy suit.
His attorney sat beside him.
Maya and Marquez conducted the interview.
Cross acknowledged attending the meetings.
He explained that his role had been to advise the city about legal exposure and procedural requirements.
He denied instructing anyone to destroy evidence or falsify records.
Maya showed him Whitaker's memorandum.
“Do you remember reviewing this?”
Cross examined it.
“I may have.”
“Why wasn't the recommendation for independent review included in the final summary?”
“I didn't prepare the final summary.”
“Did you approve it?”
“I reviewed portions of it.”
“Did you notice the recommendation was missing?”
“I don't recall.”
Maya paused.
“Would you agree that the recommendation was relevant to the meeting's purpose?”
Cross looked at the memorandum again.
“Yes.”
“Then why was it omitted?”
His attorney leaned forward.
Cross answered carefully.
“I can't explain a drafting decision I don't remember making.”
Maya nodded.
“Did you ever advise the city to conceal complaints?”
“No.”
“Did you ever instruct employees to remove relevant facts from official records?”
“No.”
“Did you ever knowingly provide false information to a court?”
“Absolutely not.”
Maya studied him.
She had no basis to challenge those denials without further evidence.
So she moved to the next question.
“Mr. Cross, do you believe the city handled those complaints appropriately?”
For the first time, he hesitated.
“I believe the city made decisions based on the information available.”
“That wasn't my question.”
Cross looked toward his attorney.
Then he answered.
“With what I know now, I believe some matters should have received independent review.”
Maya waited.
Cross continued.
“I can acknowledge that without admitting I committed misconduct.”
“Yes,” Maya said. “You can.”
The interview ended after two hours.
Cross left without making any dramatic admission.
Marquez reviewed the notes.
“What do you think?” she asked.
Maya considered her answer.
“He was defensive.”
“That isn't evidence.”
“I know.”
“He acknowledged some decisions were poor.”
“Yes.”
“Did he admit wrongdoing?”
“No.”
“Did we establish a criminal violation?”
“No.”
Marquez closed the folder.
“Then we follow the evidence we have.”
Maya nodded.
She had expected the interview to be difficult.
What surprised her was how ordinary Cross seemed.
He was not a theatrical villain.
He did not boast about controlling the city.
He did not threaten witnesses.
He was a lawyer who had spent years making decisions within an institution that prioritized avoiding liability.
Some of those decisions might have been lawful.
Some might have been negligent.
Some might have contributed to a culture of secrecy.
But Maya could not transform uncertainty into certainty simply because the story would be more satisfying that way.
The facts had to determine the outcome.
The anonymous messages stopped.
For nearly two months, Maya heard nothing from the unknown sender.
The preliminary assessment continued, but no evidence emerged establishing that Cross had knowingly falsified records.